Rickey or Fingers?

What does everyone suggest for pick and why?

Rickey sux

fingers and it is not even close

I would go Fingers, he's a beast in the bullpen.

Rickey is very disappointing.

Definitely fingers 100%

Tons of good outfielders and some to be had for free like trammel and marsh from the TA programs.

Not as many high end relievers like fingers, and the ones that are out cost a bunch on the market.

Rollie fingers lickin good. Rickey is not the same from last year version.

I had a feeling but shocked Rickey isn’t good oh well

They did Rick dirty with that trash [censored] card, just avoid till the end

Fingers then Orel.

@SchnauzerFace said in Rickey or Fingers?:

Fingers then Orel.

Ty BUTTrey has some dirty STUFF too.

@pbake12 said in Rickey or Fingers?:

@SchnauzerFace said in Rickey or Fingers?:

Fingers then Orel.

Ty BUTTrey has some dirty STUFF too.

Oh yeah, that’s a good point. Fingers—>Orel is standard, but you need the coach’s OK before going Orel-Buttrey. Fingers-Buttrey seems like a case-by-case basis.

Rickey will be the last one I’m taking unfortunately

I took Rickey first and regretted it pretty fast. Like others have said, it’s not even close to the 99 SS Rickey from last year. I should have known better — everyone said to take Kluber or Fingers but I stupidly picked Rickey anyway.

But I guess this is my new trend on the high diamond rewards. Last year, the overall consensus was to take Kershaw or Ryan first. Even knowing that, I took....Alan freaking trammel. lol.

Ricky is buns make him ur last pick

@nymets1987 said in Rickey or Fingers?:

What does everyone suggest for pick and why?

Rickey swings a noodle. Go Rollie

Yeah, even vs LHP Rickey is a let down. Fingers is filthy.

I’m a Rickey fan, so I picked him first. I wasn’t really expecting much, but he is hitting over .330, and for me, that’s really good. Also, He’s great in center field. I’m proud of you, Rickey. You’re the greatest of all time.

I've really struggled with Fingers, any suggestions on pitching with him?

Rickey has an awful swing.

@ImDFC said in Rickey or Fingers?:

Rickey has an awful swing.

You are not wrong, but I’ve found that if you keep your pci on top of the ball, he fares much better. Against righties, He’ll hit a lot of liners and grounders up the middle. And against lefties, well let’s face it, there are no lefties so I don’t know.

@risk712 said in Rickey or Fingers?:

I've really struggled with Fingers, any suggestions on pitching with him?

That’s on you brah. He is 2-0 with 14 saves and a 0.25 ERA for me. The guy is a stud on the mound.

@risk712 said in Rickey or Fingers?:

I've really struggled with Fingers, any suggestions on pitching with him?

People sit on the sinker. Don't forget that he has a 4 seamer.

See that thread about not blowing late game leads? It was probably written by someone who took Ricky over Fingers.