At this point MLB 24 is the worst show ever released
-
@IrishFist412 said in At this point MLB 24 is the worst show ever released:
It’s certainly not the worst gameplay wise but the doubling down on Seasons is what makes it the absolute worst experience in the franchise’s history. As I’ve said on here before - I used to play the show year round. Last year I bailed when season 3 dropped, This year I’ll finish out season 1 and then I’ll be bailing when NCAA football drops. I’m not going to keep chasing a carrot especially when I can only use the carrot for a week or two before it’s taken away again lol…I’d be fine with them going back to grinding for immortals or even the way it was from 18-22. It really sucks because this used to be the only game I would play year round.
Lots of people think it’s the worst gameplay but some people are getting rewarded for bad swings consistently so they like the game.
-
@VioletNine9 Then those people didn’t experience The Show 16 with the bunting glitch that couldn’t be stopped. Or pre-Show 2020 where contact hitters were useless. While Show 24 is not perfect, It’s leaps & bounds better than its predecessors.
-
I still vote for 18.
I do believe a lot of people have regency bias when making these claims, maybe not all but some.
-
@Weshill627 said in At this point MLB 24 is the worst show ever released:
For some reason I am not meant to make World series. I lost again, 14-7. My opponent was taking bad swings in the first 4 innings and then all of the sudden in the 5th inning he couldn't get out. From a game development standpoint. Idk how someone could take horrible swings and keep getting rewarded. I gave up 3 "Late" homers. lol I'm current down to 847 because SDS enjoys making you lose more points than you gain on wins.
I'm 18-13 on the season, and its not looking good. I would take a few days off of Ranked, but there isn't anything else to do in the game lol. I've played BR and Events, since there's no other grinding. Ranked is the only thing I haven't done yet.
At least in MLB 18 you could grind Immortals, there was always something to do. In mlb 24, you complete the 10 minute mini program and then nothing.You are an addict asking for permission to get clean, lol.
Seriously, though, you're not wrong.
-
@Dolenz said in At this point MLB 24 is the worst show ever released:
I do believe a lot of people have regency bias when making these claims, maybe not all but some.
God save the Queen!
-
@Dolenz said in At this point MLB 24 is the worst show ever released:
I still vote for 18.
I do believe a lot of people have regency bias when making these claims, maybe not all but some.
Especially because 18's gameplay was garbage. You can defend the souvenirs program grind, but there is no defending power meta and useless fastballs.
-
Worst gameplay - '18
Worst content - '24Started in '18 so I don't know about previous versions.
-
@Skarmaen said in At this point MLB 24 is the worst show ever released:
Worst gameplay - '18
Worst content - '24Started in '18 so I don't know about previous versions.
It's not a coincidence that 18 was the first year that the 100 threshold for attributes was broken. Resulting in bad game play that took awhile to get right. 17 played great, but had too much online grinding for programs, but way better than this buy packs [censored].
-
My first year to play DD was '21 and that is by far my favorite content-wise. I know people say programs were "too easy' and they gave everything out for free, but I don't care. It was fun and it made me want to play the game. I thought it had gameplay issues, but looking back it wasn't nearly as bad as I thought.
During these four years, I have played DD, '24 is the worst and it isn't even close. The content is terrible and the foul ball issues mixed with "pitcher confidence" make gameplay unbearable. For me, this is the complete opposite of '21 in that basically nothing makes me want to play DD.
-
I legit am done with MLB 24. Not only as we've discussed the Content is trash. The gameplay is horrible. I just lost AGAIN to a guy i was beating all game long. Tied in the 10th i didn't get 1 foul ball. My opponent had double digit fouls in the 10th and won with a blooper up the middle.
I have a 6.5 ERA this season. pitching used to be my strong suit. now i can't beat anyone. I am down to 803 and can't win anymore. I would say ill play something else in MLB 24, too bad there is nothing else to do.
SDS do us all a favor, drop the MLB license and let someone else try. You guys ruined the good name you build in the PS3 days.
-
@Cordzilla99 I would legit start a GO FUND ME for SDS to drop the MLB license and give it to another studio. They've turned my favorite gaming franchise into a joke.
-
@Weshill627 let me know where I can sign the paper. Lol
-
@Honor_The_Game44
Totally agree. Loved 21 and since then there has been a dramatic decline.
-
@Weshill627 bump bump bump bump bump
Send me the link when you do! Id say $80 donations sound about right for some reason......
-
22 was the last game I really truly enjoyed and didn't feel left behind because I couldn't grind all day/to the cap every day. 23 as well but to a much lesser extent
-
I am really tired of Ranked bros. I have played 5 ranked games today. I am 3-2, started the day at 823 and right now i am at 839. I REALLY hope they change ranked next year. Its so boring to be stuck on a ladder I can never climb.
-
@Sarge1387 said in At this point MLB 24 is the worst show ever released:
22 was the last game I really truly enjoyed and didn't feel left behind because I couldn't grind all day/to the cap every day. 23 as well but to a much lesser extent
Yes 22 for obvious reasons of no sets or seasons for me. Game has gone to hell ever since.
-
@Weshill627 said in At this point MLB 24 is the worst show ever released:
I am really tired of Ranked bros. I have played 5 ranked games today. I am 3-2, started the day at 823 and right now i am at 839. I REALLY hope they change ranked next year. Its so boring to be stuck on a ladder I can never climb.
Maybe that's just your level? Sorry. Not everyone can hit 900 every season, and it sounds pretty logical to hit your level and hover there.
-
@Loyal-Wiglaf I've made World Series each year since mlb 17. I lose in the most annoying ways. Come to my stream and watch Wes_Hill1. Trust me i can make it, the game won't let me
-
@Weshill627 said in At this point MLB 24 is the worst show ever released:
@Loyal-Wiglaf I've made World Series each year since mlb 17. I lose in the most annoying ways. Come to my stream and watch Wes_Hill1. Trust me i can make it, the game won't let me
Whelp, that sucks. Good luck then. I won't say, "That's baseball," because it's a video game, and for me it's always been something close to a line-drive out simulator with. But everyone is in fact playing with the same broken game, so...
