Why won’t they make a good catcher!!
-
Jason Kendal is a beast and one of the most underrated cards in this game.
This year's game is the best ever for that position hands down
-
Gary Sanchez had a great quote it's not me it's YOU
-
Been saying since he was released JT is the best C in the game
-
I've been using the new Adley since I got him TA4. I really like him, but agree with so many of the posts here: Posada, Realmuto (TA3 and All-Star), Salvy (TA3 and HRD), Sam Huff (TA2), Grandal (TN), Schwarber (MA) are all good... I haven't really tried Carter, Pudge, or Biggio there yet. Compared to last year, I feel like there are so many viable catching options
-
What catchers we got left? Maybe a prime or sig Posey? I agree with the mass here. We got catchers. At least 10 solid options.
-
Pudge has great contact, good power, speed and elite defense. What else could you want in a catcher?
-
@knoxwurst31_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
Pudge has great contact, good power, speed and elite defense. What else could you want in a catcher?
A good swing and switch ability.
-
I rake with P5 85 Tom Murphy. Even against righties and even on HOF.
-
@ikasnu_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
@knoxwurst31_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
Pudge has great contact, good power, speed and elite defense. What else could you want in a catcher?
A good swing and switch ability.
Good swing for me. Good luck finding a true 5-tool athlete switch hitting catcher I guess!
-
@knoxwurst31_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
@ikasnu_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
@knoxwurst31_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
Pudge has great contact, good power, speed and elite defense. What else could you want in a catcher?
A good swing and switch ability.
Good swing for me. Good luck finding a true 5-tool athlete switch hitting catcher I guess!
80s pop ain't 5-tool my guy.
-
@ikasnu_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
@knoxwurst31_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
@ikasnu_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
@knoxwurst31_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
Pudge has great contact, good power, speed and elite defense. What else could you want in a catcher?
A good swing and switch ability.
Good swing for me. Good luck finding a true 5-tool athlete switch hitting catcher I guess!
80s pop ain't 5-tool my guy.
I didn't say Pudge is a 5-tool catcher. I said good luck finding someone that is. Derrrrrrrr.
-
I won't rest until we get a Sig Series Ted Simmons!
-
@doihearbossmusic said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
Been saying since he was released JT is the best C in the game
I said it from the beginning too. I hit parallel V with him a while ago. Ended up hitting 80 plus hikers with a batting average over .400. He’s throws out everyone and is almost the fastest and best player on the field at all times.
-
@bloopnablast_34_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
3 catchers I wanna see soon.. Javy Lopez, Thurman Munson, and Mauer.
You forgot Darren Daulton and Mickey Tettleton
-
@yankblan_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
@bloopnablast_34_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
3 catchers I wanna see soon.. Javy Lopez, Thurman Munson, and Mauer.
You forgot Darren Daulton and Mickey Tettleton
How about The Great Hampino?
-
@knoxwurst31_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
@ikasnu_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
@knoxwurst31_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
@ikasnu_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
@knoxwurst31_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
Pudge has great contact, good power, speed and elite defense. What else could you want in a catcher?
A good swing and switch ability.
Good swing for me. Good luck finding a true 5-tool athlete switch hitting catcher I guess!
80s pop ain't 5-tool my guy.
I didn't say Pudge is a 5-tool catcher. I said good luck finding someone that is. Derrrrrrrr.
You mentioned how he had a good swing for you, then went on to say good luck finding a 5 tool switch hitting catcher. Pretty easy to see why I thought you were talking about Pudge.
Derpa derrrrr.
-
I feel like there are some really good catchers. Pudge, Biggio, Realmuto, Salvy, Schwarber, Adley, etc. The issue is that there is not just a dominant one. All of them have a flaw of some sort. Some are slow (0 speed), some lack pop, others lack defense. But the good part of that is that it promotes variety among the teams. So you really have to focus on what do I want out of your catcher. To me Realmutto is the best well rounded. Adley is second on my list because he lacks the pop of JT but he is a switch hitter. Again personal preference. Schwarber is my bench bat forever. Last year it was a combo of Pudge, Foxx and Biggio.
-
@ikasnu_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
@knoxwurst31_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
@ikasnu_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
@knoxwurst31_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
@ikasnu_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
@knoxwurst31_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
Pudge has great contact, good power, speed and elite defense. What else could you want in a catcher?
A good swing and switch ability.
Good swing for me. Good luck finding a true 5-tool athlete switch hitting catcher I guess!
80s pop ain't 5-tool my guy.
I didn't say Pudge is a 5-tool catcher. I said good luck finding someone that is. Derrrrrrrr.
You mentioned how he had a good swing for you, then went on to say good luck finding a 5 tool switch hitting catcher. Pretty easy to see why I thought you were talking about Pudge.
Derpa derrrrr.
Not to get in a pissing match, but I also included "switch hitting" which Pudge clearly is not.
-
@ikasnu_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
@knoxwurst31_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
Pudge has great contact, good power, speed and elite defense. What else could you want in a catcher?
A good swing and switch ability.
Have you used him this year? Swing seems like it's much improved. He's been crushing it for me
-
@yankblan_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
@bloopnablast_34_psn said in Why won’t they make a good catcher!!:
3 catchers I wanna see soon.. Javy Lopez, Thurman Munson, and Mauer.
You forgot Darren Daulton and Mickey Tettleton
And Fisk.
