Who do you want?

[theCRIMSON_4_2_0]

1988 MVP Jose Canseco
Bernie Williams
Robin Ventura
Ron Gant
Julio Franco
Kevin Mitchell
Howard Johnson

[Bob_Loblaw1984_PSN]

Off the top of my head...

Hitters: Strawberry, Raines, Aaron, Clemente, Hundley, Caminiti, McGwire, Sosa, Bonds, Bo, Rose, Santo, A-Rod, Kent, Whitaker, Giles brothers, Javy Lopez, the Fielders.

Pitchers: Doc, Fernando, Pedro, Unit, Clemens, Koufax, Quisenberry, Randy Myers, Kevin Brown, Orosco, McGraw, Rhodes, Nelson.

[SaveFarris_PSN]

Tatis Sr .

[the_dragon1912_PSN]

I will do one for every team
Boston: Yaz
Baltimore: Frank Robinson (Could work for the reds too)
Rays: Carl Crawford
Blue Jays: Delgado
Yankees: Dimaggio
Indians: Satchel Paige
Twins: Kirby Puckett
Tigers: Magglio Ordonez/ HAnke Greenberg/ Lou Whitaker
Royals: Bo Jackson
White Sox: Carlton Fisk(Shoeless Joe isn't happening)
Angels: K Rod
A's: Jose Canseco
Mariners: A Rod
Rangers: Juan Gonzalez
Astros: Lance Berkman
Mets: Doc Gooden
Braves: Hank Aaron
Marlins: Jeff Conine
Phillies: Chase Utley
Nationals/ Expos: Tim Raines
Cardinals: McGwire
Pirates: Clemente
Brewers: Prince Fielder
Cubs: Sosa
Reds: Scott Rolen(He would probably get a cardinals card though)
Dodgers: Roy Campanella
Padres: Dave Winfield
Diamondbacks: Randy Johnson
Giants: Lincecum
Rockies: Matt Holiday

[wynsanity318_PSN]

I just want Bob Uecker itll be like the years they gave us Mendoza but more fun especially if we can replace all the announcers with Bob Uecker

[Timbino_PSN]

Pat Borders

[rAtbAby407]

Pedro Martinez.

[maurice91932_PSN]

I would say I want Dave Winfield back, but that’s the homer pick.

To satisfy the most people, though, either Roberto Clemente or Hank Aaron is a must.

For pitchers, I’d say Gooden, Pedro, Randy Johnson, or Koufax would be great additions.

Of course, all the ‘roid users would be great, as would Pete Rose, but that’s not going to happen anytime soon.

[bhall09_PSN]

I want Mark McGwire and Bo Jackson But I cant complain, I got Helton and Larry Walker this year.

[samguenther1987_PSN]

I'll also do one for every team

Baltimore - Mike Mussina
Boston - Pedro Martinez
New York AL - Derek Jeter
Tampa Bay - Carlos Pena
Toronto - Carlos Delgado/Roy Halladay

Chicago AL - Carlton Fisk
Cleveland - Manny Ramirez
Detroit - Hank Greenberg
Kansas City - Bo Jackson
Minnesota - Kirby Pucket

LA AL - Troy Glaus
Oakland - I know i said 1 each but i have to include the trio (Mulder, Zito, Hudson)
Seattle - Randy Johnson
Texas - Juan Gonzalez
Houston - Lance Berkman

[ZOMBIEKILLS_128]

I really want Ryan Howard to be in the game. Lot of first baseman but he would be mine

[samguenther1987_PSN]

Atlanta - Hank Aaron
Miami - Kevin Brown
New York NL - David Wright
Philladelpa - Chase Utley/ Ryan Howard
Washington - Tim Rains

Chicago NL - Sammy Sosa
Cincinnati - Frank Robinson
Milwaukee - Prince Fielder/Cecil Fielder
Pittsburgh - Roberto Clemente
Saint Louis - Mark McGwire

Arizona - Richie Sexson
Colorado - Andres Gallaraga
LA NL - Roy Campanella / Sandy Koufax
San Diego - Jake Peavy
San Francisco - Barry Bonds (The most obvious choice)

[MikeForbes101]

Barry Zito, Eric Chavez.

[Falconholic33]

Deion Sanders

[Falconholic33]

Bo Jackson FS

[phillydave35_PSN]

@eatyum said in Who do you want?:

Scott Rolen
Chris Carpenter
Edgar Renteria
Ray Lankford
Mark Mcgwire
Mark Mulder
Matt Morris
Rafael Furcal
Woody Williams
Placido Polanco
Mark Grudzielanek

Obviously not all these cards would be super huge impact diamonds, but those are just names I thought off.

Rolen’s high diamond should be a Phillie if we get him

[Falconholic33]

Julio Franco

[KaptinKrunch00]

Hank Aaron definitely, and even though he is a cheater, imagine a 99 barry bonds when he hit the 72 homers

[jz2016cubs_PSN]

Roberto Clemente
Ron Santo
Sosa
These are all I can think of for now.

[samguenther1987_PSN]

@KaptinKrunch00 said in Who do you want?:

Hank Aaron definitely, and even though he is a cheater, imagine a 99 barry bonds when he hit the 72 homers

It would be max stats across the board for hitting