Hitting is not broken?

SDS

Edgar Martinez...

https://youtu.be/z-BenmZrOHc

Good/good with an exit velo of 4mph lower than the 98mph FB.

SDS

C’mon we all know Edgar has always had a noodle bat in this game. Also you didn’t square it up. Why should you be handed a home run or extra base hit for a ball you didn’t square up with a guy notoriously known for not having power? Not trying to downplay your complaint but I’ve seen wayyy worse than this.

SDS

You did not entirely square that ball up and Edgar has mid 80's power...

SDS

I know I’m gonna get a lot of flak for saying this but:

I actually don’t think that ball was barrelled up very well. I know the swing feedback said good/good but if you pause the video, your PCI wasn’t even close to touching the ball when you made contact. Honestly, based off where your PCI was, it should’ve been a pop up.

SDS

@VEGAS__T said in Hitting is not broken?:

C’mon we all know Edgar has always had a noodle bat in this game. Also you didn’t square it up. Why should you be handed a home run or extra base hit for a ball you didn’t square up with a guy notoriously known for not having power? Not trying to downplay your complaint but I’ve seen wayyy worse than this.

You mean like the early/okay no doubters? Lmao

SDS

@carey_56 said in Hitting is not broken?:

I know I’m gonna get a lot of flak for saying this but:

I actually don’t think that ball was barrelled up very well. I know the swing feedback said good/good but if you pause the video, your PCI wasn’t even close to touching the ball when you made contact. Honestly, based off where your PCI was, it should’ve been a pop up.

So you agree hitting is broken if the feedback can't match the action.

I'm not complain about the result so much as the hitting engine making relatively little sense.

SDS

@aaronjw76 said in Hitting is not broken?:

@VEGAS__T said in Hitting is not broken?:

C’mon we all know Edgar has always had a noodle bat in this game. Also you didn’t square it up. Why should you be handed a home run or extra base hit for a ball you didn’t square up with a guy notoriously known for not having power? Not trying to downplay your complaint but I’ve seen wayyy worse than this.

You mean like the early/okay no doubters? Lmao

I was actually referring to this...

https://youtu.be/FvBvdwG2Tx4

But the early/okay HRs are just as bad lol (unless I’m hitting them then they are completely justified)

SDS

@carey_56 said in Hitting is not broken?:

I know I’m gonna get a lot of flak for saying this but:

I actually don’t think that ball was barrelled up very well. I know the swing feedback said good/good but if you pause the video, your PCI wasn’t even close to touching the ball when you made contact. Honestly, based off where your PCI was, it should’ve been a pop up.

No flak here ive noticed the pci moves after hitting the ball i usually hit in a specific part of the zone where i know my opponent is gonna throw said pitch and it happens all the time it'll move slightly right while im holding the pci for no apparent reason other than the little billy coding

SDS

@SMASHED_THAT said in Hitting is not broken?:

@carey_56 said in Hitting is not broken?:

I know I’m gonna get a lot of flak for saying this but:

I actually don’t think that ball was barrelled up very well. I know the swing feedback said good/good but if you pause the video, your PCI wasn’t even close to touching the ball when you made contact. Honestly, based off where your PCI was, it should’ve been a pop up.

No flak here ive noticed the pci moves after hitting the ball i usually hit in a specific part of the zone where i know my opponent is gonna throw said pitch and it happens all the time it'll move slightly right while im holding the pci for no apparent reason other than the little billy coding

Only time pci moves on zone for me is if I'm early or late. If I’m early they move it up and if I’m late they move it down. If you are claiming they move it on good timing for “little billy” reasons I would have to disagree

SDS

@JFazNYY13 said in Hitting is not broken?:

You did not entirely square that ball up and Edgar has mid 80's power...

Care to explain this one then?

https://youtu.be/pXX2-CbvYCQ

SDS

@aaronjw76 said in Hitting is not broken?:

@JFazNYY13 said in Hitting is not broken?:

You did not entirely square that ball up and Edgar has mid 80's power...

Care to explain this one then?

https://youtu.be/pXX2-CbvYCQ

Easily...they both went around the same distance but one was hit down the line and one was hit to the furthest gap in the ballpark. Both went probably around 380ft but one was hit in a better area than the other.

SDS

Not saying that hitting is good (or anywhere close to it) but this is a poor example. This is veteran difficulty vs. the CPU. And like others have said, there are far worse examples of good input not generating good results

SDS

Yep but good okays are flying outta the ball park

SDS

If this was on HoF online you might’ve swung and missed lol

SDS

Reading the family and friends of SDS defend posts is hilarious.

SDS

Thats like a 12/15 on the PCI contact thingy so it's not a guareenteed HR

SDS

@WorstVikingEver said in Hitting is not broken?:

Reading the family and friends of SDS defend posts is hilarious.

These are becoming just as bad and annoying as the “get gud” trolls ive seen you complain about. I gave him logic and valid reasons for both his videos and even included my own video of bad gameplay. Not defending SDS just calling out bs when I see it.

SDS

@VEGAS__T said in Hitting is not broken?:

@WorstVikingEver said in Hitting is not broken?:

Reading the family and friends of SDS defend posts is hilarious.

These are becoming just as bad and annoying as the “get gud” trolls ive seen you complain about. I gave him logic and valid reasons for both his videos and even included my own video of bad gameplay. Not defending SDS just calling out bs when I see it.

Perfect perfect line outs and jammed late hits. Games broken not attacking you. games broken

SDS

@WorstVikingEver said in Hitting is not broken?:

@VEGAS__T said in Hitting is not broken?:

@WorstVikingEver said in Hitting is not broken?:

Reading the family and friends of SDS defend posts is hilarious.

These are becoming just as bad and annoying as the “get gud” trolls ive seen you complain about. I gave him logic and valid reasons for both his videos and even included my own video of bad gameplay. Not defending SDS just calling out bs when I see it.

Perfect perfect line outs and jammed late hits. Games broken not attacking you. games broken

No. It's not. Your expectations suck.

SDS

@WiryHooligan22 said in Hitting is not broken?:

@WorstVikingEver said in Hitting is not broken?:

@VEGAS__T said in Hitting is not broken?:

@WorstVikingEver said in Hitting is not broken?:

Reading the family and friends of SDS defend posts is hilarious.

These are becoming just as bad and annoying as the “get gud” trolls ive seen you complain about. I gave him logic and valid reasons for both his videos and even included my own video of bad gameplay. Not defending SDS just calling out bs when I see it.

Perfect perfect line outs and jammed late hits. Games broken not attacking you. games broken

No. It's not. Your expectations suck.

@WiryHooligan22 said in Hitting is not broken?:

@WorstVikingEver said in Hitting is not broken?:

@VEGAS__T said in Hitting is not broken?:

@WorstVikingEver said in Hitting is not broken?:

Reading the family and friends of SDS defend posts is hilarious.

These are becoming just as bad and annoying as the “get gud” trolls ive seen you complain about. I gave him logic and valid reasons for both his videos and even included my own video of bad gameplay. Not defending SDS just calling out bs when I see it.

Perfect perfect line outs and jammed late hits. Games broken not attacking you. games broken

No. It's not. Your expectations suck.

You family or friend wont lose their job at SDS calm down kitten