• Categories
  • Popular
  • Dev Tracker
Skins
  • Default (The Show 26)
  • No Skin
  • The Show 23
  • Dark
  • The Show 24
  • The Show 25
  • The Show 26
Collapse
THESHOW.COM
Game Games Support Support My Account My Account

Community Forum

PriorFir4383355_XBLP

PriorFir4383355_XBL

@PriorFir4383355_XBL
About
Posts
1.4k
Topics
50
Followers
0
Following
1

Posts

Recent Best Controversial

    New ideas for MLB27
  • PriorFir4383355_XBLP PriorFir4383355_XBL

    @Shrikester22_PSN said:

    It would be awesome if your player wins MVP, they get a year taken off their rookie contract. Six years is brutal. MLB supposedly does this.

    The only rule I'm aware of in actual MLB play is the so-called "Super Two" rule, which really applies to the top 22% of players on rookie level contracts. This rule allows those on rookie contracts deemed to be in the top 22% of their peers in quality of play to qualify for salary arbitration one year earlier than there peer players deemed to be in the bottom 78%.

    The intent of the rule was to reward excellent players on rookie contracts, but the actual impact has been to encourage teams to delay MLB call up's for highly talented players in the minor leagues. This happens because one of the qualifications is that earns a minimum of 86 days of service time in the preceding season. Therefore, by delaying the player's call up, a team can essentially gain an entire year of MLB service before the super two rule kicks in.


  • New ideas for MLB27
  • PriorFir4383355_XBLP PriorFir4383355_XBL

    What SDS needs to do in order to recapture their once undisputed place as the best sports video game on the market:

    1. Physics based game engine where the human player's game control inputs rein supreme in terms of the quality of pitches, hits, and fielding. Eliminate pre-determined outcomes by eliminating RNG logic. Baseball is a simple game of physics and begs for a video game that leverages this reality. Game pad inputs should determine the location, spin rate, and velocity of a pitch. The hit should be solely determined by the actual physics of the bat to ball contact, influenced by the weather conditions. Yes, the difficulty levels should tailor the effective size of the bat's sweet spot and ease of pitch effect, but the outcomes should remain entirely physics based.

    2. Upgrade the game's graphics, not merely in terms of the quality of graphics to leverage true 4K resolution, but more important also sees the environment have true effect on the play on the field. Examples of this would be when raining, to see the field puddle, especially in the outfield, causing balls to hydroplane, or experience mud influenced drag on grounders through the infield, as well as slow runners down. Uniforms should show evidence of saturation and batting helmets and hats should show drips off the brims.

    3. True AI commentary, ending the use of pre-recorded audio statements brought up by game code. Instead, each play should organically result in originally compiled commentator audio to ensure that it is timely and accurate to what is happening. This means when the color commentator starts a long-winded statement, he shuts up immediately if an important play is developing, and the main commentator immediately describes it.

    4. In RTTS, eliminate the restrictions on equipment, making all equipment in the game freely available and having zero influence on the avatar player's performance level. Performance levels should be strictly limited to the quality of the on-the-field performance, interactions with teammates, coaches, manager and the press. Interviews with the press and coaches and manager should be audio based and present the human player with key options in reply that each carry meaningful impact of the player's development and image within the public, press, and team.

    5. Customer driven custom content must be a major focus for improvement, not merely to Stadium Creator, but also Uniform Creator and Logo Editor. These three modes have been horribly neglected. With this should also be the option to finally be able to change the uniforms, logos, and branding for all 30 teams during each offseason in Franchise, and not limit this to merely the team you are the GM for.

    6. Baseball carries the richest history of any American sport. This should be reflected in how the game can be played. Allow customers to tailor their Franchise teams for different eras of the game and be allowed to create uniforms and stadiums that accurately reflect these historic periods and make their Franchise experience an equally rich historic expression. This should go hand-in-hand with not only expanding the collegiate experience in RTTS, but also allowing the Negro Leagues to become the theme within Franchise, complete with historically accurate uniforms and stadiums.


  • Just want to point out that the YouTubers lashing out at SDS, actively promote gambling to children.
  • PriorFir4383355_XBLP PriorFir4383355_XBL

    Anyone who abuses children is someone that other good adults should have nothing to do with. I really don't know how much money these folks make off this stuff, but I'm very sure it isn't worth the price they sold their souls for.


  • MLBTS on PC - Illegal, no?
  • PriorFir4383355_XBLP PriorFir4383355_XBL

    @SiberiaTigerCub_PSN said:

    If you own a copy of the game, it is perfectly legal to play an emulated version on different hardware including PCs. This falls under legal protections to make backups of software and media.

    You need to consult an attorney at law. What you said is simply contrary to the law. You are only allowed to make copies if the terms of service you agreed to as a condition to purchase the game authorized it.

    If the copyright specifically says that you are not allowed to play the game on a PC, then you are not allowed to. If there is any question regarding this, then read the terms outlined in this contract you agreed to when installing the game:

    https://www.playstation.com/en-us/legal/software-eula/

    Even if you purchased for X-Box console, the end user license agreement still applies.

    Note specifically section 1.4 of the EULA, which reads in part: "The Software is licensed to you, not sold. You are granted a limited, non-exclusive, non-transferable, and personal license to play or use the Software for your private, non-commercial use on the system or device it was intended for."

    Again, note the final words, "use on the system or device it was intended for." It doesn't get any more clear than that folks! You either purchased the game to play on an X-Box or Playstation or Switch device. The game is not sold for use on PC's. And moreover, you do not own the game, you are merely granted a license to play the game and are required to play it according the terms in the EULA.

    That's the law folks.


  • MLBTS on PC - Illegal, no?
  • PriorFir4383355_XBLP PriorFir4383355_XBL

    @Bridge-Piece_XBL said:

    @PriorFir4383355_XBL said:

    These people are not creators. They are grafters. They grafted onto a video game an online identity, feeding their egos to the point where they now think they are larger than the video game itself. Anyone, and I mean anyone, who wraps his ego up with a video game is a troubled soul.

    Troubled souls are not the sort of people one should look to for setting a moral example!

    Maybe not to this extreme, but I see what you’re saying. I’m getting attacked by content creators on Twitter just for questioning the legality of this whole thing. Some of these guys have lost their absolute minds and seem to think they can do or say whatever they want. It’s honestly a shame.

    Does that reaction to your statements not confirm my views about them?

    There is no question about the legality of this. Tort law is quite clear on the subject. The entity that holds the copyright has the authority to determine its use. If those terms are not acceptable to you, then don't purchase the item. That's the only proper response. It is never acceptable to abuse the TOS and then attack people for pointing out that completely clear fact.


  • MLBTS on PC - Illegal, no?
  • PriorFir4383355_XBLP PriorFir4383355_XBL

    These people are not creators. They are grafters. They grafted onto a video game an online identity, feeding their egos to the point where they now think they are larger than the video game itself. Anyone, and I mean anyone, who wraps his ego up with a video game is a troubled soul.

    Troubled souls are not the sort of people one should look to for setting a moral example!


  • MLBTS on PC - Illegal, no?
  • PriorFir4383355_XBLP PriorFir4383355_XBL

    Unless SDS releases a version of the game for PC, then playing it on PC is a violation of the copyright and terms of use. Given the myriad of issues with the community market, and the reality that the problems materialized due to the ability to run hacks and bots via a PC, then despite all my serious objections to how SDS is ruining this game, I agree with their view to keep the game off PC's.


  • 5 months later and they STILL refuse to answer us
  • PriorFir4383355_XBLP PriorFir4383355_XBL

    @RoarHowl_XBL said:

    99 days still waiting

    It would be nice if your persistence paid off. But, sadly, I must say to you that it won't. You are dealing with a company that when it decides a problem with the game isn't important, they will exceed the patience of Jobe.

    Keep this reality in mind ... the Stadium Creator community had their forum moved into the one for Uniforms and Logos -- a two-group forum that had languished for several years with no visible interest by SDS. Since then, SDS has ignored all three game modes in both community forum interaction but more importantly any improvements in the three modes. That's two straight years of total ignorance by a company who has every good reason to care about the quality of their game.

    Like another person wrote. If there isn't money in it, SDS could not possible care less. Their 99% effort this year has been a perpetual seven month long frustration trying to defeat the bots that have clearly harmed the community market. SDS smells lost money and they have devoted almost all their programmer effort to that one issue, letting a myriad of other bugs and game play issues go another year without care.


  • Would anyone else love a San Diego Studio hockey game? (RTTS style)
  • PriorFir4383355_XBLP PriorFir4383355_XBL

    I play both games.

    First off, the EA NHL 27 game is light years ahead of SDS and MLB The Show. And of the two sports, my favorite by far is baseball, so if anything I am biased to embrace a baseball video game more so than a hockey video game.

    You are correct in one thing, there is no option to create your own hockey arena. But, in fairness, just like in football and basketball, the layout of a hockey ice surface is regulated such that they all look exactly the same with respect to the rules of the game. Only baseball allows each baseball venue to contain unique features that affect game play. So, Stadium Creator was a vital part of the MLB The Show game, one that was finally released with MLB 17, but has since been increasingly bypassed until since MLB 24 it has received zero additions or upgrades.

    If you found the NHL game too easy then adjust the difficulty level and sliders. As you said, your use of the sliders improved your entire team. You want to make yourself a superstar but keep the team average. OK, I understand your goal, but think of it this way, at least EA gives you the option to tweak the quality of your avatar player's team. SDS doesn't give you any such option at all.

    My take? I refused to purchase MLB 26. I have every title from MLB 21 through 25. Took a lot of neglect and outright malice by SDS to make me choose to avoid buying their game again. By contrast, I have had an excellent relationship with EA's NHL team through their community forum, able to get a few bugs fixed in quick order and their response to customers is more honest and positive than what SDS has turned into.


  • Youtubers are all going in
  • PriorFir4383355_XBLP PriorFir4383355_XBL

    Again, there are no absolutes in baseball.

    Runners on first and third and one out. Hitter strikes a sharp hit but is defended by an infielder leading to a double play to end the inning. In hindsight, a walk to load the bases would have worked better for the offense. Point is there are no absolutes in baseball. There are only probabilities and outliers with an excellent defensive play can upset even those probabilities.

    The adage "a walk is as good as a hit," has a context. It doesn't mean a walk is as good as any hit in any situation.

    Sabermetrics is also a measuring tool, nothing more and nothing less. BTW: The movie Moneyball glossed over many truths in the A's that season, and also engaged in a lot of outright lies about real people. The movie barely acknowledged the existence of the A's starting pitchers. That ignored a heck of a lot given that the game of baseball is primarily pitching and defense.

    Driving up pitch counts by trying to earn walks only works when your pitching staff keeps you in the game so that the one or two runs you can work this way can make the difference.

    Another flawed adage is that "a strikeout is just another out." This is context based. A strikeout in a first and third situation is better than a double play to end the inning. But, overall, putting the ball in play is better than walking when there are runners in scoring position, but a walk always is better than an out.

    A third adage: "There is no defense against the base on balls!"


  • Youtubers are all going in
  • PriorFir4383355_XBLP PriorFir4383355_XBL

    @PapaRick68_MLBTS said:

    Okay, I’ll bite. A walk isn’t as good as a hit? Explain. I first heard that expression when I was in Little League which was well before the dawn of sabermetrics.

    A walk will not score a runner in scoring position unless the bases are loaded, and even then, only scores one run, not two on a single. Of course, like with everything else in baseball, it's all about context, the exact nature of the hit, and the quality of the defensive fielding and your own base running.

    But, a walk is certainly as good as a single when the bases are empty, and with a runner on first.

    However, there can be a definite context where a walk can actually work better than a single -- driving up pitch count. If a string of batters force deep counts to earn walks, it can put a pitcher into a severely fatigued state with runners on first and second, increasing the odds of a mistake getting hammered for a multi-base hit.

    Baseball is beautiful because of the complexity of how plays can materialize. The odds can be measured, but never guaranteed. There are no absolutes in baseball, only events that play out uniquely.


  • Youtubers are all going in
  • PriorFir4383355_XBLP PriorFir4383355_XBL

    @TheGoaler_PSN

    It's not fear.

    It's profits. This is what happens when the federal laws against monopolistic practices are loosened to the point where so few corporations exist that they can collaborate and divide up the market into exclusive shares. They choose not to compete directly against each other because by this agreement they each enjoy a monopoly within singular sports.

    For everyone out there enamored by government control of the economy, this is a perfect time to comprehend how corporate control of even individual slivers of an economy results in lazy production and equally tone deaf refusal to work hard for customer loyalty.


  • Too many verification attempts
  • PriorFir4383355_XBLP PriorFir4383355_XBL

    Two things here I cannot comprehend. First, if SDS devoted one tenth of the human talent and resources to upgrading the custom content modes of this game (Stadium Creator, Uniform Creator, and Logo Editor), it would make a far more beneficial impact on the game than the community market.

    Second, after several months of near relentless focus, the bots appear to not only be winning the battle, but causing SDS to further anger customers through overly restrictive applications.

    I'm not faulting SDS for trying to win the good fight. I'm certainly condemning those people who employ bots and other cheat code options to harm the game. But, at the root of all this comes this unalterable fact. This is supposed to be a baseball video game and not some effort to emplace a virtual model of commodity trading.

    Perhaps one day, SDS's leadership will make Sony executives appreciate that reality and allow them the resources needed to make long overdue upgrades to this video game.


  • Too many verification attempts
  • PriorFir4383355_XBLP PriorFir4383355_XBL

    In my military career, when discussing training counter tactics in tactical aviation, we often reminded ourselves of an elemental truth: "Don't do the enemy's job for them!"

    Meaning, don't get so aggressive at flying low, that you impact the ground and destroy your own airplane, thereby doing the enemy's job for them.

    The BOTS have a central goal of denying the community market from legitimate use. Denying legitimate customers use of the market does the job of these people who employ these BOTS.


  • How do you motivate yourself to keep playing this mode when scripting and rubber banding ultimately decide your stats?
  • PriorFir4383355_XBLP PriorFir4383355_XBL

    Everything that's been correctly addressed as a fundamental flaw in the game code (such as this OP) is rooted in one motivation -- to perpetuate the online competition mode.

    The solution to this, and all the other problems, is for the game to stop trying to be something other than the best possible video game simulation of actual baseball games.

    Equal outcomes is the mortal enemy of sports.

    That deserves repeat ... equal outcomes is the mortal enemy of sports.

    Sports are the ultimate expression of the measurement of human skill. Your skills with the game control pad should be the only determining factor when it comes to wins and loses. If someone can develop the skills to go 162-0, then so be it. It is up to the customer himself to determine if his definition of happiness playing this game requires an increase in difficulty level. It should never be the game code that determines that for the customer.

    SDS is destroying itself by yielding itself to profits above quality, and equality above merit.


  • Worst L&F Drop Ever
  • PriorFir4383355_XBLP PriorFir4383355_XBL

    My view on this is that SDS long ago sold their soul to morph a baseball video game into something, more like a virtual commodity trading site. The problem is that doing that has also changed the focus of a number of customers, from discussing the actual quality of the game itself in terms of how the game engine and graphics replicate the real game of baseball, and into the quality of virtual trinkets.

    Concepts like improving how players look in the game, how the ball reacts to the grip, rotation, and velocity of the pitcher, and how the bat reacts to the ball -- those are the areas that need focus. This because SDS has fallen well short of where today's sports video games are at.

    You play MLB The Show and the presentation is soulless. It rains in the game and all the players look like they are playing in sunshine. The field lacks all concept of being wet, no influence on the ball and certainly no rain effects like splashes, mud, or rooster tails. Other sports video games played outdoors? The rain impacts how the gameplay flows, you see rain caused effects, not only on physical appearances, but most critically on how objects interact.

    So, with respect, when I see so many threads devoted to the quality of player cards, and see so few discussing the antiseptic nature of the actual game, it makes me sad.


  • Worst L&F Drop Ever
  • PriorFir4383355_XBLP PriorFir4383355_XBL

    There has been absolutely NOTHING written in this thread that in any way justifies anyone insulting another. There are some people at this forum who need to grow up and accept being able to read things they may not agree with without coming across in a condescending tone.


  • For the final time this year…
  • PriorFir4383355_XBLP PriorFir4383355_XBL

    When was the last time SDS actually surprised us in a positive way by exceeding expectations?

    The solution is clear and without replacement -- stop buying this game and force SDS to either upgrade or go out of business.


  • SDS LITERALLY STOLE FROM ME AND SAID SO WHAT?!?!
  • PriorFir4383355_XBLP PriorFir4383355_XBL

    Yes and no. In a purely moral sense, it is theft. They robbed you of your time by dangling something you wanted in front of you and then reneging on the deal. Whether intentional or accidental, it is still theft in that regard. But, in a legal sense, the items have no value and the currency has no value and therefore, per the terms of law, there is no theft at all.

    To be theft, the items denied have to have actual value. Now, if you paid currency for these stubs, then I hope you learned how your hard earned money is worth far more than this virtual junk that SDS is peddling, and shame on SDS for continuing to do this.

    I'm no fan of SDS. I stopped being one a few years ago. They need to just get back to making a baseball video game that is the very best at replicating the actual game of baseball, not some junk version of the New York Stock Exchange and Macy's! SDS has obsessed this year on one thing and one thing only -- trying to defeat the bots that have harmed the profits they calculate they can derive from the community market. If SDS had put a fraction of that work into fixing the myriad of bugs in the game and crafting actual improvements in the game engine and graphics, then we might have a game worth buying!

    Everyone should take good heed of your experience. I think you've been treated horribly and SDS needs to take this experience seriously. But, the customers need to take it more seriously and answer it by refusing to patronize this game until it stops trying to be something other than a plain high quality baseball video game.


  • SDS LITERALLY STOLE FROM ME AND SAID SO WHAT?!?!
  • PriorFir4383355_XBLP PriorFir4383355_XBL

    My take on this might be a bit unusual, but I think of this again as the trinkets that SDS dangles for purchase are precisely worthless junk purchased by worthless pseudo currency. The only actual investment on your part was the time you spent earning the stubs.

    This is why people need to get back to some good old-fashioned common sense. You buy a video game to play the game to have fun. It is not supposed to serve as some grand experiment in financial transactions. And yet, that's exactly what SDS has turned their once marvelous baseball video game into -- some junk post sale transaction hub, selling and buying worthless junk with worthless junk fake currency.

    What should you do?

    Ask yourself a basic question. Do you enjoy actually playing the baseball games presented in this baseball video game? If the answer is yes, then play those games and completely forget about these micro transactions. If the answer is no, then stop playing the game and never purchase another release until SDS stops this nonsense and puts their own old-fashioned hard work into making their game the best it can be.

X Instagram Facebook YouTube Twitch Discord TikTok
Major League Baseball Players Association Major League Baseball Sony Interactive Entertainment PlayStation Studios San Diego Studio ESRB ESRB Certificate
Terms of Use Privacy Policy TheShow.com Community Code of Conduct MLB The Show Online Code of Conduct MLB The Show Games

“PlayStation Family Mark”, “PlayStation”, “PlayStation Studios logo”, “PS5 Logo”, and “Play Has No Limits” are registered trademarks or trademarks of Sony Interactive Entertainment Inc. ©2026 Sony Interactive Entertainment LLC. MLB and MiLB trademarks and copyrights are used with permission of Major League Baseball. Visit MLB.com and MiLB.com. Officially Licensed Product of MLB Players, Inc. MLBPA trademarks, copyrighted works and other intellectual property rights are owned and/or held by MLBPA and may not be used without the written consent of MLBPA or MLB Players, Inc. Visit MLBPLAYERS.com, the Players Choice on the web. The Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum trademarks and copyrights are used with permission of the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, Inc., as applicable. Visit the official website of the Hall of Fame at BaseballHall.org. Official Licensee-Major League Alumni Marketing, Inc. © MLAM. Officially Licensed by the Negro Leagues Baseball Museum, Inc. Kansas City, MO. Stubs is a registered trademark or trademark of Sony Interactive Entertainment LLC. Nintendo Switch is a trademark of Nintendo. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.

  • Login

  • Login or register to search.
  • First post
    Last post
0
  • Categories
  • Popular
  • Dev Tracker
  • Login

  • Login or register to search.