Who is the Best Card in the Game?
-
Now this should be a good debate!
CF Signature Carlos Beltran: I think he's still the best
RF Moonshot Hank Aaron: The card is absolutely juiced
3B Chipper Jones: A fan favorite who is also juiced
C. Jorge Posada: His swing is butter and his card is unrealistically insane.
RF Milestone Babe Ruth: It's Babe Ruth
LF Hall of Fame Ted Williams: His card is still absolutely nuts
RF Finest Jose Bautista: Joey Bats is also juiced (though many people struggle with him)
SP Milestone John Donaldson: He's basically untouchable as a pitcher and is a great hitter as well
2B 2025 All-Star Ketel Marte: Also a fan favorite who has an insane swing
1B Neon Lou Gehrig: Another very juiced card
C. 2025 Home Run Derby Cal Raleigh: You never know
SS Finest Jimmy Rollins: He has a great swing -
John Donaldson. He gets in people’s head I think.
-
Jimmy Rollins
-
Posada, every year for me.
-
Based purely on attributes.....
Caveat - I know more goes into it than strictly crunching numbers but crunching numbers is all I got.1B
Best Overall: Lou Gehrig
Best Offensive: Hank Greenberg2B
Best Overall: Brice Turang
Best Offensive: Joe MorganSS
Best Overall: Honus Wagner
Best Offensive: Ozzie Smith3B
Best Overall: Chipper Jones
Best Offensive: Chipper JonesLF
Best Overall: Rickey Henderson
Best Offensive: Ted WilliamsCF
Best Overall: Jakob Marsee
Best Offensive: Grady SizemoreRF
Best Overall: Jose Bautista
Best Offensive: Babe RuthRF
Best Overall: Jose Bautista
Best Offensive: Hank Aaron (best offensive score of any player in the game currently)C
Best Overall: Gary Sanchez
Best Offensive: Gary Sanchez -
I have all these cards. Chipper is #1, Donaldson is #2. I don’t think Hank Aaron is in the convo at all and I think Randy Johnson should be mentioned. Only way to beat him is bunt cheese.
-
@NWOStunna_PSN said in Who is the Best Card in the Game?:
I have all these cards. Chipper is #1, Donaldson is #2. I don’t think Hank Aaron is in the convo at all and I think Randy Johnson should be mentioned. Only way to beat him is bunt cheese.
I get it if Hanks swing is not good but those Offensive attributes, taken as a whole are the best in the game. He's definitely a DH though as the fielding and reaction is not good.
Con R - 125
Con L - 125
Pow R - 125
Pow L - 125
Vis - 109
Disc - 101
Clt - 125 -
Babe Ruth for me
-
@Dolenz_PSN said in Who is the Best Card in the Game?:
Based purely on attributes.....
Caveat - I know more goes into it than strictly crunching numbers but crunching numbers is all I got.2B
Best Overall: Brice TurangSS
Best Offensive: Ozzie Smith
CF
Best Overall: Jakob Marsee
Best Offensive: Grady SizemoreRF
Best Overall: Jose BautistaRF
Best Overall: Jose BautistaC
Best Overall: Gary Sanchez
Best Offensive: Gary SanchezTotally deserved, all of these
To be fair, Ill give Turang a bit of pass because he is at least arguably the best 2B in MLB this year
-
I love the HOF Gil Hodges card. Underrated in my opinion
