Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread
-
Excellent video lots of great news!! Ty SDS!!!
-
Don’t let this distract you from the fact this game still doesn’t have collision detection.
-
@sean_87__psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
Don’t let this distract you from the fact this game still doesn’t have collision detection.
You keep posting all over forums about collision detection and how game still doesnt have it. Can you go more into detail as to what you want this feature to bring? Because i see what some might consider a form of collision detection in the video today.
-
@grizzbear55_psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@sean_87__psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
Don’t let this distract you from the fact this game still doesn’t have collision detection.
You keep posting all over forums about collision detection and how game still doesnt have it. Can you go more into detail as to what you want this feature to bring? Because i see what some might consider a form of collision detection in the video today.
Every year you see a few collisions in the field going for a fly ball right? I just want it to be a possibility that’s all. I don’t like seeing players go through each other. I think it would make the game feel more authentic. Agree or disagree?
-
@sean_87__psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@grizzbear55_psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@sean_87__psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
Don’t let this distract you from the fact this game still doesn’t have collision detection.
You keep posting all over forums about collision detection and how game still doesnt have it. Can you go more into detail as to what you want this feature to bring? Because i see what some might consider a form of collision detection in the video today.
Every year you see a few collisions in the field going for a fly ball right? I just want it to be a possibility that’s all. I don’t like seeing players go through each other. I think it would make the game feel more authentic. Agree or disagree?
Well i have never experienced a player going through another player in the 10 or 11 years i've been playing with that being said.
At some point i think it would be a cool aspect of game, but there are more pressing issues they need to work on b4 creating or piling on to other issues that are to me more priority.
-
@grizzbear55_psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@sean_87__psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@grizzbear55_psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@sean_87__psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
Don’t let this distract you from the fact this game still doesn’t have collision detection.
You keep posting all over forums about collision detection and how game still doesnt have it. Can you go more into detail as to what you want this feature to bring? Because i see what some might consider a form of collision detection in the video today.
Every year you see a few collisions in the field going for a fly ball right? I just want it to be a possibility that’s all. I don’t like seeing players go through each other. I think it would make the game feel more authentic. Agree or disagree?
Well i have never experienced a player going through another player in the 10 or 11 years i've been playing with that being said.
At some point i think it would be a cool aspect of game, but there are more pressing issues they need to work on b4 creating or piling on to other issues that are to me more priority.
Certainly are other issues, but this one is simple. I can’t believe you’ve never went for a fly ball and the computer does too, they sometimes step right through each other. It usually happens on the sky high fly outs.
-
@sean_87__psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@grizzbear55_psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@sean_87__psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@grizzbear55_psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@sean_87__psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
Don’t let this distract you from the fact this game still doesn’t have collision detection.
You keep posting all over forums about collision detection and how game still doesnt have it. Can you go more into detail as to what you want this feature to bring? Because i see what some might consider a form of collision detection in the video today.
Every year you see a few collisions in the field going for a fly ball right? I just want it to be a possibility that’s all. I don’t like seeing players go through each other. I think it would make the game feel more authentic. Agree or disagree?
Well i have never experienced a player going through another player in the 10 or 11 years i've been playing with that being said.
At some point i think it would be a cool aspect of game, but there are more pressing issues they need to work on b4 creating or piling on to other issues that are to me more priority.
Certainly are other issues, but this one is simple. I can’t believe you’ve never went for a fly ball and the computer does too, they sometimes step right through each other. It usually happens on the sky high fly outs.
Nope, animation i get is whichever one i am locked onto the other one throws both hands up and moves out of way. Sometimes closer than i like, but never gone through another player. But that doesn't mean it doesn't happen and definitely not calling you a liar, just saying i have not personally witnessed that.
-
@grizzbear55_psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@sean_87__psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@grizzbear55_psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@sean_87__psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@grizzbear55_psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@sean_87__psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
Don’t let this distract you from the fact this game still doesn’t have collision detection.
You keep posting all over forums about collision detection and how game still doesnt have it. Can you go more into detail as to what you want this feature to bring? Because i see what some might consider a form of collision detection in the video today.
Every year you see a few collisions in the field going for a fly ball right? I just want it to be a possibility that’s all. I don’t like seeing players go through each other. I think it would make the game feel more authentic. Agree or disagree?
Well i have never experienced a player going through another player in the 10 or 11 years i've been playing with that being said.
At some point i think it would be a cool aspect of game, but there are more pressing issues they need to work on b4 creating or piling on to other issues that are to me more priority.
Certainly are other issues, but this one is simple. I can’t believe you’ve never went for a fly ball and the computer does too, they sometimes step right through each other. It usually happens on the sky high fly outs.
Nope, animation i get is whichever one i am locked onto the other one throws both hands up and moves out of way. Sometimes closer than i like, but never gone through another player. But that doesn't mean it doesn't happen and definitely not calling you a liar, just saying i have not personally witnessed that.
You know what’s crazy, they had collisions like 15-20 years ago. I remember them when I was younger. Either ps1 or ps2, I can’t remember.
-
@sean_87__psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@grizzbear55_psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@sean_87__psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@grizzbear55_psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@sean_87__psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@grizzbear55_psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@sean_87__psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
Don’t let this distract you from the fact this game still doesn’t have collision detection.
You keep posting all over forums about collision detection and how game still doesnt have it. Can you go more into detail as to what you want this feature to bring? Because i see what some might consider a form of collision detection in the video today.
Every year you see a few collisions in the field going for a fly ball right? I just want it to be a possibility that’s all. I don’t like seeing players go through each other. I think it would make the game feel more authentic. Agree or disagree?
Well i have never experienced a player going through another player in the 10 or 11 years i've been playing with that being said.
At some point i think it would be a cool aspect of game, but there are more pressing issues they need to work on b4 creating or piling on to other issues that are to me more priority.
Certainly are other issues, but this one is simple. I can’t believe you’ve never went for a fly ball and the computer does too, they sometimes step right through each other. It usually happens on the sky high fly outs.
Nope, animation i get is whichever one i am locked onto the other one throws both hands up and moves out of way. Sometimes closer than i like, but never gone through another player. But that doesn't mean it doesn't happen and definitely not calling you a liar, just saying i have not personally witnessed that.
You know what’s crazy, they had collisions like 15-20 years ago. I remember them when I was younger. Either ps1 or ps2, I can’t remember.
Don't think i started till it was on ps3 but i might've played last version on ps2.
-
@grizzbear55_psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@sean_87__psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@grizzbear55_psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@sean_87__psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
Don’t let this distract you from the fact this game still doesn’t have collision detection.
You keep posting all over forums about collision detection and how game still doesnt have it. Can you go more into detail as to what you want this feature to bring? Because i see what some might consider a form of collision detection in the video today.
Every year you see a few collisions in the field going for a fly ball right? I just want it to be a possibility that’s all. I don’t like seeing players go through each other. I think it would make the game feel more authentic. Agree or disagree?
Well i have never experienced a player going through another player in the 10 or 11 years i've been playing with that being said.
At some point i think it would be a cool aspect of game, but there are more pressing issues they need to work on b4 creating or piling on to other issues that are to me more priority.
There’s a clip for that:
MLB The Show 18 pickoff collision detection required
https://youtu.be/oedyiMCfIAYMLB The Show 17 how to create the ultimate first baseman
https://youtu.be/uIReczDHwmoMLB The Show conjoined Mets
https://youtu.be/APZSjuGD5JoPlus this one is a screenshot:
MLB The Show Columbus Clippers taking team bonding to the extreme after a fielding error
https://twitter.com/red_ted_is_back/status/1311572234633318400?s=21 -
Loved all the new additions to fielding this year, only thing I didn’t see you guys talk about was fielders having more of a sense of urgency. Honestly I think adding some kind of acceleration button would be cool to add. Or maybe a quick throw addition but if you do a quick throw it lessens the green window by a lot while throwing the ball. Maybe using R2 /RT as a urgent button while running and throwing but doing so will have an impact on throw accuracy. But everything else looks amazing , can’t wait for release, keep up good work SDS.
-
@savefarris_psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
@gradekthebard said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
the completely unrealistic play where a first baseman catches a liner to first and then tags out the runner that was at first.
The baserunner is not even close to the bag in this video. In the game the base runner is near the bag when it happens.
-
@sean_87__psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
Don’t let this distract you from the fact this game still doesn’t have collision detection.
That’s one more thing to complain and worry about. We have bigger issues than that with the game. If anything, we should be thanking SDS for not adding it in.
-
I dont care about collisions. Yes, sometimes guys get close, but whatever. The thing I was watching for and didn't really see was fielder's having more of a sense of urgency. SO many situations where guys just kind of stand there, or the animation is slow to throw the ball when he should be hurrying.
-
@bhall09_psn said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
I dont care about collisions. Yes, sometimes guys get close, but whatever. The thing I was watching for and didn't really see was fielder's having more of a sense of urgency. SO many situations where guys just kind of stand there, or the animation is slow to throw the ball when he should be hurrying.
I have witnessed this but only with fielders who have lesser fielding attributes.
Are you seeing it all the time?
Are you seeing it with guys who have good fielding?
What is the reaction attribute to the player you have seen it with?
-
Wondering if Sheffield will play better defense than Machado at the hot corner...
-
@gradekthebard said in Feature Premiere - Fielding Overhaul Thread:
The only thing I care that got fixed in fielding is the completely unrealistic play where a first baseman catches a liner to first and then tags out the runner that was at first.
I rather see them fix the ability to tag runners out when they're obviously out, instead of calling them safe.
Additionally, I hope they fix the sense of urgency to get rid of the ball when the situation is appropriate instead of lollygagging getting rid of the ball.
-
One thing I didn't see in the fielding video was still a clear explanation about how to rob home runs. I think three, simple, clear examples would be great. "You should jump just after the last arrow goes green .... and push <which button the player is supposed to push>". A basic, simple example of how to rob a home-run would be great, and/or add it as a repeatable defensive play we can practice. I like the fielding video overall, yet still have no idea how to rob a home-run based on the information from the video.
-
A admin locked this topic on
