Cobb or Mays or Griffey Jr in CF?
-
I used to have 99 Cobb but sold him when I obtained 99 Mays. I also have 99 Griffey. I have not been hitting as well with Mays as either Cobb or Griffey, perhaps because I face more righty pitching..
What's your opinion as to the best CF in the game?
-
I really like Griffey, but others have had issues with him. His bat is insane though. Overall, probably try Mays first and see if you can get the hang of his swing, I use him off the bench for lefties and a pinch runner.
-
mike trout has been very good for me if you can hit with a smaller PCI. he has more power against righties which is nice.
-
Mays with Cobb a close second. Mays has the range ,reaction and speed with a strong arm. Griffey Jr plays better defensively for me in RF/LF. I've read alot about his defensive errors here, so he is prone to the misplay.
My A team defensively is Mays CF, Cobb LF and Griffey/Dawson RF platoon -
If I'm going off my personal gameplay experience I'd rank them Griffey, Cobb, Trout, Mays in that order. I haven't experienced the same offensive success with Mays as many others, nor have I experienced the same defensive issues with Griffey (I can't remember one animation-related issue).
-
A few weeks ago I would have said Mays no question. Then I started slumping with Mays and moved Cobb from LF to CF. Cobb’s pure speed make him the only CF in Mays league. His [censored] arm isn’t as much a liability either.
Griffey has that weird animation in CF not as much in RF.
When you are hitting well with him Mays is the easy choice. If not Cobb is the best 4 tool player in the game
-
If I had to rank these center fielders for my team with an addition it would be mays trout Griffey Cobb.
-
Mays in center, I play griffey in right field and belli in left. I haven’t had one error since moving Griffey to roght
-
@pfcorporate said in Cobb or Mays or Griffey Jr in CF?:
If I had to rank these center fielders for my team with an addition it would be mays trout Griffey Cobb
Trout? Really? I was on the verge of selling him but there just aren’t any cards I am I retested in buying.
-
@Maverick31762 said in Cobb or Mays or Griffey Jr in CF?:
@pfcorporate said in Cobb or Mays or Griffey Jr in CF?:
If I had to rank these center fielders for my team with an addition it would be mays trout Griffey Cobb
Trout? Really? I was on the verge of selling him but there just aren’t any cards I am I retested in buying.
Yes I still think mays is the best but there are quite a few games where I want to get another lefty bat in the outfield and a lot of times I will bench mays and keep trout in the lineup to put in Williams or Ruth.
-
Mays is the best..
-
Griffey’s bats insane
-
Mays is the best player in the game. Simple.
-
Griffey hasnt made any errors for me in the field I have him in LF has his accuracy and fielding are still great with Mays in CF and Ichiro in RF. Ichiro may not have the power but has the speed to get him to extra bases and I have him at the top of my order. I like to have the fast guys batting 1-2-3 so when the 4-5-6 the pitcher has to watch out for a bomb.
-
Griffey, Mays, Belli is my outfield. Griffey is my best bat but Mays is giving him a run for his money and I like his defensive style better. I dont know what it is but I feel I track better.
-
Yes I know tracking is not different with players....it's my mind but I still feel that way....call it my mental flaw LOL.
-
People are sleeping on Cobb
-
If you've only got room for one, Mays without a doubt.
-
@Maverick31762 said in Cobb or Mays or Griffey Jr in CF?:
People are sleeping on Cobb
Nobody is sleeping on him, he's just not as good as Mays or Griffey
-
@skepple15 said in Cobb or Mays or Griffey Jr in CF?:
@Maverick31762 said in Cobb or Mays or Griffey Jr in CF?:
People are sleeping on Cobb
Nobody is sleeping on him, he's just not as good as Mays or Griffey
That thought is an example of sleeping on him. You can sit down now sir.
