TA4 - Who Did You Take?
-
After doing all the collections and exchanges I went with....
Mantle, Saberhagen, Pudge, Rollins, Gibson and Hoffman.
-
I haven't had much time to play but went Seaver and Mantle first. Love the streamlined Showdown.
-
Mantle first was an easy decision being a yankee fan.
I can’t decide who to take from NL west. I opened the pack and have been going back and forth with Castilla or Hoffman…
-
@bksniper23_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
Mantle first was an easy decision being a yankee fan.
I can’t decide who to take from NL west. I opened the pack and have been going back and forth with Castilla or Hoffman…
Not to make your decision any harder but I hear Gonzalez is also really good.
-
After the exchanges my first picks were Mantle, Frank, Biggio, Sheffield, Honus, and Hoffman.
I'm going to be honest though I'm excited to try out all of them other than Saberhagen and Price(they are by far the worst two cards in the entire program). Olerud won't get much use by almost anyone but I feel like he will be really fun -
Seaver’s velocity should be much higher but I’m going with him as well.
-
@samguenther1987 said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
@bksniper23_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
Mantle first was an easy decision being a yankee fan.
I can’t decide who to take from NL west. I opened the pack and have been going back and forth with Castilla or Hoffman…
Not to make your decision any harder but I hear Gonzalez is also really good.
Lol this is going to sound sick but I still hate the guy 20 years later for the bloop single in the World Series against Rivera. Out of spite I can’t put him in the line up.
-
@kdclemson_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
@mike-forbes101_xbl said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
Adley being a catcher was a big thing for me. I also had a bit of a struggle with Mickey's swing last year.
Adley isn't even the best catcher out of these.
He 100% is.
-
@bksniper23_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
@samguenther1987 said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
@bksniper23_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
Mantle first was an easy decision being a yankee fan.
I can’t decide who to take from NL west. I opened the pack and have been going back and forth with Castilla or Hoffman…
Not to make your decision any harder but I hear Gonzalez is also really good.
Lol this is going to sound sick but I still hate the guy 20 years later for the bloop single in the World Series against Rivera. Out of spite I can’t put him in the line up.
Fair enough, for me that was one of the greatest moments ever lol sorry
-
@ikasnu_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
@kdclemson_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
@mike-forbes101_xbl said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
Adley being a catcher was a big thing for me. I also had a bit of a struggle with Mickey's swing last year.
Adley isn't even the best catcher out of these.
He 100% is.
Not better than Biggio
-
@kdclemson_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
@ikasnu_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
@kdclemson_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
@mike-forbes101_xbl said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
Adley being a catcher was a big thing for me. I also had a bit of a struggle with Mickey's swing last year.
Adley isn't even the best catcher out of these.
He 100% is.
Not better than Biggio
Switch hitter. Better by default, better overall pop too, plus has 96 blocking.
-
@ikasnu_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
@kdclemson_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
@ikasnu_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
@kdclemson_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
@mike-forbes101_xbl said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
Adley being a catcher was a big thing for me. I also had a bit of a struggle with Mickey's swing last year.
Adley isn't even the best catcher out of these.
He 100% is.
Not better than Biggio
Switch hitter. Better by default, better overall pop too, plus has 96 blocking.
Contact is more important than power, Biggio also has 85 speed lol
-
@kdclemson_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
@ikasnu_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
@kdclemson_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
@ikasnu_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
@kdclemson_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
@mike-forbes101_xbl said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
Adley being a catcher was a big thing for me. I also had a bit of a struggle with Mickey's swing last year.
Adley isn't even the best catcher out of these.
He 100% is.
Not better than Biggio
Switch hitter. Better by default, better overall pop too, plus has 96 blocking.
Contact is more important than power, Biggio also has 85 speed lol
No it really isn't, besides Biggio isn't that big of an improvement in contact over Adley. The speed is a plus I admit that, but I'd rather have the power to hit the ball out.
-
Mantle best card in the game. Honus a god. Rollins is surprisingly good, Feank two singles in 3 at bats so far,
-
This is the order of the cards I've unlocked so far:
- Frank Thomas, 1B
- Greg Maddux, SP
- Jimmy Rollins, SS
- Adley Rutschman, C
- Gary Sheffield, OF
-
Mantle and Snider were my first two. Next up is Wagner and Maddux.
-
@samguenther1987 said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
O man this has already been a great day, started at 205k, picked up Pearson because i missed out on him last year, saw matt kemp had fallen to 95k so i took him. With TA4 this evening my team has completely changed. And i still have 55k to work from
I finally picked up Jansen, I am back up around 70k. I got Mantle and Snider, Most of Sat and early Sunday I completed all the AL live Series collection for my Son. The NL I finished on Fri. With the drop in prices it was pretty easy.
-
Mantle, Thomas, Seaver, Wagner, Julio Rodriguez and Hoffman
-
@ikasnu_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
@kdclemson_psn said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
@mike-forbes101_xbl said in TA4 - Who Did You Take?:
Adley being a catcher was a big thing for me. I also had a bit of a struggle with Mickey's swing last year.
Adley isn't even the best catcher out of these.
He 100% is.
I agree. Adley is insane,
-
Is it just me or does Thomas have no power? I’ve had about 20 at bats with him and all singles so far
-
A admin locked this topic on
