Incognito players we might see…

[Ericulous1_PSN]

Reggie- Mr October
Pujols- The Machine (I know he’s not in the game)
Bob Feller- Rapid Robert

[SakAttack87_PSN]

"Chuck Nasty" - Charlie Blackmon
"The Flyin' Hawaiian" - Shane Victorino
"The Giambino" - Jason Giambi
"Swish-alicious" - Nick Swisher

[TheGoaler_PSN]

I thought most people didn't like the nicknames.
Now we want more?

[BrikMahorn_XBL]

We can’t see them…they’re “incognito”.

The other thing we can’t see is their names on the screen when it shows who is coming up next inning!

[bmoo44_PSN]

The big dunp

[Jacky Chan1_XBL]

I really want Tim Lincicum(so).

[RShackleford_XBL]

"Big Sexy" Bartolo Colon
"The Cobra" Dave Parker

[MrBojanglees_XBL]

“Oil Can” Boyd
“The Yankee Clipper” Joe DiMaggio
“Spaceman” Bill Lee
“Charlie Hustle” Pete Rose
“Shoeless Joe” Jackson
“Yogi” Berra
“The Kid” Ted Williams

Some of these are probably exempt from MLBPA licensing due to either being banned from the game (Rose/Jackson) or because they have exempted themselves due to the greater value of their names (DiMaggio/Williams).

[NWOStunna_PSN]

I wish we could get the Georgia Peach back!

[Ericulous1_PSN]

@TheGoaler_PSN said in Incognito players we might see…:

I thought most people didn't like the nicknames.
Now we want more?

I don’t get why this has people so up in arms.

I agree it’s lame that they put the nicknames as their actual name and that it just shows “ “ up next inning but I like the card art and the concept.

Some of the names though….. I think they had to dig deep and makes some stuff up.

[Ericulous1_PSN]

Also, I get that Youk is easier to write on a card. But when Stephen King calls you the Greek god of walks, that’s your nickname.

[genopolanco_PSN]

A “CarGo” Carlos Gonzalez and “Tulo” Tulowitzki would make my year in an otherwise meh content year for me so far.

[Dolenz_PSN]

@TheGoaler_PSN said in Incognito players we might see…:

I thought most people didn't like the nicknames.
Now we want more?

Hey, if they are going to do them then we may as well ask for our favorite players to be included.

Personally, I am not a fan because most of the time I have no idea who I am facing.

[MooningGnome_XBL]

I'd go crazy for a "The Mayor" Sean Casey

[romeischillin_PSN]

The two I would like are "Squirrel" or "Flying Squirrel" for Jeff McNeil (although he has a Charisma card, but I see some guys with Charisma cards also have Incognito cards) and then also "Polar Bear" for Pete Alonso (although again I believe he has a WBC card)... I also know a couple guys like Blake Snell and Rich Goosage have Kaiju cards and felt like they would've fit better in the Incognito series instead.