My All-Time Team Lineups in MLB The Show 25
-
@x-814-x-MAFIA-x_PSN
I'm still waiting for a good Jim Rice
-
@TheBigPapa55_PSN said in My All-Time Team Lineups in MLB The Show 25:
Again, I think Rolen was the better Cardinal than Arenado, so that's why I started him instead. I was only able to get the tier 2 boosts from Gray and Donovan. Kinda sucks.
They are closer than you might think, especially considering the cliff Arenado has fallen off the last few years. Even though Arenado has been with the Cardinals one year less than Rolen he has actually played more games.
That said, Rolen's overall stats were better.
-
Due to issues with my PlayStation, All-Time teams have been halted. Sorry, my PS5 bailed on me, so I have to wait for a new one. All this thing did was turn off completely whenever I boot it up after anywhere from 15 seconds - 10 minutes.
-
ALL-TIME CUBS TEAM
C – Wildcard Carson Kelly
1B – 2025 Finest Anthony Rizzo
2B – 2025 NLDS Nico Hoerner
3B – Milestone Kris Bryant
SS – 2025 Finest Dansby Swanson
LF – 2025 Finest Ian Happ
CF – 2025 Finest Pete Crow-Armstrong
RF – 2025 Finest Kyle Tucker
DH – Spooky Series Andre DawsonBENCH
2B – HRDX Series Ben Zobrist
RF – Signature Jason Heyward
LF/UTIL – New Threads Willi Castro
RF/DH – Moonshot Sammy SosaROTATION
SP1 – Signature Jake Arrieta
SP2 – August Spotlight Cade Horton
SP3 – Milestone Kerry Wood
SP4 – 2025 Finest Matthew Boyd
SP5 – Topps Now Justin SteeleBULLPEN
LRP – Topps Now Andrew Kittredge
MRP - Moonshot Rich Gossage
MRP – Cornerstone Bruce Sutter
MRP – New Threads Ryan Pressly
MRP – Live Series Drew Pomeranz
SU – New Threads Taylor Rogers
SU – Spotlight Brad Keller
CP – Hall of Fame Lee Smith -
@girldad4_MLBTS
No ‘25 finest schwarber? TheBigPapa55 was using players that ever played with the team even if it isn’t a Cubs card -
Yeah I did that but this team is was all cubs card. I had WC Baez as well
-
@markemark_NSW
Here's my Cubs team:
C. 2025 Postseason Carson Kelly
1B Neon Anthony Rizzo
2B Hall of Fame Ryne Sandberg
3B Milestone Kris Bryant
SS 2025 Postseason Javier Baez
LF 2nd Half Heroes Billy Williams
CF Spooky Andre Dawson
RF Moonshot Sammy Sosa
DH Home Run Derby X Ben Zobrist
Bench:
RF Signature Jason Heyward
2B Awards Alfonso Soriano
LF 2025 Finest Kyle Schwarber
CF 2025 Finest Pete Crow-Armstrong
Rotation
Spooky Greg Maddux
Signature Jake Arrieta
Milestone Kerry Wood
2025 All-Star Matthew Boyd
Standout Yu Darvish
Bullpen
Spotlight Brad Keller
Cornerstone Bruce Sutter
Topps Now Andrew Kittredge
Finest Aroldis Chapman
Hall of Fame Dennis Eckersley
Spooky Craig Kimbrel
Awards Rich Gossage
Hall of Fame Lee Smith
The real All-Time Cubs -
Dude, not having the WS MVP Ben Zobrist in the lineup is criminal. That alone makes it simply a theme team.
-
All-Time Nationals (WE’RE Back Boys!)
C. Finest Gary Carter
1B 2025 Finest Bryce Harper
2B Awards Alfonso Soriano
3B Home Run Derby X Ryan Zimmerman
SS 2025 Finest Trea Turner
LF Moonshot Tim Raines
CF Spooky Andre Dawson
RF Hall of Fame Vladimir Guerrero
DH 2025 Finest Juan Soto
Bench
RF Awards Larry Walker
SS Home Run Derby X Ian Desmond
LF 2025 Finest James Wood
SS 2025 Finest CJ Abram’s
Rotation
2025 Postseason Max Scherzer
Neon Jordan Zimmerman
Awards Pedro Martinez
2025 All-Star Mackenzie Gore
Awards Randy Johnson
Bullpen
Color Storm Blake Treinen
Live Clayton Beeter
Live Jackson Rutledge
Live Jose A. Ferrer
Spotlight Kyle Finnegan
Live PJ Poulin
Live Cole Henry
Hall of Fame Lee Smith
Possibly the worst bullpen in history - I just used Randy out of the pen - won 6-3 -
All-Time Yankees:
C. Signature Jorge Posada
1B Neon Lou Gehrig
2B Awards Alfonso Soriano
3B Cornerstone Wade Boggs
SS Neon Derek Jeter
LF Signature Bernie Williams
CF Milestone Mickey Mantle
RF Milestone Babe Ruth
DH 2025 Postseason Aaron Judge
Bench
RF Milestone Paul O'Neill
1B Awards Jason Giambi
RF Finest Gary Sheffield
RF Spotlight Giancarlo Stanton
Rotation
Captain Whitey Ford
Hall of Fame CC Sabathia
Milestone Roger Clemens
Awards Gerrit Cole
Signature Andy Pettitte
Bullpen
Spooky Jonathan Loaisiga
New Threads David Bednar
New Threads Camilo Doval
2025 Postseason Devin Williams
Finest Andrew Miller
2025 Finest Aroldis Chapman
Signature Darren O'Day
Awards Rich Gossage
