MLBTS on PC - Illegal, no?
-
Seeing people on Twitter talking about someone getting the Switch version of MLB The Show 26 running natively on PC.
Isn’t this illegal? I can’t imagine Nintendo, Sony, or SDS being okay with people bypassing protections and porting their game to PC without permission.
-
Unless SDS releases a version of the game for PC, then playing it on PC is a violation of the copyright and terms of use. Given the myriad of issues with the community market, and the reality that the problems materialized due to the ability to run hacks and bots via a PC, then despite all my serious objections to how SDS is ruining this game, I agree with their view to keep the game off PC's.
-
@PriorFir4383355_XBL yeah, which is why I’m confused about creators celebrating this. It’s both illegal AND bad.
-
As a saying as old as time...
"If buying isn't owning, then piracy isn't stealing."
It's a tale as old as time. Unfortunately, the proverb has been passed around more than Dennis Schroeder in the past 6 years. Sometimes we glorify crimes, sometimes we don't.
People will say: "Buy a PC!" Ram prices cost more than rent in the modern day. Most casual gamers don't have the money or time to buy a PC.
Consoles will be and have always been the norm.
-
There have been emulators around for ages, especially on PC.
Things may be trickier these days with companies saying that you don't own the software but I think, in the past, emulators were fine IF you owned the original game and got the files from that source.
It was the distributing of ROMs that caused all of the issues. Distributing the game for PC to those who do not own it is Piracy. That is more the issue that the company would go after than actually those just playing it.
From what little I saw you can't play online so it's not like online players are running into PC players.
-
These people are not creators. They are grafters. They grafted onto a video game an online identity, feeding their egos to the point where they now think they are larger than the video game itself. Anyone, and I mean anyone, who wraps his ego up with a video game is a troubled soul.
Troubled souls are not the sort of people one should look to for setting a moral example!
-

-
These people are not creators. They are grafters. They grafted onto a video game an online identity, feeding their egos to the point where they now think they are larger than the video game itself. Anyone, and I mean anyone, who wraps his ego up with a video game is a troubled soul.
Troubled souls are not the sort of people one should look to for setting a moral example!
Maybe not to this extreme, but I see what you’re saying. I’m getting attacked by content creators on Twitter just for questioning the legality of this whole thing. Some of these guys have lost their absolute minds and seem to think they can do or say whatever they want. It’s honestly a shame.
-
The celebrated the third party sites, why would they be above this?
-
The celebrated the third party sites, why would they be above this?
Yeah I give them too much of my energy. It’s like arguing with middle schoolers.
-
These people are not creators. They are grafters. They grafted onto a video game an online identity, feeding their egos to the point where they now think they are larger than the video game itself. Anyone, and I mean anyone, who wraps his ego up with a video game is a troubled soul.
Troubled souls are not the sort of people one should look to for setting a moral example!
Maybe not to this extreme, but I see what you’re saying. I’m getting attacked by content creators on Twitter just for questioning the legality of this whole thing. Some of these guys have lost their absolute minds and seem to think they can do or say whatever they want. It’s honestly a shame.
Does that reaction to your statements not confirm my views about them?
There is no question about the legality of this. Tort law is quite clear on the subject. The entity that holds the copyright has the authority to determine its use. If those terms are not acceptable to you, then don't purchase the item. That's the only proper response. It is never acceptable to abuse the TOS and then attack people for pointing out that completely clear fact.
-
These people are not creators. They are grafters. They grafted onto a video game an online identity, feeding their egos to the point where they now think they are larger than the video game itself. Anyone, and I mean anyone, who wraps his ego up with a video game is a troubled soul.
Troubled souls are not the sort of people one should look to for setting a moral example!
Maybe not to this extreme, but I see what you’re saying. I’m getting attacked by content creators on Twitter just for questioning the legality of this whole thing. Some of these guys have lost their absolute minds and seem to think they can do or say whatever they want. It’s honestly a shame.
Does that reaction to your statements not confirm my views about them?
There is no question about the legality of this. Tort law is quite clear on the subject. The entity that holds the copyright has the authority to determine its use. If those terms are not acceptable to you, then don't purchase the item. That's the only proper response. It is never acceptable to abuse the TOS and then attack people for pointing out that completely clear fact.
Exactly. And that’s what I’ve been trying to say. You don’t have to agree with SDS’s rules, but that doesn’t give you the right to ignore them (or the law, for that matter). What’s more concerning to me is how quickly some of these creators resort to personal attacks when someone challenges their behavior. The reaction I’ve gotten today honestly just reinforces your point.
Man I’m done. Just done with them.
-
If you own a copy of the game, it is perfectly legal to play an emulated version on different hardware including PCs. This falls under legal protections to make backups of software and media.
-
@Player99_MLBTS outright not true. PC has FAR more users than consoles.
-
If you own a copy of the game, it is perfectly legal to play an emulated version on different hardware including PCs. This falls under legal protections to make backups of software and media.
You need to consult an attorney at law. What you said is simply contrary to the law. You are only allowed to make copies if the terms of service you agreed to as a condition to purchase the game authorized it.
If the copyright specifically says that you are not allowed to play the game on a PC, then you are not allowed to. If there is any question regarding this, then read the terms outlined in this contract you agreed to when installing the game:
https://www.playstation.com/en-us/legal/software-eula/
Even if you purchased for X-Box console, the end user license agreement still applies.
Note specifically section 1.4 of the EULA, which reads in part: "The Software is licensed to you, not sold. You are granted a limited, non-exclusive, non-transferable, and personal license to play or use the Software for your private, non-commercial use on the system or device it was intended for."
Again, note the final words, "use on the system or device it was intended for." It doesn't get any more clear than that folks! You either purchased the game to play on an X-Box or Playstation or Switch device. The game is not sold for use on PC's. And moreover, you do not own the game, you are merely granted a license to play the game and are required to play it according the terms in the EULA.
That's the law folks.
-
Globally, yes PC has a larger user base. I think America is a bit closer to 55-45 in favor of PC, other countries it’s closer to 65-35. I’m probably going to be joining the PC group soon, especially with next gen consoles rumored to be north of $1,200.
-
Globally, yes PC has a larger user base. I think America is a bit closer to 55-45 in favor of PC, other countries it’s closer to 65-35. I’m probably going to be joining the PC group soon, especially with next gen consoles rumored to be north of $1,200.
I used to game on PC with a controller, but there are just so many things to tweak. I prefer just being able to use a console, which is made strictly for gaming.
-
@SiberiaTigerCub_PSN I was talking about how most people who are getting into gaming and don't have the GDP of
TaiwanChinese Taipei will often buy a console.I do accept the fact that alot of people, if not most gamers are on PC.
-
@SiberiaTigerCub_PSN I was talking about how most people who are getting into gaming and don't have the GDP of
TaiwanChinese Taipei will often buy a console.I do accept the fact that alot of people, if not most gamers are on PC.
The problem is that the consoles seemingly are becoming as expensive as an equivalent PC
-
with next gen consoles rumored to be north of $1,200.
A next gen gaming console should not be anything over $600-$700.
I don't know but I think next gens are not going to do very well, especially in this economic climate where everyone's discretionary funds that would go to this kind of entertainment are going for groceries, gas...ect.
The only saving grace for project Helix is I think you can preserve your games forever.
For that I would've thought that Sony would not gouge us on the price of a next gen console. Kinda of yes, we are doing this but we are not kill you all on pricing for our consoles....sort of an olive branch of sorts.
I'm planning on staying with my PS5 until it dies, I can't justify and for the principle as well, spending north of $1000 for a console when I picked up my PS5 brand new 2 years ago for $549.99, it makes zero sense.