Daily player debate: Top 3 Bosses, Bottom 3
-
Schwarber is one of those that was a W for almost everyone but I could never really get it going with him. But what a valuable card with C as a secondary and he has an awesome swing.
I always forget about Posada but his card is sneaky good too. And I love that someone gave Gary Carter some love.
-
@the_dragon1912 said in Daily player debate: Top 3 Catchers:
For me its Trout, Mays, Griffey, Mantle In that order. I've always raked with Mays while the majority of the community has not though
And to answer the first 2 days, Kaline is Meh and Woodruff. Burnes and Jake Arrieta are in close competition for most overrated cards in the game
I'm interested in this overrated comment. I am not at all contending it, just curious why you think it. I know overrated doesn't necessarily mean bad, just not reaching the lofty bar people set for them. Again, I have yet to use Burnes Finest, will probably break him out this weekend.
-
@ericulous1_psn said in Daily player debate: Top 3 Catchers:
@the_dragon1912 said in Daily player debate: Top 3 Catchers:
For me its Trout, Mays, Griffey, Mantle In that order. I've always raked with Mays while the majority of the community has not though
And to answer the first 2 days, Kaline is Meh and Woodruff. Burnes and Jake Arrieta are in close competition for most overrated cards in the game
I'm interested in this overrated comment. I am not at all contending it, just curious why you think it. I know overrated doesn't necessarily mean bad, just not reaching the lofty bar people set for them. Again, I have yet to use Burnes Finest, will probably break him out this weekend.
Everyone, and I mean everyone, talks about how good Arrieta is. Like I've heard a lot of people say he's up there with Verlander, Degrom, Ryan, etc. He is just okay at best on any difficulty but legend online. As for Burnes, he isn't as highly acclaimed, but he is always the first finest starter recommended when I think he is closer to middle of the pack
-
Ruiz, Posada, 3) Salvy i guess but I don't hit good with him so I don't really have a 3
-
I have to say of all the catcher I have used, AS Realmuto probably was the best for me. Catcher is probably the one position that rotates the most on my squad, as I can't stay consistent with a single one of them....I am fairly solid with Sal right now but who knows how long that will last. Gonna give Foxx a run at C but the defense concerns me. Adley stinks
Realmuto
Awards Posada
Perez -
Top 3 catchers for me are:
- Adley
- Foxx
- Schwarber
Salvy would've been top 3 but his defense is horrible for me even though he has good stats.
-
Top 5 Lefty relievers.
Wagner, Miller, Chapman and after that I'd say Hader TA3 and Matzek Postseason.
-
@ericulous1_psn said in Daily player debate: Great LH relievers:
Top 5 Lefty relievers.
Wagner, Miller, Chapman and after that I'd say Hader TA3 and Matzek Postseason.
Wagner, Chapman. Britton, Miller. I only believe there are 4 far above the rest. No one else comes close for me.
-
@brainfreeze442 said in Daily player debate: Great LH relievers:
@ericulous1_psn said in Daily player debate: Great LH relievers:
Top 5 Lefty relievers.
Wagner, Miller, Chapman and after that I'd say Hader TA3 and Matzek Postseason.
Wagner, Chapman. Britton, Miller. I only believe there are 4 far above the rest. No one else comes close for me.
Oh wow, I always forget about Britton.
-
Aaron Loup might be the best reliever in the entire game tbh. After him, for me, it's been Miller, Soto, Wagner, and Britton/Matzek
-
@sauciestburrito_psn said in Daily player debate: Great LH relievers:
Aaron Loup might be the best reliever in the entire game tbh. After him, for me, it's been Miller, Soto, Wagner, and Britton/Matzek
I just gave up a 2 run bomb by Loup hahaha, but that's not anything against him. He's been solid for me otherwise.
If I had to have 1 bullpen (I really like to rotate pitchers), they would be:
RH-
Goose Gossage
Kenley Jansen
Eric Gagne
Mariano RiveraLH
Billy Wagner
Andrew Miller
Aroldis Chapman
Josh HaderAlex Reyes is also right up there, and Brusdar and Matzek
-
@ericulous1_psn said in Daily player debate: Great LH relievers:
@sauciestburrito_psn said in Daily player debate: Great LH relievers:
Aaron Loup might be the best reliever in the entire game tbh. After him, for me, it's been Miller, Soto, Wagner, and Britton/Matzek
I just gave up a 2 run bomb by Loup hahaha, but that's not anything against him. He's been solid for me otherwise.
If I had to have 1 bullpen (I really like to rotate pitchers), they would be:
RH-
Goose Gossage
Kenley Jansen
Eric Gagne
Mariano RiveraLH
Billy Wagner
Andrew Miller
Aroldis Chapman
Josh HaderAlex Reyes is also right up there, and Brusdar and Matzek
How many LHP do you keep in your bullpen?
-
Wagner........ Miller and Loup. Wagner is in a league of his own as a reliever IMO. He is just lights out.
-
@the_dragon1912 said in Daily player debate: Great LH relievers:
Foxx, Piazza, Schwarber
This but for me Piazza and Foxx are about equal. I have Piazza at p4 so ive been sticking with him starting trying to get him to P5 with Foxx on bench
-
@brainfreeze442 said in Daily player debate: Great LH relievers:
@ericulous1_psn said in Daily player debate: Great LH relievers:
@sauciestburrito_psn said in Daily player debate: Great LH relievers:
Aaron Loup might be the best reliever in the entire game tbh. After him, for me, it's been Miller, Soto, Wagner, and Britton/Matzek
I just gave up a 2 run bomb by Loup hahaha, but that's not anything against him. He's been solid for me otherwise.
If I had to have 1 bullpen (I really like to rotate pitchers), they would be:
RH-
Goose Gossage
Kenley Jansen
Eric Gagne
Mariano RiveraLH
Billy Wagner
Andrew Miller
Aroldis Chapman
Josh HaderAlex Reyes is also right up there, and Brusdar and Matzek
How many LHP do you keep in your bullpen?
Depends, this bullpen is not the one I run because I change up my rosters doing division based teams or theme teams. I just picked my top 8 from those
Sometimes I'll go 4 and 4 like above. If I were to play RS at a high level, I'd probably do that.
You?
-
@ericulous1_psn said in Daily player debate: Great LH relievers:
@brainfreeze442 said in Daily player debate: Great LH relievers:
@ericulous1_psn said in Daily player debate: Great LH relievers:
@sauciestburrito_psn said in Daily player debate: Great LH relievers:
Aaron Loup might be the best reliever in the entire game tbh. After him, for me, it's been Miller, Soto, Wagner, and Britton/Matzek
I just gave up a 2 run bomb by Loup hahaha, but that's not anything against him. He's been solid for me otherwise.
If I had to have 1 bullpen (I really like to rotate pitchers), they would be:
RH-
Goose Gossage
Kenley Jansen
Eric Gagne
Mariano RiveraLH
Billy Wagner
Andrew Miller
Aroldis Chapman
Josh HaderAlex Reyes is also right up there, and Brusdar and Matzek
How many LHP do you keep in your bullpen?
Depends, this bullpen is not the one I run because I change up my rosters doing division based teams or theme teams. I just picked my top 8 from those
Sometimes I'll go 4 and 4 like above. If I were to play RS at a high level, I'd probably do that.
You?
I usually run 3 LHP, I usually need RH more.
-
If they ever release that Brad Hand from last year, that was the best lefty reliever of all time.
-
@sauciestburrito_psn said in Daily player debate: Great LH relievers:
Aaron Loup might be the best reliever in the entire game tbh. After him, for me, it's been Miller, Soto, Wagner, and Britton/Matzek
He very well could be. His delivery is glitchy. Hard to make good contact.
-
@sauciestburrito_psn said in Daily player debate: Great LH relievers:
Aaron Loup might be the best reliever in the entire game tbh. After him, for me, it's been Miller, Soto, Wagner, and Britton/Matzek
Not sure what people see in Loup. He was absolutely brutal for me, and he’s pretty easy to hit when I face him.
Didn’t see Soto mentioned. By far my best overall reliever with an era under 2 in over 50 innings.
