Old Time Players..that need to be in the game
-
Carl Yastremszki and Yogi Berra would be good as well.
-
@yankblan_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
@cjhanz84_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
Rose and shoeless joe will never be in the game.
If one gets in over the other, then Rose. He didn’t bet on his own team. Many people gamble on sports games, but shoeless joe was a straight up cheater
Except the problem was when he didn't bet for his team; what in law we call in contrario...
He never betted against his team. I have no clue where you are getting that. He admitted to betting and everything that has ever been found on it shows he only bet on his team.
-
As far as Shoeless goes, he needs to be reinstated. He was illiterate and had no idea what he was signing and his play proves he was not trying to throw the game. Shoeless was far from a cheater and in fact, has been treated egregiously by baseball.
-
@baracesilk_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
As far as Shoeless goes, he needs to be reinstated. He was illiterate and had no idea what he was signing and his play proves he was not trying to throw the game. Shoeless was far from a cheater and in fact, has been treated egregiously by baseball.
Thats why I said if anyone ever manages to raise shoeless joe from the dead his first priority won’t be making a CAP, it will be getting that person to raise Mountain Landis so he can kick the sh*t out of him. Then he’s probably going to go collect royalties from the restaurant chain that bares his name, after that, maybe he makes a CAP.
-
Cap Anson
Mordeci "3-Finger" Brown
Ed "S#it%y Batter" Dugan
Ducky Medwick
Jimmy "Huge Drunk" McGhugh
Walter "The Racist" Williams
Tris Speaker
George "Big P#%sy" O'Shea
Pete "Lead Legs" WhitemanTo name a few.
-
@baracesilk_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
As far as Shoeless goes, he needs to be reinstated. He was illiterate and had no idea what he was signing and his play proves he was not trying to throw the game. Shoeless was far from a cheater and in fact, has been treated egregiously by baseball.
Joe knew... He just wasn't a rat and it cost him.
-
@xxchaosmnkyxx_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
Rube Waddell, I always make a CAP bullpen build since classic bullpen lefties are rare. He was a starter but just one of the crazy characters of the game. Check him out
I would counter this by building a stadium near a fire station and have a doggy daycare in the outfield.
-
@baracesilk_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
@yankblan_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
@cjhanz84_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
Rose and shoeless joe will never be in the game.
If one gets in over the other, then Rose. He didn’t bet on his own team. Many people gamble on sports games, but shoeless joe was a straight up cheater
Except the problem was when he didn't bet for his team; what in law we call in contrario...
He never betted against his team. I have no clue where you are getting that. He admitted to betting and everything that has ever been found on it shows he only bet on his team.
On the days he didn't bet on his team it could be seen as betting against them.
-
@arvcpa_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
Cody Bellinger. He used to be great!
game three NLCS enough said lol
-
@cjhanz84_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
Rose and shoeless joe will never be in the game.
If one gets in over the other, then Rose. He didn’t bet on his own team. Many people gamble on sports games, but shoeless joe was a straight up cheater
The White Sox owner was a POS
-
@arvcpa_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
Cody Bellinger. He used to be great!
wut
-
@baracesilk_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
@yankblan_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
@cjhanz84_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
Rose and shoeless joe will never be in the game.
If one gets in over the other, then Rose. He didn’t bet on his own team. Many people gamble on sports games, but shoeless joe was a straight up cheater
Except the problem was when he didn't bet for his team; what in law we call in contrario...
He never betted against his team. I have no clue where you are getting that. He admitted to betting and everything that has ever been found on it shows he only bet on his team.
It isn’t hard to understand; if he didn’t bet on his team on certain days, was it because players were banged up? The SP having shoulder problems? Day game after a late night party for the team?
-
@misfits_138_1_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
Cap Anson
Mordeci "3-Finger" Brown
Ed "S#it%y Batter" Dugan
Ducky Medwick
Jimmy "Huge Drunk" McGhugh
Walter "The Racist" Williams
Tris Speaker
George "Big P#%sy" O'Shea
Pete "Lead Legs" WhitemanTo name a few.
Speaker definitely needs to be in, although he'd basically be a Cobb clone.
-
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
@cjhanz84_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
Rose and shoeless joe will never be in the game.
If one gets in over the other, then Rose. He didn’t bet on his own team. Many people gamble on sports games, but shoeless joe was a straight up cheater
The White Sox owner was a POS
This doesnt have anything to do with his personality, but most people dont realize Charlie Comiskey was also a player. His 1887 season was a fixture when constructing rosters on whatifsports.com. 335 AVG, 139 R, 103 RBI, 117 SB.
-
Roger Maris
Jackie Jenson
Ted Williams (yes, I know he was there in the past) -
@yankblan_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
@baracesilk_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
@yankblan_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
@cjhanz84_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
Rose and shoeless joe will never be in the game.
If one gets in over the other, then Rose. He didn’t bet on his own team. Many people gamble on sports games, but shoeless joe was a straight up cheater
Except the problem was when he didn't bet for his team; what in law we call in contrario...
He never betted against his team. I have no clue where you are getting that. He admitted to betting and everything that has ever been found on it shows he only bet on his team.
It isn’t hard to understand; if he didn’t bet on his team on certain days, was it because players were banged up? The SP having shoulder problems? Day game after a late night party for the team?
Or like every other person who bets in the world....you just dont bet on every [censored] game.
-
@poksey_mlbts said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
@cjhanz84_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
Rose and shoeless joe will never be in the game.
If one gets in over the other, then Rose. He didn’t bet on his own team. Many people gamble on sports games, but shoeless joe was a straight up cheater
The White Sox owner was a POS
This doesnt have anything to do with his personality, but most people dont realize Charlie Comiskey was also a player. His 1887 season was a fixture when constructing rosters on whatifsports.com. 335 AVG, 139 R, 103 RBI, 117 SB.
Everything to do with why most of the player though the 1919 WS.
-
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
@poksey_mlbts said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
@cjhanz84_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
Rose and shoeless joe will never be in the game.
If one gets in over the other, then Rose. He didn’t bet on his own team. Many people gamble on sports games, but shoeless joe was a straight up cheater
The White Sox owner was a POS
This doesnt have anything to do with his personality, but most people dont realize Charlie Comiskey was also a player. His 1887 season was a fixture when constructing rosters on whatifsports.com. 335 AVG, 139 R, 103 RBI, 117 SB.
Everything to do with why most of the player though the 1919 WS.
I gotcha. Just pointing out that he was also a player, as most people only know him as the White Sox owner, and that he had one very good season as a player.
He was an owner that was great for fans, and the city, but terrible for players.
-
@poksey_mlbts said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
@poksey_mlbts said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
@cjhanz84_psn said in Old Time Players..that need to be in the game:
Rose and shoeless joe will never be in the game.
If one gets in over the other, then Rose. He didn’t bet on his own team. Many people gamble on sports games, but shoeless joe was a straight up cheater
The White Sox owner was a POS
This doesnt have anything to do with his personality, but most people dont realize Charlie Comiskey was also a player. His 1887 season was a fixture when constructing rosters on whatifsports.com. 335 AVG, 139 R, 103 RBI, 117 SB.
Everything to do with why most of the player though the 1919 WS.
I gotcha. Just pointing out that he was also a player, as most people only know him as the White Sox owner, and that he had one very good season as a player.
He was an owner that was great for fans, and the city, but terrible for players.
agreed
-
PETE ROSE !!!!!!! ENOUGH SAID !!!!!!!
-
A admin locked this topic on
