In your opinion, who are the five best starting pitchers in The Show 22?
-
Since we have a pretty good variety of high-end cards, I'm curious who everyone is enjoying using.
I've had some mixed results with everyone but Randy Johnson, Pedro Martinez, Cliff Lee, Al Leiter, and Chris Sale. So those are likely to be my top-5 with Grayson Rodriguez and Cole Hamels as my honorable mentions.
I'm looking forward to 99 Greg Maddux, Justin Verlander, Bob Gibson, Jake Arrieta, and Clayton Kershaw.
-
@BodamEscapePlan said in In your opinion, who are the five best starting pitchers in The Show 22?:
Since we have a pretty good variety of high-end cards, I'm curious who everyone is enjoying using.
I've had some mixed results with everyone but Randy Johnson, Pedro Martinez, Cliff Lee, Al Leiter, and Chris Sale. So those are likely to be my top-5 with Grayson Rodriguez and Cole Hamels as my honorable mentions.
I'm looking forward to 99 Greg Maddux, Justin Verlander, Bob Gibson, Jake Arrieta, and Clayton Kershaw.
Online? That's a lot of lefties.
-
@BodamEscapePlan said in In your opinion, who are the five best starting pitchers in The Show 22?:
Since we have a pretty good variety of high-end cards, I'm curious who everyone is enjoying using.
I've had some mixed results with everyone but Randy Johnson, Pedro Martinez, Cliff Lee, Al Leiter, and Chris Sale. So those are likely to be my top-5 with Grayson Rodriguez and Cole Hamels as my honorable mentions.
I'm looking forward to 99 Greg Maddux, Justin Verlander, Bob Gibson, Jake Arrieta, and Clayton Kershaw.
I definitely am hoping we get a Kershaw that is has overly boosted attributes. He is my best pitcher every year. I already paralleled his ASG card to a P5, but that won’t complete with all the new pitchers. All the pitchers you listed I would love for them to make.
-
Top 4 are Randy, Pedro, Nolan and Grayson for sure. Number 5 is all about personal preference and what skill level you play. Wood has good stuff but questionable control. People like Burnett and Oswalt. I like Glavin over Lee. One guy I have not tried but has shut me down is Finest Cueto.
-
Imo Randy, Nolan, Grayson, Seaver, Lee
-
Randy Nolan Pedro Kerry Grayson/Ohtani
-
randy / nolan / wood / roberts / my 5th rotates on a few
-
Valenzuela, Saberhagen, May, Grienke, and Wood
-
This question is subjective on so many levels. It all depends what difficulty you play on?
-
Ryan, Johnson, Martinez, Wood and Feller but this is just my top 5.
-
Can I get more insight to the 99 Seaver.
He seems pedestrian.H/9 is super but what is it that has him in this chat?
-
I think we all are forgetting about the submariner CAP with the OP pitch mix!
-
@RazorForte45_XBL said in In your opinion, who are the five best starting pitchers in The Show 22?:
Can I get more insight to the 99 Seaver.
He seems pedestrian.H/9 is super but what is it that has him in this chat?
I think he’s really readable. He doesn’t have a high K per 9 so you can foul a lot of pitches off too. He’s better than a lot of pitchers but I don’t think he’s top 5. That’s just my opinion though.
-
Ryan, Johnson, Grayson, (Soon to be Kluber), Vida Blue other great options include Cueto/Burnett/Mussina/Sale. There's a lot of great pitchers out now.
-
I must have no idea how to pitch with Grayson online as I have a 9+ era with him.
-
@BIG_PAPIx34_PSN said in In your opinion, who are the five best starting pitchers in The Show 22?:
@BodamEscapePlan said in In your opinion, who are the five best starting pitchers in The Show 22?:
Since we have a pretty good variety of high-end cards, I'm curious who everyone is enjoying using.
I've had some mixed results with everyone but Randy Johnson, Pedro Martinez, Cliff Lee, Al Leiter, and Chris Sale. So those are likely to be my top-5 with Grayson Rodriguez and Cole Hamels as my honorable mentions.
I'm looking forward to 99 Greg Maddux, Justin Verlander, Bob Gibson, Jake Arrieta, and Clayton Kershaw.
Online? That's a lot of lefties.
Those are my guys more often than not. Sometimes I'll mix in Grayson and Kerry Wood, too.
I just haven't had much good right-handed starter luck. That's why I'm looking forward to this Finest Kluber and the others I listed. I did like Euly Perez for quite some time, though. I miss him, honestly.
-
@Hikes83_PSN said in In your opinion, who are the five best starting pitchers in The Show 22?:
This question is subjective on so many levels. It all depends what difficulty you play on?
That's why I prefaced this question with in your opinion. I'm not looking for a definitive answer.
-
@theBlindRhino said in In your opinion, who are the five best starting pitchers in The Show 22?:
Valenzuela, Saberhagen, May, Grienke, and Wood
I've heard good things about the Topps Now Dustin May. I may have to give him a go.
-
Randy, Nolan, Pedro, Wood, Glavine.
-
@BodamEscapePlan said in In your opinion, who are the five best starting pitchers in The Show 22?:
@theBlindRhino said in In your opinion, who are the five best starting pitchers in The Show 22?:
Valenzuela, Saberhagen, May, Grienke, and Wood
I've heard good things about the Topps Now Dustin May. I may have to give him a go.
Check out The Show's Twitter. They're asking you to make a Starting 5 with certain pitchers that are assigned points.
