Bagwell or Thome
-
I would say Thome, but I am partial to lefty hitters.
-
I don't like either one of them. If I had to choose, I'd go with Thome because he's a lefty bat.
-
Thome by a mile
-
Thome - and don’t think it’s super close. Bagwell has always felt kinda weird at the plate. I love thome - Babe will be moving him to the bench soon, but I see him as my LH PH for the year.
-
Bagwell easily.
Defense and speed help not clog up the base paths.
They fixed his swing, because I'm hitting everything, everywhere with him this year.
-
Killebrew
-
I platoon with both of these guys and I hit for better average with Bagwell, but more power with Thome. If you're only going to get one I would suggest Bags since he hits both lefties and righties well and also has decent speed and gold fielding.
-
@AlbinoWaffles said in Bagwell or Thome:
I platoon with both of these guys and I hit for better average with Bagwell, but more power with Thome. If you're only going to get one I would suggest Bags since he hits both lefties and righties well and also has decent speed and gold fielding.
They really did a number on Bagwell. He hits so much better than the last 4 years. I used to have to platoon, or just bench him. AS, HOF, lefty, righty. Doesn't matter. Gap shots ripped singles up the middle, power to the left and right bleachers. Just a great card all around this year.
-
Edge to Thome, lefty with 3rd base eligibility. But Bagwell has better defense and speed. So it depends how you build your team. I keep going back to Bellinger at first because of lefty and speed.
-
I have prestige thome so far he 0/8...
-
Thome hits em a mile
-
@Malikeve said in Bagwell or Thome:
I have prestige thome so far he 0/8...
0 for 8? Should probably give up on him
-
@hoboadam said in Bagwell or Thome:
@AlbinoWaffles said in Bagwell or Thome:
I platoon with both of these guys and I hit for better average with Bagwell, but more power with Thome. If you're only going to get one I would suggest Bags since he hits both lefties and righties well and also has decent speed and gold fielding.
They really did a number on Bagwell. He hits so much better than the last 4 years. I used to have to platoon, or just bench him. AS, HOF, lefty, righty. Doesn't matter. Gap shots ripped singles up the middle, power to the left and right bleachers. Just a great card all around this year.
I agree, and I don’t think many people know how good Bagwell is because there’s so many choices at 1B. If you need a righty 1B for whatever reason, he’s the guy (until gold glove frank Thomas drops Friday)
-
Thome is pretty good
-
A admin locked this topic on
