The hitting skill gap is the widest its ever been. Thats why MOST of you dont like it.
-
I do really like the game overall, but I disagree with this post... MOST people don't like the hitting because bad swings are still being rewarded as much as good swings.
I just played a 15-inning game against a guy that was like 16-4 or something like that, and we both squared up literally dozens of [censored] all game long and were not rewarded. For example, I was perfect with the PCI off Oswalt several times with FOTF Josh Bell, Eddie Matthews, etc, and wasn't rewarded at all. My opponent was really good, and I'm sure he had the same experience based on how many deep flyouts he had.
How did I end up winning the game in the 15th inning? I hit a walk-off HR with Trevor Story on a fastball that I completely missed (inner PCI not even touching the ball). This is the part of the game that constantly drives me crazy (even when I was lucky enough to win this one).
-
@challengerjs said in The hitting skill gap is the widest its ever been. Thats why MOST of you dont like it.:
I do really like the game overall, but I disagree with this post... MOST people don't like the hitting because bad swings are still being rewarded as much as good swings.
IMO, this is much more of an explanation for disgruntled comments on gameplay than so called “skill gap”.
Most of us know when we are being owned by a better player. Nobody complains about that.
It’s giving up solo bombs on curveballs your opponent barely got the PCI on with Aaron Judge that irk me, personally.
I have no problem tipping my cap to a good hitter/better player.
But when that same opponent can’t hit three fastballs in a row right down Broadway, after said home run, this is where I find the game lacking.
-
@halfbutt said in The hitting skill gap is the widest its ever been. Thats why MOST of you dont like it.:
@challengerjs said in The hitting skill gap is the widest its ever been. Thats why MOST of you dont like it.:
I do really like the game overall, but I disagree with this post... MOST people don't like the hitting because bad swings are still being rewarded as much as good swings.
IMO, this is much more of an explanation for disgruntled comments on gameplay than so called “skill gap”.
Most of us know when we are being owned by a better player. Nobody complains about that.
It’s giving up solo bombs on curveballs your opponent barely got the PCI on with Aaron Judge that irk me, personally.
I have no problem tipping my cap to a good hitter/better player.
But when that same opponent can’t hit three fastballs in a row right down Broadway, after said home run, this is where I find the game lacking.
I agree, but the people who will disagree with you will point out "how do you know your opponent barely got the PCI on the ball?".
-
I agree, but the people who will disagree with you will point out "how do you know your opponent barely got the PCI on the ball?".
You’re right, it’s hard to know for sure. Is the swing feedback even accurate? We don’t know.
That said, right after I gave up said home run, I wanted to test that notion.
That’s where the fastballs down the middle come in. Could my opponent have been sitting offspeed? Maybe. But if he can hit out an inside curve that barely hung, but not three fastballs down the middle, what does that say about the game?
Personally, I think it was Judge’s attributes that hit out the curveball, not my opponent.
-
@halfbutt said in The hitting skill gap is the widest its ever been. Thats why MOST of you dont like it.:
I agree, but the people who will disagree with you will point out "how do you know your opponent barely got the PCI on the ball?".
You’re right, it’s hard to know for sure. Is the swing feedback even accurate? We don’t know.
That said, right after I gave up said home run, I wanted to test that notion.
That’s where the fastballs down the middle come in. Could my opponent have been sitting offspeed? Maybe. But if he can hit out an inside curve that barely hung, but not three fastballs down the middle, what does that say about the game?
Personally, I think it was Judge’s attributes that hit out the curveball, not my opponent.
Personally, I think you cannot trust the feedback.
Question, were you winning when Judge hit his bomb?
-
I think it was tied. Whatever. GG to my opponent.
-
@halfbutt said in The hitting skill gap is the widest its ever been. Thats why MOST of you dont like it.:
Nice flex.
Personally, I don’t see where skill is involved in determining whether an outcome is good squared, good good, perfect, or good ok, but if it makes you feel better about it, sure.
Lmao. It just doesnt happen as often as you all make it seem. You just arent good. Its okay
-
@Marg0904 said in The hitting skill gap is the widest its ever been. Thats why MOST of you dont like it.:
Sure..Especially when I'm hitting a 3 perfects in a game and not a single one of them is a hit..But my opp is making late/okay HRs
Let me guess. In showdown?
-
@challengerjs said in The hitting skill gap is the widest its ever been. Thats why MOST of you dont like it.:
I do really like the game overall, but I disagree with this post... MOST people don't like the hitting because bad swings are still being rewarded as much as good swings.
I just played a 15-inning game against a guy that was like 16-4 or something like that, and we both squared up literally dozens of [censored] all game long and were not rewarded. For example, I was perfect with the PCI off Oswalt several times with FOTF Josh Bell, Eddie Matthews, etc, and wasn't rewarded at all. My opponent was really good, and I'm sure he had the same experience based on how many deep flyouts he had.
How did I end up winning the game in the 15th inning? I hit a walk-off HR with Trevor Story on a fastball that I completely missed (inner PCI not even touching the ball). This is the part of the game that constantly drives me crazy (even when I was lucky enough to win this one).
The better hitter has won every game ive played so far.
-
@GrandpaShaft said in The hitting skill gap is the widest its ever been. Thats why MOST of you dont like it.:
@Marg0904 said in The hitting skill gap is the widest its ever been. Thats why MOST of you dont like it.:
Sure..Especially when I'm hitting a 3 perfects in a game and not a single one of them is a hit..But my opp is making late/okay HRs
Let me guess. In showdown?
RS
-
@halfbutt said in The hitting skill gap is the widest its ever been. Thats why MOST of you dont like it.:
Nice flex.
Personally, I don’t see where skill is involved in determining whether an outcome is good squared, good good, perfect, or good ok, but if it makes you feel better about it, sure.
You do by putting the PCI on the ball ?
-
Squaring up the ball on HOF is much harder this year, which is GREAT. However, squaring up the ball still has a nearly random outcome, which is TERRIBLE. I don't mind hitting being hard, when you can practice and get better. If you still have RNG outcomes on good swings, it makes the entire hitting system DISMAL.
-
@GrandpaShaft said in The hitting skill gap is the widest its ever been. Thats why MOST of you dont like it.:
@challengerjs said in The hitting skill gap is the widest its ever been. Thats why MOST of you dont like it.:
I do really like the game overall, but I disagree with this post... MOST people don't like the hitting because bad swings are still being rewarded as much as good swings.
I just played a 15-inning game against a guy that was like 16-4 or something like that, and we both squared up literally dozens of [censored] all game long and were not rewarded. For example, I was perfect with the PCI off Oswalt several times with FOTF Josh Bell, Eddie Matthews, etc, and wasn't rewarded at all. My opponent was really good, and I'm sure he had the same experience based on how many deep flyouts he had.
How did I end up winning the game in the 15th inning? I hit a walk-off HR with Trevor Story on a fastball that I completely missed (inner PCI not even touching the ball). This is the part of the game that constantly drives me crazy (even when I was lucky enough to win this one).
The better hitter has won every game ive played so far.
Or the worst pitcher took the Big L?
-
@Matt_42187 said in The hitting skill gap is the widest its ever been. Thats why MOST of you dont like it.:
I like the skill gap this year. I'm average, but when I can hang with people with good records, I feel ok with myself. I think pitching doesn't really need to be tweaked. Pitchers like Nolan Ryan will be all over the place. Pitchers with great control, will be effective most of the time.
Lol Roy Oswalt with 99 BB/9 misses over the heart of the plate 5+ times a game for me i dunno wtf youre talking about
-
@xV_darkshadow_Vx said in The hitting skill gap is the widest its ever been. Thats why MOST of you dont like it.:
@Matt_42187 said in The hitting skill gap is the widest its ever been. Thats why MOST of you dont like it.:
I like the skill gap this year. I'm average, but when I can hang with people with good records, I feel ok with myself. I think pitching doesn't really need to be tweaked. Pitchers like Nolan Ryan will be all over the place. Pitchers with great control, will be effective most of the time.
Lol Roy Oswalt with 99 BB/9 misses over the heart of the plate 5+ times a game for me i dunno wtf youre talking about
In real life, Oswalt didn’t have 99 control and he did miss over the plate more than 5+ per game. It happens.
-
@Matt_42187 said in The hitting skill gap is the widest its ever been. Thats why MOST of you dont like it.:
@xV_darkshadow_Vx said in The hitting skill gap is the widest its ever been. Thats why MOST of you dont like it.:
@Matt_42187 said in The hitting skill gap is the widest its ever been. Thats why MOST of you dont like it.:
I like the skill gap this year. I'm average, but when I can hang with people with good records, I feel ok with myself. I think pitching doesn't really need to be tweaked. Pitchers like Nolan Ryan will be all over the place. Pitchers with great control, will be effective most of the time.
Lol Roy Oswalt with 99 BB/9 misses over the heart of the plate 5+ times a game for me i dunno wtf youre talking about
In real life, Oswalt didn’t have 99 control and he did miss over the plate more than 5+ per game. It happens.
So now were back to the real life arguement? I thought you wanted a skill gap and user input too matter? Skill gap for hitting but not pitching that doesnt make much sense imo.
-
My favorite games are the ones where your clearly the better pitcher and kids flailing can’t time a single thing. On the other end ur squaring just off center getting goof goods or just early squared, solid contacts and just out after out. Then you go back to pitching just flailing again then magically just catches a perfect perfect missle for a HR and hangs on for the win. I would have to imagine that it’s directional or analog hitting.
-
I agree with the OP. I’ve been practicing a lot and can tell when I’m playing someone better or worse than me.
In a close game I agree this game has some funny stuff going on, but you can hit and hit well in this game if you put in the work.
-
I’ve been a as zoomed as you can player for years. Noticed switching to strikezone two has increased my contact and ball tracking so much more in this game.
