Times SDS Lied to Us This Year
-
PCI shrinkage and collections are the two biggest lies for me that they need to come out and address. It’s not even that I’m a top player or anything, just wondering how that got fumbled so bad. Also like to hear if there is a decision about removing the card cap for just Live Series.
-
I remember being excited in the prerelease stream when they said mini seasons stats were fixed.
They also said there would be more unique format ones besides just WBC
They also said The Show Live would be back after all star break (I dont care about that one as much)
-
I'll also say about the Finest exchanges: you can see my thread on these. Im playing fairly casually and handicapping myself and on my way to earning them through gameplay
If I allowed myself to trade in the two no sell cards from the playstation pass and the 5 diamonds I got from the last roster update I would have 3 of the 4 finished through gameplay (conquest, mini seasons, only playing a couple days a week, fairly average luck)
The weekend classic cards and Soto chase are more player unfriendly than the exchanges, which combined would cost less than any single one of those, although the WC ones should come down this weekend.
And you dont need the cards for the collection anyway
The overreaction to this in my mind is over the top. The three separate packs was significantly worse.
-
@Teak2112_MLBTS
It's not even that. It's the idea that you're paywalling cards in November for no reason. Every card should be unlockable by playing to some degree. If one card is behind an exchange, no problem. Even if 4 are, at least have them stack on each other. If you get one, you get the other. It is November. You're never gonna touch any of this again in 3 months. Though I do agree that the packs are egregious but they didn't really lie about that. -
Those cards arent remotely paywalled. Its under 200k for all of them combined even if you are impatient. In the time Ive made progress on those cards, I have also earned 200k from selling golds and the deluxe pack dupes only.
What makes even less sense is you put this under play your way...when these are cards I am actually able to earn from playing my way. I can get these cards without touching online modes, forced difficulty, or the market. Thats all I really ask from 'play your way'.
I am not saying tis good content, but its also not remotely close to any reasonable definition of 'paywall'.
There are plenty of things SDS did lie to us about, when you lie yourself in the same post that hurts the chances SDS takes you seriously.
-
Depends on your definition of paywall.
For some it means real money for others it just means that it requires a large amount of stubs.
I see both sides of the argument. And I do not see paywall and pay to win as synonymous. The game is not pay to win. But when pressed and when I was trying to get the 5 Cardinals chase cards and 2 headliners that all came out within a short period, that felt paywalled
-
Pay to win is an ambiguous term.
Paywall shouldnt be ambiguous, it is specifically you don't get the cards without paying.
2K paywalls: their paid pass has a lower tier exclusive card and their festival model requires buying cash shop only packs (and LOTs of them) to obtain the meta cards
In my view grinding stubs to buy cards is a terrible model that just feels bad, even if its not an unreasonable amount of time spent. While I invested time into getting the stubs, I still am left with cards that i do not feel I earned so I rarely want to use them, its such a hollow feeling.
And it could be worse: you could be a Reds fan and get your best player unobtainable to 75% of the playerbase one year and behind the biggest collection in the game the next year. As a Mets fan it sucks knowing Beltran will always be behind some nonsense (maybe next year have his inevitable meta collection/wbc reward be a Royal since they got a good free one last year)
-
Also the misinformation int he OP:
They never banned the WBC exploiters. They lied about it, but they never did it.And honestly WBC exploit and stub selling sites are both worse than outright cheating: one impacts the outcome in a 1:1 game, the other hurts the entire playerbase through market inflation and removal of things like IPs as a way to complete the ranked program. All of it though deserves lifetime IP bans, but easier said than done.
-
For offline players, I can add a couple.
For Stadium Creator, when they were asked via this site and directly via email about whether they would improve anything or address the many asks for that tool, they responded with essentially a 'wait for an upcoming announcement about Stadium Creator' that was done in a manner that something good was coming. The announcement they were talking about was the "reset" that there would be no carryover of the Vault to the Show 26. Essentially, they punished the users of Stadium Creator (players online and offline, or creators/users only of that tool) for the stuff that online cheaters and cheating "grinders" did with Lagrassa.
SDS did their latest on the day they released their statement in preparation for The Show 27. That statement talked about doing better with communication. However, on the day the statement is released, they wipe out (purposely or accidentally or a hack) all newer logos in the Vault, and the entire Stadium Vault of old stadiums in version 25 and earlier were entirely wiped out, even though SDS pretty much assured last year that the stadiums in the older versions would remain there. Either they lied, or there is an issue that they are not communicating to everyone about that essentially makes their latest statement a lie because there is still no better job of communication to all of the fans of the game.
Where is the communication about why newer logos are gone from the Vault and where is the communication about why all the stadiums in the old Vault are gone?
-
@Teak2112_MLBTS
Paywall and pay to win are not the same things. Many people consider massive collections (live series for example) as paywalls. Doesn’t mean you have to spend a whole lot of money, but it’s behind a large amount of in-game stubs, so I don’t get your point about SDS not taking anyone seriously because I’m not lying, unlike them. -
@teak2112_mlbts
You might be right about the WBC bans. I don't know if NOBODY got banned but there's no real evidence anyone did get banned.