Story and J-Roll vs Did
-
Trevor is superior to both
-
@Ikasnu said in Story and J-Roll vs Did:
Trevor is superior to both
Looks like Story doesn’t have quite as high of stealing as Rollins and gold instead of diamond defense but a better arm and more power. I was leaning to Story also because I desperately need a righty.
-
@zach_b25 said in Story and J-Roll vs Did:
@Ikasnu said in Story and J-Roll vs Did:
Trevor is superior to both
Looks like Story doesn’t have quite as high of stealing as Rollins and gold instead of diamond defense but a better arm and more power. I was leaning to Story also because I desperately need a righty.
He's the best, bro.
-
@Ikasnu said in Story and J-Roll vs Did:
@zach_b25 said in Story and J-Roll vs Did:
@Ikasnu said in Story and J-Roll vs Did:
Trevor is superior to both
Looks like Story doesn’t have quite as high of stealing as Rollins and gold instead of diamond defense but a better arm and more power. I was leaning to Story also because I desperately need a righty.
He's the best, bro.
Just got MVP Trout tonight so I don’t even need to lock in Story
-
@zach_b25 said in Story and J-Roll vs Did:
@Ikasnu said in Story and J-Roll vs Did:
Trevor is superior to both
Looks like Story doesn’t have quite as high of stealing as Rollins and gold instead of diamond defense but a better arm and more power. I was leaning to Story also because I desperately need a righty.
Rollins > Story
Switch hitter, better speed, better defense, better contact and better bunter in a pinch as needed, his power plays well above his stats from BOTH SIDES. Surprised it's even debatable.
-
Rollins is the goat at SS , didi better bat but I have him at second. Both are staples of my squad
-
The hardest thing about this game is for anyone to say who's the best! We all play different with different cards and swings! So far at SS my favorite is jimmy rollins! But he lacks power! Great all around SS! Potm free correa is very good ! But isn't amazing vs LHP. Larkin is [censored]!! But alot like larkin! Story just isn't good enough vs RHP!! And isnt as good fielding as rollins! Banks is solid but I don't like his swing! For me its not smooth! Plus he's 110k or more!
In my opinion the best SS is Your CAP!! 2 is rollins! 3rd correa and or didi !!
-
@zach_b25 said in Story and J-Roll vs Did:
Currently have prestige Didi as my primary SS. Just got MVP trout so I’m in the market for a different SS. Story or Rollins? I’m only the pepper map away from the boss pack because I’m slowly becoming a casual. Get both, get neither, or do whatever I want because this is just a video game?
Do a cap at SS and sell the boss cards. Get the best equipment possible. They are all cheap now. Cap is easily the best SS available.
-
Both Story and Rollins can play 2B well as FYI. Even though out of position, the penalty isn't all that high (you can see for yourself). Gives more flexibility if you have a few guys you are rotating like I am (Banks/Story/Rollins/J-Ram)
-
Jimmy Rollins is by far the Worst Short Stop i've ever used Defensively. Maybe it's the game itself and not him, but I've had too many looping fly balls and grounders not hit directly at him go for base hits because he just stops running aggressively for the ball. Like just gives up on it. His speed is nice on the base paths, but I'd rather have Didi or HRD Cal there. Haven't used the Awards Story yet.
-
@DoIHearBossMusic said in Story and J-Roll vs Did:
@zach_b25 said in Story and J-Roll vs Did:
@Ikasnu said in Story and J-Roll vs Did:
Trevor is superior to both
Looks like Story doesn’t have quite as high of stealing as Rollins and gold instead of diamond defense but a better arm and more power. I was leaning to Story also because I desperately need a righty.
Rollins > Story
Switch hitter, better speed, better defense, better contact and better bunter in a pinch as needed, his power plays well above his stats from BOTH SIDES. Surprised it's even debatable.
Nope nope. Trevor > Every SS in the game. Hands down.
You also know I'm heavily biased.
-
Trevor is basically Prestige Chipper but with better defense and a lot of speed. His price in the market has shot up and think people are finally figuring out that, well, he's really good.....
-
@GixxerRyder750 said in Story and J-Roll vs Did:
Jimmy Rollins is by far the Worst Short Stop i've ever used Defensively. Maybe it's the game itself and not him, but I've had too many looping fly balls and grounders not hit directly at him go for base hits because he just stops running aggressively for the ball. Like just gives up on it. His speed is nice on the base paths, but I'd rather have Didi or HRD Cal there. Haven't used the Awards Story yet.
Really? I haven’t had that experience with him at all. But what you’re describing is exactly what I experienced with Barry Larkin, including his prestige card.
For me, J-Roll is the best SS in the game. Defense and baserunning have been great, and I’ve even hit above his attributes so far. I’m looking forward to the prestige version.
-
So far I can't consistently hit with Rollins. Was just thinking maybe selling him off for Trevor Story Awards series.
-
@maurice91932 said in Story and J-Roll vs Did:
@GixxerRyder750 said in Story and J-Roll vs Did:
Jimmy Rollins is by far the Worst Short Stop i've ever used Defensively. Maybe it's the game itself and not him, but I've had too many looping fly balls and grounders not hit directly at him go for base hits because he just stops running aggressively for the ball. Like just gives up on it. His speed is nice on the base paths, but I'd rather have Didi or HRD Cal there. Haven't used the Awards Story yet.
Really? I haven’t had that experience with him at all. But what you’re describing is exactly what I experienced with Barry Larkin, including his prestige card.
For me, J-Roll is the best SS in the game. Defense and baserunning have been great, and I’ve even hit above his attributes so far. I’m looking forward to the prestige version.
Rollins is the best SS so far
-
@high-heat-27 said in Story and J-Roll vs Did:
The hardest thing about this game is for anyone to say who's the best! We all play different with different cards and swings! So far at SS my favorite is jimmy rollins! But he lacks power! Great all around SS! Potm free correa is very good ! But isn't amazing vs LHP. Larkin is [censored]!! But alot like larkin! Story just isn't good enough vs RHP!! And isnt as good fielding as rollins! Banks is solid but I don't like his swing! For me its not smooth! Plus he's 110k or more!
In my opinion the best SS is Your CAP!! 2 is rollins! 3rd correa and or didi !!
CAPs are for RTTS
-
@Catman9186 said in Story and J-Roll vs Did:
So far I can't consistently hit with Rollins. Was just thinking maybe selling him off for Trevor Story Awards series.
I can't his with him either but I locked him in for the voucher (sold Harper for ~$240K so it was worth it) so I'm stubborn and will keep rolling him out at 2B (have Banks at SS). Really love Jimmy but struggling to hit as well and hard to justify playing him.
-
I chose Rollins as my pick and his D is legit endgame but I couldn't really hit with him so I sold him. I bought Alan Trammall to try him out until I get Didi finished and he is a way better hitter but noticeable difference on defense. Basic nut shell response. If you need or prioritize defense get Rollins. If you need some hitting get any other high diamond SS. Im personally just switching guys in and out until Tatis comes out which should be soon
-
A admin locked this topic on
