Top 5 cards in the game as of now...
-
Randy Johnson 99
Stan Musial 96
Honus Wagner 96
George Brett 99Haven't used the new David Ortiz but he crushes at least for me in the moments in his program.
I don't have Ryan (Milestone), Soto (HRD), Stanton (ASG), Robinson (Collection), Mullins (Milestone) or Julio Rodriguez HRD yet so this list is subject to change obviously.
-
POTM Jim Rice
Yeah, i said it
-
My top 5:
96 Gary carter. Seriously, nothing but homers
95 Topps Now Walsh. His home run waddle is hilarious
93 Jose altuve. I have higher rated cards but this guys rakes
93 Topps Now (POTM??) Tarik Skubal.
96 Rollie fingers. No one can touch him. -
These are some awful lists omg lol
-
Ok,dude,I’ll bite….
Who’s the top 5 in your collection, shawnzinator??
-
Randy Johson
Juan Soto
Julio Rodriguez
George Brett
Jackie Robinson -
Ryan
Feller
Yordan
Altuve
MA DeversEdit: I hit really well with 97 Miggy
-
I have every card now and have tried all the top ones.
No particular order:
Big Unit
Nolan Ryan
Mullins
Brett
HRD J-Rod/HRD Soto (tie)Honorable Mention: HRD Pujols.
I hate and never use Awards Pujols because of his terrible swing, but HRD Pujols has that super smooth Live Series old man Pujols swing. Best righty swing for me by a mile.
Edit - I can't ignore Jackie. Not a fan of his swing and yet he still puts up numbers.
-
@shawnzinator13 said in Top 5 cards in the game as of now...:
These are some awful lists omg lol
Sorry Shawnzinator, ....Alan Trammell and Casey Mize....obviously.
-
@capardo_xbl said in Top 5 cards in the game as of now...:
My top 5:
96 Gary carter. Seriously, nothing but homers
95 Topps Now Walsh. His home run waddle is hilarious
93 Jose altuve. I have higher rated cards but this guys rakes
93 Topps Now (POTM??) Tarik Skubal.
96 Rollie fingers. No one can touch him.Dude, I hated all of Gary Carter's cards last year but man do I love his 2nd half card this year. I can't keep him out of my lineup.
-
Randy
Brett
Soriano
HDR Julio
SpringerP.S. Leaving Xander off this list was very hard for me. This is why we don’t make lists with both pitchers and hitters.
-
@shawnzinator13 said in Top 5 cards in the game as of now...:
These are some awful lists omg lol
Not everybody has every card and everybody hits differently with certain players, how about instead of insulting everyone you leave your own list? Just saying
-
@samguenther1987 said in Top 5 cards in the game as of now...:
@shawnzinator13 said in Top 5 cards in the game as of now...:
These are some awful lists omg lol
Not everybody has every card and everybody hits differently with certain players, how about instead of insulting everyone you leave your own list? Just saying
He can't hear you, he's watching films of 2006 and wondering why the pitchers can't throw the ball to first base and hearing chants of ECKSTEIN....ECKSTEIN.
@Oppo_Tacoz_PSN , good call. There should be 2 lists. I thought about it because when they introduced Nolan Ryan's new card I immediately thought we had a new number 1 and then I thought the same with the JROD and Buxton HRD card.
Top 5 pitcher cards for me:
Randy Johnson- Signature
Bob Feller- Takashi
Chris Sale- Lightning
Rollie Fingers- Takashi
Corbin Burnes -AS 22I don't have Nolan yet and haven't used Fernando, Clase or any other All Star 22 cards yet. That'll all change today.
Hitter list:
George Brett- Retro Finest
Roberto Clemente- MS
Chase Utley- Prime
Yordan Alvarez- Lightning
Carlos Delgado- TakashiSame as above- haven't used and ASG 22 or HRD cards yet.
-
@ericulous1_psn said in Top 5 cards in the game as of now...:
@capardo_xbl said in Top 5 cards in the game as of now...:
My top 5:
96 Gary carter. Seriously, nothing but homers
95 Topps Now Walsh. His home run waddle is hilarious
93 Jose altuve. I have higher rated cards but this guys rakes
93 Topps Now (POTM??) Tarik Skubal.
96 Rollie fingers. No one can touch him.Dude, I hated all of Gary Carter's cards last year but man do I love his 2nd half card this year. I can't keep him out of my lineup.
Seriously, I couldn’t hit with a Carter card either. But, like you said, this one just hits everything. Even in contact that I think is an out, it is a double off the right field wall. Amazing numbers.
-
No love for Ketel Marte??
-
@oppotacoz_xbl said in Top 5 cards in the game as of now...:
Randy
Brett
Soriano
HDR Julio
SpringerP.S. Leaving Xander off this list was very hard for me. This is why we don’t make lists with both pitchers and hitters.
That Xander card is one of my best players for sure.
-
Randy
Brett
Devers P5 Lightning
Mauer 96 covers collection
Altuve 93 Monthly Awards HOT TAKE! (beastly card!) -
Randy, Brett, Jackie, Thomas, Ryan.
Honorable mentions: HRD Soto, ASG J-Rod, ASG Swanson, Clemente.
-
@ericulous1_psn said in Top 5 cards in the game as of now...:
@capardo_xbl said in Top 5 cards in the game as of now...:
My top 5:
96 Gary carter. Seriously, nothing but homers
95 Topps Now Walsh. His home run waddle is hilarious
93 Jose altuve. I have higher rated cards but this guys rakes
93 Topps Now (POTM??) Tarik Skubal.
96 Rollie fingers. No one can touch him.Dude, I hated all of Gary Carter's cards last year but man do I love his 2nd half card this year. I can't keep him out of my lineup.
I don’t hit well with carter vs righties but he absolutely destroys lefties
-
@arvay83_xbl said in Top 5 cards in the game as of now...:
Randy
Brett
Devers P5 Lightning
Mauer 96 covers collection
Altuve 93 Monthly Awards HOT TAKE! (beastly card!)Yep that Altuve has been my favorite Monthly card so far (other than Devers and Yordan).
And @StyxXx80_XBL that Ketel Marte card is incredibly versatile as always with a sweet swing. Hope he has a killer second hand so he can get a Finest
