Youtubers are all going in
-
I agree that it is not pay to win. I've been saying that for years
But on the NMS front it is a matter of perspective. Maybe it's easier than before but I still would not say easy.
It requires some combination of flipping, investing, pack luck and skill. Offline players are hindered by everything they earn being "No Sell". Meanwhile online players get to sell all of those rewards
Part of the reason this game is NMS friendly is skill has a big advantage, and great cards aren't an effective crutch if you don't have the skill. If you are easily fooled into swinging at pitches outside of the zone or cant catch up to inside heat better cards arent going to solve that. If you are predictable with your pitches even someone like me will start smacking you around by the 6th inning.
Completing the big collections NMS requires dedication for sure, but you can make WS without collection cards.
-
Okay, for whatever reason Koogs video popped up on YouTube when I loaded it, so I watched it.
It may be a negative video, but he makes valid points and backs it up.
Of course as everyone is complaining about packs this year I find myself wondering where these complaints were for the previous versions. I know I posted about it several years ago. Back when they hid Matt and Jackson Holiday in a special pack instead of in the fathers day program like the other cards (MLB 23 and Diamond Duo Packs).
SDS has been heading this direction for years. Shouting at the driver of the vehicle that you don't want to go to a destination is pointless after you have already arrived.
-
In 2023 the programs had 10+ cards along with way more packs than we currently get, the inning path had more than single ballins and shows, ALL of the topps Now cards were in programs, same with the monthly awards. Collections rarely needed pack cards if you did all the content. Chase cards were once a month. TA existed.
Now not only have pack cards increased (THREE different types of weekly packs with chase, headliner and spotlight on top of the expanded deluxe pack system) and the programs are a shell of what they used to be.
On top of this, we have the shrinkage fiasco and the WBC exploit and the game doesnt play as well it did in most people's eyes as it did in 23/24
Had the content and gameplay improved people would be more forgiving.
-
What, I am saying though is that their were hints way back then.
Here is my post from 2023
There has always been two ways to get cards in this game. Time or Money.
But there is little doubt that this year that they have changed their approach and it now takes even more time or even more money.
There have been 27 Duo packs which means that 54 99 overall diamonds have been locked in packs. In that time we have had 15 (?) 99 overalls introduced through the Xp program. The vast majority of the remaining 99's are collection rewards, which I am guessing most players never complete. So this leads people to come to the conclusion, rightfully so, that SDS/Sony is getting greedier.
Then there are the reduced stub payouts across the board. The current weekly wonders has no stub rewards. It is, I believe, made up of no sale equipment, one regular pack and one Duos pack. So stubs are reliant on pack luck. Then at some point this season they decided that the break even point in showdowns needed to be after you defeat six bosses when before that it was after four bosses. Guaranteeing that more people lose stubs playing these.
So, neither side in this debate is wrong. You can still get most of everything for free but that will require a lot of time playing the game, some time flipping or investing in cards is probably needed as well. But on the flip side those who do not have that kind of time or devotion are actually having a harder time earning cards than they have in the past.
It's a matter of which perspective you view this situation from.
-
I think people have always been sounding the drum about the increase in packs, and people are particularly loud whenever something is no sell that wasn't in the past
If I recall the packs were out of hand early in 2024 to the point they gave a program in response to the complaints that was all packs at the end of inning 1 (and then never did it again the rest of the year). They throw the bone, then people seem to forget about it for a while. They tried it with packapalooza again this year, to lesser effect.
They have actually hit a pretty good balance in the ramp up of the monetization (to the detriment of the players of course) which has lessened the backlash to a degree, but now the goodwill in other parts of the total package has dried up so players aren't being as easily distracted
-
they seem to copy each other but at least they're saying the truth. i don't follow or know many of these guys but they show up on my youtube feed from time to time.
Like I said many many times the last 3 years, once this new management took over and soft fired Ramone and the other 2 guys who use to be the community face of this series, the game has gone to trash. Some of the youtubers have finally caught onto that and are saying it out loud.
There was another guy I saw who was describing I think back for MLBTS 19 he was invited out to SDS to get feedback since MLBTS 18 was so bad for DD. He said back then they actually listened but at one point in the video, he described how the suits came down to see what was going on and all the devs got nervous and it felt like pins and needles. And he noticed this back in 2019! Now w/ this new group that took over 3 years ago, I'm sure it's worse where the devs can't stand up for themselves and maybe are contriubting to the downfall now.
They want to be madden/2k so bad since they see the revenue those two games generate.
-
they seem to copy each other but at least they're saying the truth. i don't follow or know many of these guys but they show up on my youtube feed from time to time.
Like I said many many times the last 3 years, once this new management took over and soft fired Ramone and the other 2 guys who use to be the community face of this series, the game has gone to trash. Some of the youtubers have finally caught onto that and are saying it out loud.
There was another guy I saw who was describing I think back for MLBTS 19 he was invited out to SDS to get feedback since MLBTS 18 was so bad for DD. He said back then they actually listened but at one point in the video, he described how the suits came down to see what was going on and all the devs got nervous and it felt like pins and needles. And he noticed this back in 2019! Now w/ this new group that took over 3 years ago, I'm sure it's worse where the devs can't stand up for themselves and maybe are contriubting to the downfall now.
They want to be madden/2k so bad since they see the revenue those two games generate.
That was Shelfy who mentioned being invited to SDS. And hey, that got us those Show Partners programs, which were just a collection of moments that would unlock a card. MVP Bryce was one of the rewards, completely free, an endgame card and it just required a few moments.
-
I agree that it is not pay to win. I've been saying that for years
But on the NMS front it is a matter of perspective. Maybe it's easier than before but I still would not say easy.
It requires some combination of flipping, investing, pack luck and skill. Offline players are hindered by everything they earn being "No Sell". Meanwhile online players get to sell all of those rewards
Skilled players can make bank rerunning Diamond Quests and selling rewards while those with lesser skills may have to run it multiple times just to get 1 card.
Flipping and investing is fine way to get stubs but I am not going to do it I bought this game to play some baseball now and again not to spend my time on the marketplace or gambling my stubs that a player gets a deserved upgrade (waves at Jordan Walker).
So easier? Maybe.
Easy? Not for everyone.It’s not pay to win for sure. You can field a team that can compete with any cards for free in a couple of hours starting from zero on a new account.
The topic of discussion is about completing collections, not pay to win.
-
I watched Fuzzy. Less impressed at his video because he condemned SDS for banning the WBC exploiters. First of all, I am still not convinced that they actually banned anyone for that. Secondly, anyone who uses the logic that it was justified or that players should not be punished for exploiting it because it was SDS' mistake loses credibility in my book
-
I watched Fuzzy. Less impressed at his video because he condemned SDS for banning the WBC exploiters. First of all, I am still not convinced that they actually banned anyone for that. Secondly, anyone who uses the logic that it was justified or that players should not be punished for exploiting it because it was SDS' mistake loses credibility in my book
He doesn’t even play the game so shouldn’t make judgements. All the content creators are just copying each other. It’s silly. Now the new thing is talking about the illegal PC version someone made, with them not realizing it’s illegal.
-
Since I was watching these I went ahead and watched Shelfy. Another decent one that makes some good points.
All the content creators are just copying each other. It’s silly.
It's not Silly. Maybe Fuzzy's was because he hasn't really played this year but overall Koogs and Shelfy made good points.
It's not Youtube drama for the sake of YouTube drama. These guys did not build their audiences on being negative about the game.
Many people here, myself included, come to the forums to share our opinions, good or bad, because this is our audience. So are we really any different than the streamers and YouTubers? Or are we mad that they have spent years building up an bigger audience who will listen to their opinions.
-
Since I was watching these I went ahead and watched Shelfy. Another decent one that makes some good points.
All the content creators are just copying each other. It’s silly.
It's not Silly. Maybe Fuzzy's was because he hasn't really played this year but overall Koogs and Shelfy made good points.
It's not Youtube drama for the sake of YouTube drama. These guys did not build their audiences on being negative about the game.
Many people here, myself included, come to the forums to share our opinions, good or bad, because this is our audience. So are we really any different than the streamers and YouTubers? Or are we mad that they have spent years building up an bigger audience who will listen to their opinions.
I’ll admit I haven’t watched these specific videos, but I unfollowed most creators this year because the constant negativity became exhausting. I still see their posts, and it feels like there’s a new complaint every day. We’re making videos complaining about Shane Baz getting a Finest card now? Come on.
This isn’t my favorite version of The Show either, but I still enjoy playing it. There’s a difference between constructive criticism and complaining for clicks. At some point, it feels like everyone is just recycling the same negativity.
And no, I don’t think the forums are the same. Most people here genuinely want to discuss the game, good and bad, without turning everything into a controversy.
Frankly, the cheating, exploiting, personal attacks, and immaturity I’ve seen in other parts of the community are exactly why I’ve left groups and never pursued content creation. I wouldn’t want to build an audience around that culture.
That’s why I prefer it here. We can acknowledge the game’s flaws without being negative about absolutely everything.
-
Since I was watching these I went ahead and watched Shelfy. Another decent one that makes some good points.
All the content creators are just copying each other. It’s silly.
It's not Silly. Maybe Fuzzy's was because he hasn't really played this year but overall Koogs and Shelfy made good points.
It's not Youtube drama for the sake of YouTube drama. These guys did not build their audiences on being negative about the game.
Many people here, myself included, come to the forums to share our opinions, good or bad, because this is our audience. So are we really any different than the streamers and YouTubers? Or are we mad that they have spent years building up an bigger audience who will listen to their opinions.
I’ll admit I haven’t watched these specific videos, but I unfollowed most creators this year because the constant negativity became exhausting. I still see their posts, and it feels like there’s a new complaint every day. We’re making videos complaining about Shane Baz getting a Finest card now? Come on.
This isn’t my favorite version of The Show either, but I still enjoy playing it. There’s a difference between constructive criticism and complaining for clicks. At some point, it feels like everyone is just recycling the same negativity.
And no, I don’t think the forums are the same. Most people here genuinely want to discuss the game, good and bad, without turning everything into a controversy.
Frankly, the cheating, exploiting, personal attacks, and immaturity I’ve seen in other parts of the community are exactly why I’ve left groups and never pursued content creation. I wouldn’t want to build an audience around that culture.
That’s why I prefer it here. We can acknowledge the game’s flaws without being negative about absolutely everything.
They are all [censored] buddies. They all cheat and are all pushing these anti SDS videos out at the same time because it is a coordinated effort.
-
I do not buy the narrative that Koogs is a cheater and pushing some narrative. He is simply frustrated with the game this year. The Finest drop signals the last main content of the year most years so is a natural time for people to be dropping videos like this.
-
I do not buy the narrative that Koogs is a cheater and pushing some narrative. He is simply frustrated with the game this year. The Finest drop signals the last main content of the year most years so is a natural time for people to be dropping videos like this.
Koogs is in the group. They all get together a couple times a year and make out with eachother.
Koogs has never tied his reputation to how good he is at the game like YFK and Littleman, so I agree that he is not cheating. He is in their group and participated in the coordinated campaign against SDS.
-
I do not understand how all of these people are complaining about SDS. SDS has done a good job of balancing the evolution of monetized online gaming with making things accessible to NMS people.
They could have made things 1,000 times worse for everyone and people would still be paying and playing.
-
I do not buy the narrative that Koogs is a cheater and pushing some narrative. He is simply frustrated with the game this year. The Finest drop signals the last main content of the year most years so is a natural time for people to be dropping videos like this.
I didn’t mind Koogs but he’s friends with YFK so now I refuse to watch anything he does.
-
KDJTV the same I believe he's completely frustrated with the state of the game too. Although, I do still find it funny that he tells his audience not to buy the game next year but he's going to, to make content. He has a full time job that's not comtent creation where he could boycott the game if wanted to. I understand that other content creators may not be able because its their means of living. If it's a side gig bro put your money where your mouth is.
-
KDJTV the same I believe he's completely frustrated with the state of the game too. Although, I do still find it funny that he tells his audience not to buy the game next year but he's going to, to make content. He has a full time job that's not comtent creation where he could boycott the game if wanted to. I understand that other content creators may not be able because its their means of living. If it's a side gig bro put your money where your mouth is.
Used to enjoy him. Now he’s gotten arrogant and joined the group of CCs crying about the game. I am so tired of it.
-
@wolfgangmlb_xbl but yet the one smaller twitch streamer I watch said earlier this week that it is definitely pay to play, had to turn off his stream because of him going on and on about the game being horrible this year and that he doesn't even have Zobrist yet because it's pay to play, him saying all this as he's sitting on over a million stubs and refusing to buy any cards for the collections. I don't think it's pay to play at all, I have all collections done except Elly but I'm close to getting him