3-1 on my second attempt.
First attempt I restarted when, with Mantle on first, I get David Ortiz to hit a dribbler in front of the plate. Posey picks it up and proceeds to overthrow the first baseman and the ball goes to the wall letting Mantle score. I have the throwing mode where I simply hit the proper base button so it should have been using his stats for the throw.
Second attempt with the score tied 1-1 (curse Larry Walker who hit their HR) I managed to get two guys on (2 walks or a walk and a hit batsman) Correa, I think it was, hit a line drive to center. The CF dove and missed it but I could not score so the bases were loaded. Nolan Gorman then hit a two out single to drive in 2. Rollie Fingers closed out the final 3 innings. I held the other team to 4 hits.