@foofencer_nsw said in I’m sure this has been discussed… but please help.:
I'm in a similar boat. I played 21 on PS5, and got the digital deluxe version of 22 on Switch. I will also be playing 22 on Game Pass.
I linked and made the Switch the primary, but that caused me to lose all of my progress on 21. As far as I can tell, no one at SDS took a moment to think about what would happen if someone had a different primary console from year to year. I was able to get the PS5 progress back by unlinking, but it is now impossible for me to link PS5 and Switch without losing progress on either 21 or 22.
I currently just have Switch and Xbox on the MLB linked account. It shows my cards when I log in for Xbox on the app, but I can't know for sure that it worked until midnight. They've said preorder bonuses don't transfer. I'm hoping I'm still good since the packs were opened and they show up on my squad in the app. If those cards are missing when I log onto Xbox, I'm going to be pissed.
What a conundrum! I never thought about the past games but that makes sense because it's by account, not by game.
The bonuses won't transfer but the FAQ and the video say that the full inventory will be available across platforms. Of course, that means that whichever account you have your inventory on must be your primary account for that to happen.
I'm supposed to get a gold pack with my Switch preorder and it is sounding like it's pointless because my PS account will be my primary account and only my inventory from there will be shared. At least it's just a few gold cards, which I'll eventually stop using anyway.