You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?
-
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@MaxHarvest said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
They will add an elite teir to the pack like they did w ducks, effectively tanking the value of the rare cards to greike and Boggs level
I strongly disagree. Those packs were released at a completely different time in the games life cycle. We are now at the place in which they release 99's. What cards could they possibly release to outdo Roberts/Ryan/Honrsby? 99 Jeter isn't walking through that door
Alomar, Kershaw, Chipper. A lot more players that will be better than the mid tier currently in the packs.
-
@Raider52Morrison said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@MaxHarvest said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
They will add an elite teir to the pack like they did w ducks, effectively tanking the value of the rare cards to greike and Boggs level
I strongly disagree. Those packs were released at a completely different time in the games life cycle. We are now at the place in which they release 99's. What cards could they possibly release to outdo Roberts/Ryan/Honrsby? 99 Jeter isn't walking through that door
Alomar, Kershaw, Chipper. A lot more players that will be better than the mid tier currently in the packs.
Just as they added a third tier to HRD, Prospects, etc? They won't, promise. Robert is the best 5 tool OF in the game right now, Hornsby is the best offensive 2b in the game right now, Nolan doesn't have the control and I don't love him, but he's a top 5 pitcher in the game.
-
That was my take too and people keep telling me I am wrong. I just don’t see how you have mid tier “rare” 99s than call other guys “elite” Tier 99s.
-
@OreoRockstar said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
That was my take too and people keep telling me I am wrong. I just don’t see how you have mid tier “rare” 99s than call other guys “elite” Tier 99s.
Those same people were telling you that there would be more cards added to DOTP and they were wrong. Just smile and move on
-
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@Raider52Morrison said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@MaxHarvest said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
They will add an elite teir to the pack like they did w ducks, effectively tanking the value of the rare cards to greike and Boggs level
I strongly disagree. Those packs were released at a completely different time in the games life cycle. We are now at the place in which they release 99's. What cards could they possibly release to outdo Roberts/Ryan/Honrsby? 99 Jeter isn't walking through that door
Alomar, Kershaw, Chipper. A lot more players that will be better than the mid tier currently in the packs.
Just as they added a third tier to HRD, Prospects, etc? They won't, promise. Robert is the best 5 tool OF in the game right now, Hornsby is the best offensive 2b in the game right now, Nolan doesn't have the control and I don't love him, but he's a top 5 pitcher in the game.
Robert is nowhere near as good as MVP trout or Mickey Mantle.
-
@DarthKDog09 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@Raider52Morrison said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@MaxHarvest said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
They will add an elite teir to the pack like they did w ducks, effectively tanking the value of the rare cards to greike and Boggs level
I strongly disagree. Those packs were released at a completely different time in the games life cycle. We are now at the place in which they release 99's. What cards could they possibly release to outdo Roberts/Ryan/Honrsby? 99 Jeter isn't walking through that door
Alomar, Kershaw, Chipper. A lot more players that will be better than the mid tier currently in the packs.
Just as they added a third tier to HRD, Prospects, etc? They won't, promise. Robert is the best 5 tool OF in the game right now, Hornsby is the best offensive 2b in the game right now, Nolan doesn't have the control and I don't love him, but he's a top 5 pitcher in the game.
Robert is nowhere near as good as MVP trout or Mickey Mantle.
I disagree completely. But if you locked in all those stubs, I can completely understand the need to justify that decision.
Trout: 90 speed 94 fielding, 89 arm, 90 acc, 93 reaction in CF
Mantle: 92 speed 87 fielding 94 arm 91 acc 99 reaction
Robert: 97 speed 97 fielding 96 arm 89 acc 94 reaction and maintains diamond fielding in all three OF spots.
And just for fun:
Pache: 92 speed, 99 fielding, 97 arm, 94 acc, 99 reaction
Pache and Robert are the only cards in the game that keep diamond fielding in all three OF spots.
Hitting is too subjective, as everyone hits differently with cards, and defense is more valuable than offense in the OF (Just ask Cbrev if you think I'm crazy).
-
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@DarthKDog09 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@Raider52Morrison said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@MaxHarvest said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
They will add an elite teir to the pack like they did w ducks, effectively tanking the value of the rare cards to greike and Boggs level
I strongly disagree. Those packs were released at a completely different time in the games life cycle. We are now at the place in which they release 99's. What cards could they possibly release to outdo Roberts/Ryan/Honrsby? 99 Jeter isn't walking through that door
Alomar, Kershaw, Chipper. A lot more players that will be better than the mid tier currently in the packs.
Just as they added a third tier to HRD, Prospects, etc? They won't, promise. Robert is the best 5 tool OF in the game right now, Hornsby is the best offensive 2b in the game right now, Nolan doesn't have the control and I don't love him, but he's a top 5 pitcher in the game.
Robert is nowhere near as good as MVP trout or Mickey Mantle.
I disagree completely. But if you locked in all those stubs, I can completely understand the need to justify that decision.
Trout: 90 speed 94 fielding, 89 arm, 90 acc, 93 reaction in CF
Robert: 97 speed 97 fielding 96 arm 89 acc 94 reaction and maintains diamond fielding in all three OF spots.
Only Pache and Robert can keep diamond in all three OF spots.
Hitting is too subjective, as everyone hits differently with cards, and defense is more valuable than offense in the OF (Just ask Cbrev if you think I'm crazy).
How does any argument for the best card in the game ignore offensive attributes as subjective? Cbrev rated Trout, Mantle and Walker ahead of Robert, right?
-
@SevisonJN said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@DarthKDog09 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@Raider52Morrison said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@MaxHarvest said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
They will add an elite teir to the pack like they did w ducks, effectively tanking the value of the rare cards to greike and Boggs level
I strongly disagree. Those packs were released at a completely different time in the games life cycle. We are now at the place in which they release 99's. What cards could they possibly release to outdo Roberts/Ryan/Honrsby? 99 Jeter isn't walking through that door
Alomar, Kershaw, Chipper. A lot more players that will be better than the mid tier currently in the packs.
Just as they added a third tier to HRD, Prospects, etc? They won't, promise. Robert is the best 5 tool OF in the game right now, Hornsby is the best offensive 2b in the game right now, Nolan doesn't have the control and I don't love him, but he's a top 5 pitcher in the game.
Robert is nowhere near as good as MVP trout or Mickey Mantle.
I disagree completely. But if you locked in all those stubs, I can completely understand the need to justify that decision.
Trout: 90 speed 94 fielding, 89 arm, 90 acc, 93 reaction in CF
Robert: 97 speed 97 fielding 96 arm 89 acc 94 reaction and maintains diamond fielding in all three OF spots.
Only Pache and Robert can keep diamond in all three OF spots.
Hitting is too subjective, as everyone hits differently with cards, and defense is more valuable than offense in the OF (Just ask Cbrev if you think I'm crazy).
How does any argument for the best card in the game ignore offensive attributes as subjective? Cbrev rated Trout, Mantle and Walker ahead of Robert, right?
he put them all in Tier 1A, so no he didn't rate them above others.
If you can't hit well with 87/94 RHP 101/108 LHP the issue isn't the card.
At the same time Robert hits LHP better than Trout (97/112).
So are those 4 points contact what make a card better or worse? Does Trouts +4 power matter with a perfect/perfect? Or does Defense not matter?
Timing window is a huge part of using cards in this game, which is directly impacted by swing speed. That is user dependent (hence the reason some rake with cards while others don't)
-
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@SevisonJN said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@DarthKDog09 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@Raider52Morrison said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@MaxHarvest said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
They will add an elite teir to the pack like they did w ducks, effectively tanking the value of the rare cards to greike and Boggs level
I strongly disagree. Those packs were released at a completely different time in the games life cycle. We are now at the place in which they release 99's. What cards could they possibly release to outdo Roberts/Ryan/Honrsby? 99 Jeter isn't walking through that door
Alomar, Kershaw, Chipper. A lot more players that will be better than the mid tier currently in the packs.
Just as they added a third tier to HRD, Prospects, etc? They won't, promise. Robert is the best 5 tool OF in the game right now, Hornsby is the best offensive 2b in the game right now, Nolan doesn't have the control and I don't love him, but he's a top 5 pitcher in the game.
Robert is nowhere near as good as MVP trout or Mickey Mantle.
I disagree completely. But if you locked in all those stubs, I can completely understand the need to justify that decision.
Trout: 90 speed 94 fielding, 89 arm, 90 acc, 93 reaction in CF
Robert: 97 speed 97 fielding 96 arm 89 acc 94 reaction and maintains diamond fielding in all three OF spots.
Only Pache and Robert can keep diamond in all three OF spots.
Hitting is too subjective, as everyone hits differently with cards, and defense is more valuable than offense in the OF (Just ask Cbrev if you think I'm crazy).
How does any argument for the best card in the game ignore offensive attributes as subjective? Cbrev rated Trout, Mantle and Walker ahead of Robert, right?
he put them all in Tier 1A, so no he didn't rate them above others.
If you can't hit well with 87/94 RHP 101/108 LHP the issue isn't the card.
At the same time Robert hits LHP better than Trout (97/112).
So are those 4 points contact what make a card better or worse? Does Trouts +4 power matter with a perfect/perfect? Or does Defense not matter?
Timing window is a huge part of using cards in this game, which is directly impacted by swing speed. That is user dependent (hence the reason some rake with cards while others don't)
He does, he separates the big 3 by a few lines and then adds the other 1A options. Al Kaline is a 1A option and so are like 7-10 others. One of the reasons he does it that way is lineup flexibility. You may need a left handed outfielder or your lineup may need a right handed option. Also, Trout and Mantle are the two toughest cards to obtain so there has to be other 1A type options available.
As far as defense goes, how many more runs is Robert going to save you over Walker, Trout or Mantle?
-
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@DarthKDog09 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@Raider52Morrison said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@MaxHarvest said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
They will add an elite teir to the pack like they did w ducks, effectively tanking the value of the rare cards to greike and Boggs level
I strongly disagree. Those packs were released at a completely different time in the games life cycle. We are now at the place in which they release 99's. What cards could they possibly release to outdo Roberts/Ryan/Honrsby? 99 Jeter isn't walking through that door
Alomar, Kershaw, Chipper. A lot more players that will be better than the mid tier currently in the packs.
Just as they added a third tier to HRD, Prospects, etc? They won't, promise. Robert is the best 5 tool OF in the game right now, Hornsby is the best offensive 2b in the game right now, Nolan doesn't have the control and I don't love him, but he's a top 5 pitcher in the game.
Robert is nowhere near as good as MVP trout or Mickey Mantle.
I disagree completely. But if you locked in all those stubs, I can completely understand the need to justify that decision.
Trout: 90 speed 94 fielding, 89 arm, 90 acc, 93 reaction in CF
Mantle: 92 speed 87 fielding 94 arm 91 acc 99 reaction
Robert: 97 speed 97 fielding 96 arm 89 acc 94 reaction and maintains diamond fielding in all three OF spots.
And just for fun:
Pache: 92 speed, 99 fielding, 97 arm, 94 acc, 99 reaction
Pache and Robert are the only cards in the game that keep diamond fielding in all three OF spots.
Hitting is too subjective, as everyone hits differently with cards, and defense is more valuable than offense in the OF (Just ask Cbrev if you think I'm crazy).
So you base that off of a few attribute points in Fielding. Did you take into account prestige trout or mantle? Trout and mantle both blow Robert out of the water in hitting. They don't even compare. The amount of stubs locked in for trout has absolutely nothing to do with it. I actually got trout and made a million stubs. No clue what a cbrev is but the fact that you compare pache to trout and mantle makes me belly laugh. Good day sir.
-
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@OreoRockstar said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
That was my take too and people keep telling me I am wrong. I just don’t see how you have mid tier “rare” 99s than call other guys “elite” Tier 99s.
Those same people were telling you that there would be more cards added to DOTP and they were wrong. Just smile and move on
Your such a snarky commenter, in every thread you just have this condescending tone. Should probably work on that.
There are a ton of guys who would be elite compared to the cards in the pack, those cards all have major weaknesses. Alomar compared to Hornsby for example
-
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@MaxHarvest said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
They will add an elite teir to the pack like they did w ducks, effectively tanking the value of the rare cards to greike and Boggs level
I strongly disagree. Those packs were released at a completely different time in the games life cycle. We are now at the place in which they release 99's. What cards could they possibly release to outdo Roberts/Ryan/Honrsby? 99 Jeter isn't walking through that door
Your statement makes a bunch of since but Jeter would suck lol...totally not a biased Sox fan that hates Jeter
-
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@Raider52Morrison said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@MaxHarvest said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
They will add an elite teir to the pack like they did w ducks, effectively tanking the value of the rare cards to greike and Boggs level
I strongly disagree. Those packs were released at a completely different time in the games life cycle. We are now at the place in which they release 99's. What cards could they possibly release to outdo Roberts/Ryan/Honrsby? 99 Jeter isn't walking through that door
Alomar, Kershaw, Chipper. A lot more players that will be better than the mid tier currently in the packs.
Just as they added a third tier to HRD, Prospects, etc? They won't, promise. Robert is the best 5 tool OF in the game right now, Hornsby is the best offensive 2b in the game right now, Nolan doesn't have the control and I don't love him, but he's a top 5 pitcher in the game.
Terribly disagree good sir.
-
I expect to go up a little. If not I'll just keep playing Hornsby. His defense is brutal but he has come up with some clutch hits for me.
-
@MaxHarvest said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@lucas8181 said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
@OreoRockstar said in You think these 99 beach ball cards will go up when packs out of store?:
That was my take too and people keep telling me I am wrong. I just don’t see how you have mid tier “rare” 99s than call other guys “elite” Tier 99s.
Those same people were telling you that there would be more cards added to DOTP and they were wrong. Just smile and move on
Your such a snarky commenter, in every thread you just have this condescending tone. Should probably work on that.
There are a ton of guys who would be elite compared to the cards in the pack, those cards all have major weaknesses. Alomar compared to Hornsby for example
I feel honored to have the king of S.A. talking down to me. I'm glad I can be part of the ever growing club!
-
A admin locked this topic on
