SDS: Why are bots in the marketplace allowed?
-
Exactly what my headline says. I find it ridiculous that if say I put in an order it gets 1 upped instantly. Or Even when I test upping my buy order buy 200 stubs, im instantly 1 upped. I have to literally add an extra 800 to 1000 stubs to a buy order to stop it and that's practically at the buy now price. I feel it should be against some rule to allow that sort of market manipulation. Sometimes I feel its the seller of the a card that's driving up the sell now price in order to max stubs.
I used to complain a lot a few years back about the game but I chose this year to go with the flow for the most part. Im giving the benefit of the doubt that all the bugs will be corrected and we will have a smooth game but this bot buying stuff is obnoxious. Attack me all you want, its not going to change how I feel when I literally buy the game every year and simply want to enjoy my time playing it. Battlefield 6 and Crimson Desert are always there to fall back on when frustration hits me with the game.
-
It’s so we don’t make too many coins plain and simple they don’t want flipping to be to op which I don’t rly get if ur willing to give ur time to do it u should be rewarded
-
What makes you think those are bots doing that? I’m a person and when I list something to buy/sell, I’m almost always doing exactly what you’re describing. And I’m just a dude playing game and I have to think there are 10’s of thousands of other dudes doing the same thing. I think you’re confusing a rational market with a bot and I doubt that’s true. Not even sure what a bot would gain by doing what you’ve described.
-
Because I tested it multiple times this morning at 6am on a Spring card pitcher Sloan. It was almost comical. Once I posted 800 to 1000 more stubs it stopped. When I then delete that amount and put another buy order for a few stubs more, instantly I was 1 upped.
-
What makes you think those are bots doing that? I’m a person and when I list something to buy/sell, I’m almost always doing exactly what you’re describing. And I’m just a dude playing game and I have to think there are 10’s of thousands of other dudes doing the same thing. I think you’re confusing a rational market with a bot and I doubt that’s true. Not even sure what a bot would gain by doing what you’ve described.
Needs something to complain about.
-
@tear4eddy_PSN No human is capable of removing an order and placing a new order within a fraction of a second...without some sort of tool or macro or bot. If you're a really quick human, you might accomplish it in 2-3 seconds.
-
Because I tested it multiple times this morning at 6am on a Spring card pitcher Sloan. It was almost comical. Once I posted 800 to 1000 more stubs it stopped. When I then delete that amount and put another buy order for a few stubs more, instantly I was 1 upped.
Well, I think that sort of goes against your point. A bot would blindly one up. A rational human would what for that overpriced bid to go through and post a lower one.
-
The bots exist. When you run into one it’s obvious. I’ve also found where one can download and deploy one. I don’t do it, but I found them as confirmation.
-
@LHUBison58_XBL yeah definitely wouldn’t recommend it good thing ur not can lose ur account over
-
@tear4eddy_PSN No human is capable of removing an order and placing a new order within a fraction of a second...without some sort of tool or macro or bot. If you're a really quick human, you might accomplish it in 2-3 seconds.
Add in menu times to scroll to a player we’re talking 5 minutes per card sold in this iteration, as a human. It has to be bots there’s no other explanation.
-
@jeffstified_XBL Wrong man, You're not fully grasping the simplicity of this scenario. But its ok, im working at the moment and don't have excess time to dumb it down again.
If people don't believe or even try to argue against it then I next would assume you're one of the people using some bot to purchase cards for you.
-
@Onix_Savage22_PSN I didn’t ask for advice. I’m a big boy and know the rules. As I said until I saw one I didn’t believe it. Call me Thomas, but I had to put my fingers in the holes on this one.
-
What makes you think those are bots doing that? I’m a person and when I list something to buy/sell, I’m almost always doing exactly what you’re describing. And I’m just a dude playing game and I have to think there are 10’s of thousands of other dudes doing the same thing. I think you’re confusing a rational market with a bot and I doubt that’s true. Not even sure what a bot would gain by doing what you’ve described.
This is America where capitalism is the order of the day. Take that pinko commie ball back to red china, they'll squash those bots for you.
Greed, for lack of a better word, is good. -
What makes you think those are bots doing that? I’m a person and when I list something to buy/sell, I’m almost always doing exactly what you’re describing. And I’m just a dude playing game and I have to think there are 10’s of thousands of other dudes doing the same thing. I think you’re confusing a rational market with a bot and I doubt that’s true. Not even sure what a bot would gain by doing what you’ve described.
This is America where capitalism is the order of the day. Take that pinko commie ball back to red china, they'll squash those bots for you.
Greed, for lack of a better word, is good.I like your style. Want to date?
DTF St. Louis
-
What makes you think those are bots doing that? I’m a person and when I list something to buy/sell, I’m almost always doing exactly what you’re describing. And I’m just a dude playing game and I have to think there are 10’s of thousands of other dudes doing the same thing. I think you’re confusing a rational market with a bot and I doubt that’s true. Not even sure what a bot would gain by doing what you’ve described.
This is America where capitalism is the order of the day. Take that pinko commie ball back to red china, they'll squash those bots for you.
Greed, for lack of a better word, is good.I like your style. Want to date?
DTF St. Louis
LMGDAO base ball is serious bidness. There's no time for dating, lol.
-
I think you just need to look at the margins between buy and sell. They are almost always dead on 10% give or take. It's no coincidence. Of course SDS don't want you making profit of any kind, I've given up trying to grind stubs and just focusing on practising on how to fit fly balls to the outfield.
-
I don’t think the bots are any worse rhan previous years, but the 20 card limit makes them spread their bots across many many cards. In other years you would get annoyed by having to fight against constant undercuts and move to another card. Now there is no other cards, since bots are forced to work on so many cards.
I also think that there are a lot of “bots” that are just a few people (more than 1 other person) canceling and placing bids against one another. Who among us hasn’t been guilty of constantly underucutting someone else?
The 20 card limit was intentionally introduced to make flippers compete on many more cards instead of passively putting in 200 orders. It means all cards are much more competitive, driving margins down.
Gaming companies have been fighting bots and cheats for years and it’s rarely a battle they actually win. I want to see them remove the 20 card cap. If that happens, I’d be shocked if the complaints of bots don’t start to go away.
I am also worried that any changes to combat bots will make flipping much worse for the average person. In madden there are a ton of false bans for actual people flipping. I could also see them adding CAPTCHA to the app in an effort to fight “bots”. That would effectively kill all flipping.
Tin foil hat has me thinking they almost want the bots to run rampant so that they can “combat the bots” by absolutely destroying any chance of making profit in the market.
-
@JimLahey246_PSN This keeps getting posted and is just wrong, the 20 card cap has no impact on flipping at all. If the limit was 20 orders at a time, sure. But it's not, a bot is selling any card it buys out relatively quickly since it owns both sides of every profitable flip...it's probably super uncommon for a bot to accumulate 20 of a card it is actively flipping.
SDS ignored the problem for years and now the bots are much better at scanning the market and finding profitable cards to flip. The people that own the bots and are accumulating all the stubs and selling them on 3rd party sites are improving the bots to make even more stubs since it's gone unpunished for so long. SDS should be going after 3rd party sellers legally and additionally playing whack-a-mole with a system that recognizes bot activity and bans them quickly.
-
-
@Wolfski0412_PSN I disagree. Previously bots were able to isolate on a few of the most profitable cards. Now they are competing on pretty much every card.
If it was ONE bot, your point about owning both sides may be correct. But there are many people running bots separately that are all competing with each other on many many cards.
The 20 card limit also benefits bots, because it makes flipping for a human much more tedious. You can no longer place 50+ buy or sell orders for a card or two and then check back in an hour or two. Instead you have to constantly be managing your 20 orders. Bots can do this no problem.
I absolutely agree that SDS should go after RMT but the 20 card limit is causing people to spread their stubs across many cards, instead of focusing one one or two, which is something a bot can handle a lot better than a human.
The reality is that any way to buy and sell cards outside of inside the actual game (web app and mobile app) will allow a certain number of bots in. They can play whack a mole, but the people running these bots can get a new account and continue selling stubs for money. The real solution in my opinion is allow humans to compete with bots as much as possible, which the 20 order limit does not facilitate in my opinion.
