MLB The Show 26 New Legends Request List
-
68 World Series hero and still top 5 in left handers for strike outs. Detroit icon and, sadly, recently deceased - - - Mickey Lolich
-
@Onix_Savage22_PSN Typical of Red Sox "fans". Rude and racist.
-
@Zachtronics_XBL what racist care to explain ? And rude for not wanting a Yankee in the game I’m sorry if I came in here and said oh let’s add Carl Yastrzemski to the show yankee fans wouldn’t be open to it
. Just don’t understand how supporting a sports franchise I have since I was 5 makes me a “rude racist” person. So I’ll wait for u to explain ur unnecessary comment. And if ur a Yankee fan trying to defend ur fandom im pretty sure bleacher creatures have probably yelled some of the wildest most boundary crossing disgusting things a human could ever say to another person at opposing pitchers warming up… -
@rageincage007_XBL Mickey Cochrane!
-
@Zachtronics_XBL crickets… rly call somebody racist and rude for liking a team then goes silent. Typical stankees fan. Just waiting for the 27 ring comeback.
-
@Onix_Savage22_PSN Red Sox fans have been known to throw around their share of racism. Don't assume you know me. You know what they say about that. The last thing I'll ever be is a Yankees fan, but I'd take them, Toronto, Baltimore, or Tampa over Boston's fans anyday.
-
@Zachtronics_XBL ok don’t assume you know me how about you live by ur own words. I don’t care what other Sox fans do im simply a redsox fan from Canada who watches games from home on my tv im am not racist. only turn rude if pushed to that point. So I rly don’t know who you think you are coming at me with false accusations cause I support a certain sports franchise.
-
@Zachtronics_XBL listen dude believe it or not as a baseball fan I listen to a lot of jomboy media content even as a redsox fan u know who the 2 head guys of that company are Jimmy and Jake. u know what podcast they do “talkin yanks” that’s right yankee fans and I love these guys not matter what team they choose to support. Mind u talkin yanks isn’t in my personal rotation I listen to baseball today talkin baseball wake and jake plenty of there content. moral of the story is u should take some notes and as a baseball fan not discriminate based off what teams people like… it doesn’t tell the full story of who people are.
-
How bout Brett Gardener? And Alex Rodr- nah I'm just kidding.
-
@Player99_MLBTS as a baseball fan I would love a-rod my Sox fandom wouldn’t love him as much. But ig that makes me rude and racist
️. -
@Player99_MLBTS A-Rod is in the Vault
-
Classic nickname legends would be great. Paul and Lloyd Waner (Big Poison and Little Poison). Ducky Medwick. Dizzy and Daffy Dean. Mark "The Bird" Fidrych. Bill "Spaceman" Lee. Just to name a few...
-
I really want Kevin Kiermier and Jeff Kent to be in the game so I can have a base hit machine, and a defensive line out machine.
-
Eddie Gaedel would help me get my walks up quite a bit... I might even get to one of the My Show tiers with him.

-
@Christuffer9917_PSN u will get Kent in July.
-
I've wanted to see George Sisler and Tony Mullane in the game for quite a long time, even Kid Nichols.
-
@Onix_Savage22_PSN good
-
@TheRupster12_XBL seriously? They won’t add knuckleball pitchers anymore? Not like there is a huge pool of them to pick from, but I didn’t know that SDS just cut them out period.
-
I would guess that anyone who’s surprised knuckleballers are gone has never played this game in PvP mode