Who would you choose and why?
Larkin because he rips
Reggie, because he's one of the very best cards in the game, regardless of position. Larkin might not even be the best Shortstop
Of those two, Reggie. Of that pack, Posey.
Reggie is great now, but better OF cards will be out before long. But I think Posey might actually be endgame. If you've got a CAP at catcher who you're married to, throw Posey at 1st.
Reggie and it's not even close. I have both. I love both. But Reggie is my best hitter and he hits absolute bombs
Reggie, far more dangerous than Larkin.