I want to honestly see if normal swing may be holding me back. On why I can’t even touch the ball.
I just can't find consistency online at all. I mainly play Events and BR. Been facing Nolan and Crochet a lot in the event and I go from facing someone who uses them well and mixes things up...yet I still am squaring things up, getting hits and scoring runs. Then I run into someone who is very predictable and I know where the fastball is going...set my PCI up and and wait for it and swing the second it leaves the hand...yet I am late. It just seems to change game to game.
As for your contact swing thing...since right now you are playing on All Star, why not play a few event games and test it out? All legends are fair game right now, so most teams are not too different than teams you will see in RS right now. You are going to see Nolan, Leiter, Lee, Vlad, Chipper, Jackie, Walker, etc. But that way you can do your experiment without worrying about your ranking in RS.