23 New Legends Thread!
-
Randy Johnson
Ryan Howard
Joe Mauer
Carlos Delgado
Roy Halladay
Adrian Gonzalez
Nick Swisher
Jonny Gomes
Geovany Soto
Ray Durham
Kirk Gibson
Dontrelle Willis
Mike Napoli
Kevin Youkilis
Chase Utley
Mike Mussina
Brian Wilson
J.R. Richard
Jered WeaverNot saying that these are all prime HOFers or anything, but just think that the legends pool they introduced in 22 had more appeal and recognition than what they have revealed so far outside of Jeter.
There are surely some bigger names to come, but hard to deny that last year was pretty solid when it came to the balance of HOF caliber/fun personality with the new legends they rolled out. Not getting that vibe so far.
-
Joe DiMaggio,Ted Williams, Sandy Koufax, and Ty Cobb need to be in this game.How about more catchers? Thurman Munson, Roy Campanella, Yogi Berra, and Buster Bosey.
Other than Jeter, new players have been worse than “mid”.
-
Kinda seems to me like a "put all your eggs in one basket"situation.
Well,we got Jeter.unfortunately it looks like in getting Jeter we don't get anyone else. -
@PAinPA_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
Kinda seems to me like a "put all your eggs in one basket"situation.
Well,we got Jeter.unfortunately it looks like in getting Jeter we don't get anyone else.That's the thing though it's not like guys like Swisher or Dontrelle are these elite immortal players who defined their generation, but they were fun players and personalities. The current additions are just so bland. No sizzle at all with these names.
-
When is the legends trailer?
-
Will a true Legend please stand up
️ -
@TEXAS10PT_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
Will a true Legend please stand up
️Ok- if you could add 3 players to this game following these below rules, who would they be?
-
No known steroid users (I have no problem with them in the game but those are some of the obvious ones).
-
They can’t have already been in the game as a legend (I.e. no Rogers Hornsby, Adrian Beltre is ok).
Correct me if I’m wrong because I don’t know who has all been in the show as a legend before.
Mine-
- Sandy Koufax
- Carlos Beltran (never been a legend before)
- Frank Robinson
-
-
@Ericulous1_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
@TEXAS10PT_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
Will a true Legend please stand up
️Ok- if you could add 3 players to this game following these below rules, who would they be?
-
No known steroid users (I have no problem with them in the game but those are some of the obvious ones).
-
They can’t have already been in the game as a legend (I.e. no Rogers Hornsby, Adrian Beltre is ok).
Correct me if I’m wrong because I don’t know who has all been in the show as a legend before.
Mine-
- Sandy Koufax
- Carlos Beltran (never been a legend before)
- Frank Robinson
I can't control myself and limit it to three, but this is my list. Going to exclude people like Bonds/Clemens/McGwire because we all want those guys in the game. These are just some fun names that I feel would be worthy additions who have either never been in The Show or at least haven't been in the game in quite some time.
- Bernie Williams
- Nomar Garciaparra
- Mitch Williams
- Miguel Tejada
- Juan Gonzalez
- Kevin Brown
- Lance Berkman
- Barry Zito
- Norm Charlton
- Hideki Matsui
-
-
Pete Rose
Joe D
Mark Wohlers -
Lance Berkman, Ken Caminiti, and Ruben Sierra. All switch hitters and potential fun additions. I have no plans to buy 23 as I'm still stuck on 21 and haven't even installed the premium edition 22 I pre ordered, but if they put Caminiti or Berkman in 23 they get my money that same day and I may finally throw in the towel on 21.
-
Additionally an all Blue Jays OF of Jorge Bell, Lloyd Moseby, and Jesse Barfield could be fun. I remember watching those guys back when and it was good times.
-
Roger Maris
Fred Lynn
Jeff Kent
Juan Gonzalez (user?)
Frank Robinson is a great choice
Don Drysdale or Koufax -
@TEXAS10PT_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
Roger Maris
Fred Lynn
Jeff Kent
Juan Gonzalez (user?)
Frank Robinson is a great choice
Don Drysdale or KoufaxNice picks… I was just excluding the obvious ones- Bonds, Clemens, ARod, Manny, McGuire mainly because we’d all pick them. Who wouldn’t want a 99 Bonds or ARod.
Juan Gone wild be a lot of fun.
I always forget Fred Lynn and Yaz (was he ever in the game?)
-
@JayDubYa1973_XBL said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
Lance Berkman, Ken Caminiti, and Ruben Sierra. All switch hitters and potential fun additions. I have no plans to buy 23 as I'm still stuck on 21 and haven't even installed the premium edition 22 I pre ordered, but if they put Caminiti or Berkman in 23 they get my money that same day and I may finally throw in the towel on 21.
Great picks. Berkman and Beltran are my top wants of modern stars along with Scott Rolen. Caminiti would be a lot of fun too.
-
@SakAttack87_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
@Ericulous1_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
@TEXAS10PT_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
Will a true Legend please stand up
️Ok- if you could add 3 players to this game following these below rules, who would they be?
-
No known steroid users (I have no problem with them in the game but those are some of the obvious ones).
-
They can’t have already been in the game as a legend (I.e. no Rogers Hornsby, Adrian Beltre is ok).
Correct me if I’m wrong because I don’t know who has all been in the show as a legend before.
Mine-
- Sandy Koufax
- Carlos Beltran (never been a legend before)
- Frank Robinson
I can't control myself and limit it to three, but this is my list. Going to exclude people like Bonds/Clemens/McGwire because we all want those guys in the game. These are just some fun names that I feel would be worthy additions who have either never been in The Show or at least haven't been in the game in quite some time.
- Bernie Williams
- Nomar Garciaparra
- Mitch Williams
- Miguel Tejada
- Juan Gonzalez
- Kevin Brown
- Lance Berkman
- Barry Zito
- Norm Charlton
- Hideki Matsui
Love the addition of Zito and Charlton. We need more solid lefties!!!
-
-
@Ericulous1_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
@TEXAS10PT_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
Roger Maris
Fred Lynn
Jeff Kent
Juan Gonzalez (user?)
Frank Robinson is a great choice
Don Drysdale or KoufaxNice picks… I was just excluding the obvious ones- Bonds, Clemens, ARod, Manny, McGuire mainly because we’d all pick them. Who wouldn’t want a 99 Bonds or ARod.
Juan Gone wild be a lot of fun.
I always forget Fred Lynn and Yaz (was he ever in the game?)
YAZ would be great for the game. A lot of people don’t realize Maris won back to back MVPs in 60 and 61
