P5 1/1 Club
-
I have no 1/1 but i have more P5s in this game than any other so far, mostly pitchers.
95 Glasnow
90 Santana
99 Pettitte
99 Sabathia
89 Wagner
89 Iglesias
99 SengaSkenes 99, Sale 99 and Gibson 99 all at P4, soon to be 5.
For batters, i only have 89 Shawn Green but my season 1 team is all P4, close to P5.
-
@SchnauzerFace said in P5 1/1 Club:
If being 1st to P5 is a fun chase -- but being 2nd holds absolutely no appeal
In the famous words of Ricky Bobby... "If you ain't first, you're last".
-
@Dolenz said in P5 1/1 Club:
@SchnauzerFace said in P5 1/1 Club:
That's true, but reducing the P5 threshold from 10,000 to 8,000 this year is helpful
I agree and I am fine with P5 being a grind and not easy to complete.
I do feel like it is a Trophy as much as anything. The +5 to stats is nice but at my level it is not a game changer and the difference between plus 3 or 4 compared to plus 5 is minor.
Exactly. I don't do it for the extra 5 attribute points. It's a trophy and something I can be offline competitive with.
-
I do the reverse, I try to p1 as many cards as possible.
Now that I can play with older season cards freely Ive been using a lot of those, Im guessing I have close to 400 p1s for s1 now.Since I rarely play more than 2-3 games a day now (which is more than enough to do all content) I have much fewer s2 and s3 p1s.
-
Got 3 more 1/1s to add to the collection:
98 Greg Vaughn MS
97 Sam Hilliard TN
97 Logan Driscoll TN -
Live series Mick Abel for me this year. Was going after some others that were commons but the bots who loaded into ranked of all commons beat me to it
-
@jbrown51016 That’s a fun idea. Next year I might try to load up my live series team with team captains and try to P5 all of them.
-
Got 3 More P5 1/1s. These are the best yet. All 99s including my favorite 1/1 so far: 99 Finest David Wright
https://x.com/adidasmaximus/status/1841583060724416651?t=sWH_wqgK99slXqKP7-f2xQ&s=09
Updated List of All My P5 1/1s:
- 99 Finest David Wright
- 99 Awards Jose Abreu
- 99 Prime Jason Heyward
- 98 Milestone Greg Vaughn
- 98 OOP Johan Santana
- 97 Topps Now Sam Hilliard
- 96 Topps Now S3 Cal Raleigh
- 96 Topps Now Logan Driscoll
- 95 Captain Cedric Mullins
- 95 Topps Now Jon Singleton
- 94 Topps Now Jesse Winker
-
How many do you have in total, not just season 3
-
@dbub said in P5 1/1 Club:
Got 3 More P5 1/1s. These are the best yet. All 99s including my favorite 1/1 so far: 99 Finest David Wright
https://x.com/adidasmaximus/status/1841583060724416651?t=sWH_wqgK99slXqKP7-f2xQ&s=09
Updated List of All My P5 1/1s:
- 99 Finest David Wright
- 99 Awards Jose Abreu
- 99 Prime Jason Heyward
- 98 Milestone Greg Vaughn
- 98 OOP Johan Santana
- 97 Topps Now Sam Hilliard
- 96 Topps Now S3 Cal Raleigh
- 96 Topps Now Logan Driscoll
- 95 Captain Cedric Mullins
- 95 Topps Now Jon Singleton
- 94 Topps Now Jesse Winker
How do you get all those hitters P5 so fast?
-
That's it. I didn't play in Season 1. And didn't aim for these in Season 2.
One thing I admit is it would be a lot harder back in Season 1 when they're were a lot more people playing.
It takes me on average 5 days to complete a P5 hitter.
Notice I have no pitchers yet. That's because they go faster, and I think it's because people bunt into outs on purpose to level up their pitchers. I refuse to do that. Can't imagine how boring it would be.
-
I have no new groundbreaking secrets to share. It's pretty much what I think other people do:
- Obviously have your focused hitters at the top of lineup.
- Find the worst pitching (I mix in White Sox and Rockies).
- Play as much as you can CPU on Rookie.
- Play either at a "little league stadium" from Stadium Creator or Coors (so you get first at bat). I lean more to created stadiums over Coors though.
- Maximize your Captains - I pretty much always run Kershaw and then either O'Neil Cruz or Max Muncy.
- Focus on hitters you click with. The higher your OPS, the faster it will get done. I usually range from 2.200 to 2.700 by the P5 end with each hitter. (Remember it's on Rookie)
-
I've gone and done it again (3 more times).
New P5 1/1s:
99 Postseason Jackson Chourio
99 Postseason Michael Harris II
99 Postseason Cedric Mullins (obviously)https://x.com/adidasmaximus/status/1844142383296020687?t=0uL0zKedlufGixgqf8uweA&s=19
Full Updated List of P5 1/1s:
99 Postseason Jackson Chourio
99 Postseason Michael Harris II
99 Postseason Cedric Mullins
99 Finest David Wright
99 Awards Jose Abreu
99 Prime Jason Heyward
98 Milestone Greg Vaughn
98 OOP Johan Santana
97 Topps Now Sam Hilliard
96 Topps Now S3 Cal Raleigh
96 Topps Now Logan Driscoll
95 Captain Cedric Mullins
95 Topps Now Jon Singleton
94 Topps Now Jesse Winker -
I can’t play on rookie
I play vs cpu on all star with an 80 overall squad.
If i play w my 95 up squad than it is on legend
I get it the 1/1 is cool
-
Do we have to get the 1/1 for reaching P1 first, or P5?
I was hoping to do that with Finest Al Leiter, but wound up 16th to P1. I did pitch a no-no on Veteran with him! Maybe if I just pitched 6 scoreless and quit, I'd have the first P1 of him! My offense went crazy and scored 33 or so. I was going to bunt to get back to pitching, but took the runs instead! -
@RazorForte45 I bet you cook your steaks with gun powder and eat nails for breakfast too.
-
@SJR15ITFC said in P5 1/1 Club:
@dbub I was about to post that someone already has Pedro Martinez at P5 and thought “who in their right mind has done that already?” …and then thought of this post! Nice work
Haha. It sadly wasn't me. I would have killed for a Pedro 1/1.
I don't even have Pedro yet. Plus, I've never done a pitcher. I refuse to bunt every time I'm up for 12 hours or however long it takes.
-
@TheGoaler said in P5 1/1 Club:
Do we have to get the 1/1 for reaching P1 first, or P5?
I was hoping to do that with Finest Al Leiter, but wound up 16th to P1. I did pitch a no-no on Veteran with him! Maybe if I just pitched 6 scoreless and quit, I'd have the first P1 of him! My offense went crazy and scored 33 or so. I was going to bunt to get back to pitching, but took the runs instead!The P5 1/1 is the goal. But yeah I'd still be proud of a 1/1 P1-P4.
-
I have one P5 (Pete Crow-Armstrong) and am working on another (Yu Darvish). Wouldn't mind having Fernando Tatis Jr. and Corbin Carroll also in that club.
