MLBTS 20 Historic Rosters
-
Curious. Are you leaning towards the 1919 white sox and what about the giants.
-
@biebig2010 said in MLBTS 20 Historic Rosters:
@boogiewithstu2 said in MLBTS 20 Historic Rosters:
Would love to see the 95 Mariners, that team was fun to watch .... Also, when I think of the greatest teams of all time... The 98 Yankees man, that team was STACKED !!
The 2001 Mariners had a lot more wins than the 95 Mariners so I went with the 2001 team over the 95 team.
I agree the 98 Yankees were one of the best teams of all time. The 27 Yankees were one of the best teams of all time too though. In fact, the 27 Yankees had a .714 winning percentage compared to a .704 winning percentage for the 98 Yankees. Hell, the 1939 Yankees rank right up there too with a .702 winning percentage. And who can forget the 1961 Yankees. They won at a .673 clip.
Lots of tough choices for the greatest teams of all time for each franchise.
OH no doubt the 2001 M's were the choice for the better overall team, I just thought that 95 team was more exciting in terms of offensive fire power, Griff, Edgar, Tino, Buhner, a young Arod was a great combo.... M's ownership BLEW IT in the mid 90's ... M"s could a won a title with that team had they kept Tino and improve the pitching, but they did the opposite... Yankees benefited from that... Would be cool to see historic teams playable someday, like old school Madden games...
-
Just Uploaded "Biebig2010s merged ATGs 50s60s" Roster.
It is every player from your '50s-'60s Roster Set moved into your All Time Greats Roster Set that wasn't there already. A total of 494 Players were moved.
This creates a fantastic Roster for use in a Franchise Fantasy Draft scenario.
I have long been an admirer of Your Rosters and wanted to create something that is more to my liking to use in a Franchise Fantasy Draft.
Nothing was changed what-so-ever with ONLY Player Movement/Replacement taking place.
I think this has created a Grand Roster for us Classic Roster Guys that go back to the '50s & '60s combined with many of the Pre-50s and Post-60s Star Players included.
Thanks Again for your unsurpassed contributions to this Classic Community,
Don -
@macdonald433 said in MLBTS 20 Historic Rosters:
Curious. Are you leaning towards the 1919 white sox and what about the giants.
Yes, the 1919 White Sox. They didn’t win the World Series but they should have. The 1917 team had a better winning percentage and win the World Series but the 1919 team is the most famous (or is that infamous).
As far as Giants are concerned I’m currently leaning toward the 54 Giants.
-
Willie Mays vs Christie Mathewson. Two of my absolute favorites. Hard to forget Musial and Joltin Joe. When i was little I loved the Grover Cleveland Alexander movie with Reagan, therefore really liked Rogers Hornsby. My dad being from Cincinnati and telling me all the stories of going to Crosley field in 1919 when he was 7 and thru the 20s was only beaten when he took me to Crosley in the early 60s and saw Robinson and Pinson and Rose who was a rookie going up against Chris Short of the Phillies. Loved the Reds and hated the 61 Yankees. What a team them [censored] Yankees were!!
-
@biebig2010 said in MLBTS 20 Historic Rosters:
I finished my ALL TIME GREATS roster for MLBTS 20 and uploaded it to the vault.
In addition to the ALL TIME GREATS roster I'm going to make HISTORIC ROSTER 1990-2009, HISTORIC ROSTER 1970-1989, HISTORIC ROSTER 1950-1969, HISTORIC ROSTER 1930-1949, and HISTORIC ROSTER 1900-1929.
Next up is the HISTORIC ROSTER 1990-2009. The following teams will be included:
BAL 1997
BOS 2004
NYY 1998
TB 2008
TOR 1992CWS 2005
CLE 1995
DET 2006
KC 1994
MIN 1991HOU 2005
LAA 2002
OAK 1990
SEA 2001
TEX 1999ATL 1995
MIA 1997
NYM 2000
PHI 2008
WASH 1994CHC 2003
CIN 1990
MIL 2008
PIT 1991
STL 2004ARI 2001
COL 2007
LAD 2009
SD 1998
SF 2010I know the 2001 mariners team was great with the win but that 1995 team was my heart an soul back in the day even tho I'm a red Sox fan I was a huge Mariner fan growing up as a kid too obviously because of Griffey but arod,the big unit,Jay buhner Tino Martinez that was my team....great job man much appreciated
-
@boogiewithstu2 said in MLBTS 20 Historic Rosters:
@biebig2010 said in MLBTS 20 Historic Rosters:
@boogiewithstu2 said in MLBTS 20 Historic Rosters:
Would love to see the 95 Mariners, that team was fun to watch .... Also, when I think of the greatest teams of all time... The 98 Yankees man, that team was STACKED !!
The 2001 Mariners had a lot more wins than the 95 Mariners so I went with the 2001 team over the 95 team.
I agree the 98 Yankees were one of the best teams of all time. The 27 Yankees were one of the best teams of all time too though. In fact, the 27 Yankees had a .714 winning percentage compared to a .704 winning percentage for the 98 Yankees. Hell, the 1939 Yankees rank right up there too with a .702 winning percentage. And who can forget the 1961 Yankees. They won at a .673 clip.
Lots of tough choices for the greatest teams of all time for each franchise.
OH no doubt the 2001 M's were the choice for the better overall team, I just thought that 95 team was more exciting in terms of offensive fire power, Griff, Edgar, Tino, Buhner, a young Arod was a great combo.... M's ownership BLEW IT in the mid 90's ... M"s could a won a title with that team had they kept Tino and improve the pitching, but they did the opposite... Yankees benefited from that... Would be cool to see historic teams playable someday, like old school Madden games...
I literally just posted basically the same thing without even seeing this post of yours lol....I see we think alike as in what we really think was the best mariners team if not counting the win total
-
I finished the HISTORIC ROSTER 1900-1929 and uploaded it to the vault.
Note: I ended up creating the 1912 Giants instead of the 1905 Giants.
I'm going to create one more roster for this version of MLBTS. It will be the HISTORIC ROSTER 1900-2019 and will include the top team / most famous team for each franchise between 1900-2019. The following teams will be included:
BAL 1970
BOS 2004
NYY 1927
TB 2008
TOR 1992CWS 1919
CLE 1954
DET 1984
KC 1985
MIN 1991HOU 2017
LAA 2002
OAK 1990
SEA 2001
TEX 2010ATL 1995
MIA 1997
NYM 1986
PHI 2008
WASH/MON 1994CHC 1906
CIN 1975
MIL 1982
PIT 1909
STL 1967ARI 2001
COL 2007
LAD 1955
SD 1998
SF 1954 -
@biebig2010 said in MLBTS 20 Historic Rosters:
I finished the HISTORIC ROSTER 1900-1929 and uploaded it to the vault.
Note: I ended up creating the 1912 Giants instead of the 1905 Giants.
I'm going to create one more roster for this version of MLBTS. It will be the HISTORIC ROSTER 1900-2019 and will include the top team / most famous team for each franchise between 1900-2019. The following teams will be included:
BAL 1970
BOS 2004
NYY 1927
TB 2008
TOR 1992CWS 1919
CLE 1954
DET 1984
KC 1985
MIN 1991HOU 2017
LAA 2002
OAK 1990
SEA 2001
TEX 2010ATL 1995
MIA 1997
NYM 1986
PHI 2008
WASH/MON 1994CHC 1906
CIN 1975
MIL 1982
PIT 1909
STL 1967ARI 2001
COL 2007
LAD 1955
SD 1998
SF 1954Dude these rosters are amazing to a baseball nerd like myself. I haven't messed around with any custom rosters yet myself, so this might be a dumb question.
The Darryl Strawberry on the 86 Mets...does he look like Darryl?
-
Thank you. I know over the years I keep saying how great your rosters are but the detail from equipment to hitting, pitching and fielding are unparalleled in any created rosters in any electronic sports game! On a different note, have you decided on the A's team and I guess it will be the 2007 Rockies. Again, thanx!
-
Whoops! My bad. Didnt look at your alltime list I was so excited about new roster, 1990 A's great choice. 2007 Rockies my choice. Can't wait.
-
@PeuswahBoy said in MLBTS 20 Historic Rosters:
@biebig2010 said in MLBTS 20 Historic Rosters:
I finished the HISTORIC ROSTER 1900-1929 and uploaded it to the vault.
Note: I ended up creating the 1912 Giants instead of the 1905 Giants.
I'm going to create one more roster for this version of MLBTS. It will be the HISTORIC ROSTER 1900-2019 and will include the top team / most famous team for each franchise between 1900-2019. The following teams will be included:
BAL 1970
BOS 2004
NYY 1927
TB 2008
TOR 1992CWS 1919
CLE 1954
DET 1984
KC 1985
MIN 1991HOU 2017
LAA 2002
OAK 1990
SEA 2001
TEX 2010ATL 1995
MIA 1997
NYM 1986
PHI 2008
WASH/MON 1994CHC 1906
CIN 1975
MIL 1982
PIT 1909
STL 1967ARI 2001
COL 2007
LAD 1955
SD 1998
SF 1954Dude these rosters are amazing to a baseball nerd like myself. I haven't messed around with any custom rosters yet myself, so this might be a dumb question.
The Darryl Strawberry on the 86 Mets...does he look like Darryl?
Yes, I think it looks fairly close to Darryl. When you see him batting or fielding from a distance it looks like him and when you see his face close up it looks fairly decent.
-
@macdonald433 said in MLBTS 20 Historic Rosters:
Whoops! My bad. Didnt look at your alltime list I was so excited about new roster, 1990 A's great choice. 2007 Rockies my choice. Can't wait.
There was some really, really, really tough choices to make.
The Yankees for example. I was torn between the 1927 Yanks and the 1998 Yanks. It was tough to leave behind the 1939 Yanks and the 1961 Yanks as well.
Boston was another tough choice. I really like the 1946 team and the 1975 team but I went with the 2004 team because they broke the curse of the Bambino.
San Francisco, St Louis, Pittsburgh, Wash/Mon, and Oakland also presented some really tough choices.
-
86 mets vs 69 mets another tough one. I'm really thrilled with all the choices and can't wait to start my playoffs. Thanx.
-
I uploaded HISTORIC ROSTER 1900-2010 last night. The roster contains the top team / most famous team for each franchise from 1900-2010. Teams include:
BAL - 1970
BOS - 2004
NYY - 1927
TB - 2008
TOR - 1992
CWS - 1919
CLE - 1954
DET - 1984
KC - 1975
MIN - 1991
HOU - 1986
LAA - 2002
OAK - 1989
SEA - 2001
TEX - 2010
ATL - 1995
MIA - 1997
NYM - 1986
PHI - 2008
WASH/MON - 1994
CHC - 1906
CIN - 1975
MIL - 1982
PIT - 1971
STL - 1967
ARI - 2001
COL - 2007
LAD - 1955
SD - 1998
SF - 1954 -
Thanx biebig. I messed up and lost all my downloads when I thought my ps4 was broken. Fiddled with everything and eventually lost it all. Son came over and fixed. Was just the controller was bad. New controller and all fixed, except I had wiped all the memory. Re-loaded mlb 20 and instantly downloaded all your great rosters and the fantastic new historic roster (holy cow!). One problem. I can't download your alltime greats roster. Tried over and over and it keeps saying file unavailable. All others downladed fine. Anyway you can help? Much appreciated. Your new roster is incredible! Thank you again for everything.
-
I can look at it sometime this evening. You're the first to mention any problems with it and it's been downloaded a ton since it was originally posted.
-
I’ll have to check out that 94 Expos team some day, so unfair...
-
No problem. I AM ENJOYING the new roster!
-
@macdonald433 said in MLBTS 20 Historic Rosters:
Thanx biebig. I messed up and lost all my downloads when I thought my ps4 was broken. Fiddled with everything and eventually lost it all. Son came over and fixed. Was just the controller was bad. New controller and all fixed, except I had wiped all the memory. Re-loaded mlb 20 and instantly downloaded all your great rosters and the fantastic new historic roster (holy cow!). One problem. I can't download your alltime greats roster. Tried over and over and it keeps saying file unavailable. All others downladed fine. Anyway you can help? Much appreciated. Your new roster is incredible! Thank you again for everything.
I tried downloading my ALL TIME GREATS roster from the Vault and it worked fine. I also see the number of downloads increasing whenever I look so someone is downloading it.
I think you may have some individual technical difficulties that others aren't having.
