If a major league player tried to steal with a 5 run lead, he would take one in his ear hole his next at bat. I know this doesn't answer your question, but maybe that was the thinking. I can't steal anyway, so I've never tried it with a big lead.

I assume you are playing online because I've never seen an opposing pitcher step off without throwing to a base in franchise mode. The only thing I can figure is you are hitting the button for steal, and the runner takes off as soon as the pitcher makes a move. Base running is crazy in this game.

If a major league player tried to steal with a 5 run lead, he would take one in his ear hole his next at bat. I know this doesn't answer your question, but maybe that was the thinking. I can't steal anyway, so I've never tried it with a big lead.

No, but I do not play online. However, maybe the person you were playing knew there was a glitch, and let the ball drop on purpose, knowing the runners would try to advance. Or maybe thinking you would get confused and start your runners. I guess it worked for him through no fault of your own.

I have been having base running problems for the past few years (Playstation). Mostly with 2 outs. My runner on first will not run on the hit, but will want to return to the bag, with 2 outs. Same with runners on first and second, or bases loaded. I've tried assist base running, auto running, nothing keeps the runner from wanting to tag up with 2 outs. I have to make sure I keep mashing that L1 button as soon as I make contact. Frustrating to get forced out at second with 2 outs and a single to center.