New ideas for MLB27
-
@Jamiesalmons687_XBL I mentioned getting announcers in a post recently though I suggested making them captains but including their signature phrase which would make the thing a little less expensive if they were to try. Hope they do something similar along these lines.
-
Some ideas for MLB The Show 27: let's start by making the game look like it was developed sometime within the last decade. The graphics have felt largely unchanged for years, and the series is overdue for a noticeable visual upgrade.
While you're at it, expand the soundtrack. I've played MLB The Show 25 enough that I could probably sing half the songs from memory. It feels like the game cycles through the same handful of tracks over and over again, and the repetition gets old fast.
And please do something about the menus. They're not just dated, they feel ancient. The entire user interface could use a complete modernization to make navigating the game smoother and more enjoyable.
Finally, give players the option to disable the automatic runner on second base in extra innings. Whether people like the rule in real life or not, it should be a customizable setting in franchise and Road to the Show. As someone who enjoys playing as a closer in RTTS, it's frustrating to enter a game already dealing with a runner in scoring position because of a rule that's completely outside of my control. -
Why are we not getting any Roberto Alomar, Omar Vizquel and Carlos Baerga cards?
Also, how come MLB has the best hitter award named after the best DH Edgar Martinez and the best card we got for him is a 91 overall?
-
If they improve the graphics then they have to improve the graphics engine. My gameplay can get stuttery even in offline modes in certain situations.
Everybody wants new features and I do too but honestly, as I have said before, fix the long-standing bugs like disappearing logos that have been around for years
Redesign the vaults so that users don't have to reupload a stadium if they have made no changes. Eliminate all the duplicates and make them easier to moderate.
Stop making your content team work on two games at once. I can't speak for the mobile game but this game's content suffered for it.
There is much more on my wishlist but the bottom line is polish what you have before you add more unpolished details later
-
What SDS needs to do in order to recapture their once undisputed place as the best sports video game on the market:
-
Physics based game engine where the human player's game control inputs rein supreme in terms of the quality of pitches, hits, and fielding. Eliminate pre-determined outcomes by eliminating RNG logic. Baseball is a simple game of physics and begs for a video game that leverages this reality. Game pad inputs should determine the location, spin rate, and velocity of a pitch. The hit should be solely determined by the actual physics of the bat to ball contact, influenced by the weather conditions. Yes, the difficulty levels should tailor the effective size of the bat's sweet spot and ease of pitch effect, but the outcomes should remain entirely physics based.
-
Upgrade the game's graphics, not merely in terms of the quality of graphics to leverage true 4K resolution, but more important also sees the environment have true effect on the play on the field. Examples of this would be when raining, to see the field puddle, especially in the outfield, causing balls to hydroplane, or experience mud influenced drag on grounders through the infield, as well as slow runners down. Uniforms should show evidence of saturation and batting helmets and hats should show drips off the brims.
-
True AI commentary, ending the use of pre-recorded audio statements brought up by game code. Instead, each play should organically result in originally compiled commentator audio to ensure that it is timely and accurate to what is happening. This means when the color commentator starts a long-winded statement, he shuts up immediately if an important play is developing, and the main commentator immediately describes it.
-
In RTTS, eliminate the restrictions on equipment, making all equipment in the game freely available and having zero influence on the avatar player's performance level. Performance levels should be strictly limited to the quality of the on-the-field performance, interactions with teammates, coaches, manager and the press. Interviews with the press and coaches and manager should be audio based and present the human player with key options in reply that each carry meaningful impact of the player's development and image within the public, press, and team.
-
Customer driven custom content must be a major focus for improvement, not merely to Stadium Creator, but also Uniform Creator and Logo Editor. These three modes have been horribly neglected. With this should also be the option to finally be able to change the uniforms, logos, and branding for all 30 teams during each offseason in Franchise, and not limit this to merely the team you are the GM for.
-
Baseball carries the richest history of any American sport. This should be reflected in how the game can be played. Allow customers to tailor their Franchise teams for different eras of the game and be allowed to create uniforms and stadiums that accurately reflect these historic periods and make their Franchise experience an equally rich historic expression. This should go hand-in-hand with not only expanding the collegiate experience in RTTS, but also allowing the Negro Leagues to become the theme within Franchise, complete with historically accurate uniforms and stadiums.
-
-
How about having better fan reactions, especially during the post season?
-
It would be awesome if your player wins MVP, they get a year taken off their rookie contract. Six years is brutal. MLB supposedly does this.
-
Regarding AI: I don't think it computes or generates speech fast enough to create dynamic commentary with emotion and inflection on the fly, especially on current hardware.
It made great leaps in recent years but I am not sure it is at a point where it would sound smooth or natural yet
-
@baseball-gig16_PSN a-rod, bonds. I know those 2 are a big ask they would probably never give there rights but more options. Mark texeria, Josh Hamilton, nomar, Miguel tejada, Robinson Cano, Andres gallaraga. Plenty of legends out there that would appeal to me. Hope they have big ones in the chamber for next year.
-
It would be awesome if your player wins MVP, they get a year taken off their rookie contract. Six years is brutal. MLB supposedly does this.
The only rule I'm aware of in actual MLB play is the so-called "Super Two" rule, which really applies to the top 22% of players on rookie level contracts. This rule allows those on rookie contracts deemed to be in the top 22% of their peers in quality of play to qualify for salary arbitration one year earlier than their peer players deemed to be in the bottom 78%.
The intent of the rule was to reward excellent players on rookie contracts, but the actual impact has been to encourage teams to delay MLB call up's for highly talented players in the minor leagues. This happens because one of the qualifications is that a player must earn a minimum of 86 days of service time in the preceding season. Therefore, by delaying the player's call up, a team can essentially gain an entire year of MLB service before the super two rule kicks in. Teams exchange losing out on all but 86 days of MLB service by said player in return for delaying or nullifying the Super Two rule.