Better than Trout
-
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@MRAD2010_XBL said in Better than Trout:
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@MRAD2010_XBL said in Better than Trout:
@the_dragon1912 said in Better than Trout:
Griffey is the only one you can reasonably make an argument for imo
What he said
Andrew McCuthen would like a word with everyone in this thread lol smh
I love that Cutch card but I definitely don’t think he’s better than Griffey or Trout. Here’s a hot take. I’m not even sure if he would even start over Vlad Sr,Bader or some of the other elite outfielders that are out now. Now saying he’s worse but I’m not sure that he’s better either.
Lol you guys are absolutely mad
Bro said Cutch isn’t better than Griffey vlad or bader lol
I literally was just having a convo with a too 50 player last week while he was drafting a BR team and he stated that Cutch is the best card in the game
Yes this was before trout but the question asked in this thread is who is as good as trout to use as a replacement and you dudes are saying Harrison Bader before you’re saying Cutch
Trust me it’s very rare that a card you get from a free program is going to be better than a Card that’s behind a collection wall
Oh well if a top 50 player/streamer said it must be true!
I get wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy more hits with 99 Swisher (free card) Than any other player in my library. Point is the top 50 players best card might not be the same for everybody. I think there are swing types that make it more comfortable for people which allows SDS to create more diversity. Which is what we have asked for for years.
This is why the Market is a sham b/c the 500k to 1 mil cards may not play better than the 60k card. So in a sense forcing people to collect cards to aquire cards that are unbuyable is kinda in a sense a market manipulation in a way but not to an extreme, because people have a choice to collect or not.
#Allcardsavailabletoeveryone Top cards via BR,RS, or Events is one the worst things they have done in recent years. Those are the highest price cards on the Market. So they are basically saying Win or pay a million stubs for a card.
And i respond with if that's the case then either change the limit of Max price lower or make every card available regardless what mode you play. Because in the end most people like to play with players they either grow up watching or because it is a game and should be fun for everyone not just people who have countless hours to grind the 3 competitive modes.
With that being said the other programs was a nice addition for really good playable cards. Just my personal opinion is every card should be available through stats aquired. Whether that means with players from same team or actual attribute type stats.
-
@samguenther1987 said in Better than Trout:
I mean there are a ton of other great options, but I'll exclude the ones you get for free i.e., Curtis Granderson/Harison Bader
Jim Edmonds - Finest
Ken Griffey Jr - Takashi
Honus Wagner - Milestone
Vlad Guerrero Sr - Finest
Hank Aaron FOTF (Still a beast)
Stan Musial - Finest
Babe Ruth - SignatureThat being said my outfield is now
LF -Ken Griffey Jr - Takashi
CF - Mike Trout - Finest
RF - Babe Ruth - Signatureand I'm still waiting on a 99 Reggie Jackson
99 Reggie, I can’t believe I forgot about him. I also want 99 Mantle.
Edit: I would like a better Mays too, but not too sure that will happen. -
Really interesting to see everyone's perspective. Right now we have Griffey and McCutchen are the only ones who come close to Trout. All three have power and speed. Many of the other guys mentioned have similar hitting stats but no speed. Plus you throw in active quirks for Trout, boom best card in the game. Now I do think Julio Rodriguez gets a really nice card today (speed and power) which should be a nice fill in until my Trout order fills. We also have not seen a good Mantle which if they give him the attributes he should get, would automatically be the best card because of switch hitting. My end game OF last year was Griffey, Mantle, Trout. I expect it to be the same this year.
-
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@TEXAS10PT_PSN said in Better than Trout:
MookieMan....How is Gary Sheffield the best card in the game? Awesome hitter but a Silver fielder by attributes. I'm not biting LOL
Take a look at this- if you just pay attention to attributes only these are the best cards in the game at positions
https://i.imgur.com/Emb0Cid.jpg
Look at CF- Soriano is over Cutch lol
But is Andrew Mcuthen 1000x better than Soriano in this game yes
This is why you just can’t go by attributes alone
Everyone plays different with players’ cards than others, as has been said. However, I believe that the majority of people would count Posada as a top 5 Catcher. Didn’t look at the rest of the list, but I fully agree that attributes alone do not make a card great. Many love Piazza, but I can never hit well with him. Another player that comes to mind is Manny Machado. He has one of the best Finest cards in The Show 20, but his swing just never plays like his attributes for me. Other cards play high above.
-
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@TEXAS10PT_PSN said in Better than Trout:
MookieMan....How is Gary Sheffield the best card in the game? Awesome hitter but a Silver fielder by attributes. I'm not biting LOL
Take a look at this- if you just pay attention to attributes only these are the best cards in the game at positions
https://i.imgur.com/Emb0Cid.jpg
Look at CF- Soriano is over Cutch lol
But is Andrew Mcuthen 1000x better than Soriano in this game yes
This is why you just can’t go by attributes alone
This is a great find, I had not seen this before. Only 3 I would agree with are Griffey, Jimmy and Foxx. Maybe Mauer. Thier starting pitchers are way off. Wagner and Chapman are top 2 RP but then the 2 MA guys? SHeff looks great on paper but I have yet to see many people who use him and like him. ANd the MS Judge, is a card who I thought I would love, but that vision is still brutal.
-
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@the_dragon1912 said in Better than Trout:
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@the_dragon1912 said in Better than Trout:
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@the_dragon1912 said in Better than Trout:
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@the_dragon1912 said in Better than Trout:
Griffey is the only one you can reasonably make an argument for imo
Have you guys forgot that there was a collection for a retro finest Andrew McCutch??!!
Like he might literally be the best card in the game lol
I love the Cutch card, but even if you don't factor in active quirks Trout is still better in every single way
Cutch is better than Griffey
Like what are you dudes talking about lol?
Cutch is arguably the best card in the game
McCutchen: 116/125/106/115/100 with 94 Fielding and 87 Speed
Griffey:122/111/125/121/109 with 98 Fielding and 90 Speed
Trout:113/121/125/125/81 with 91 Fielding and 99 Speed
Cutch has the lowest arm strength, vs. R is more important and vision doesn't matter enough to knock Trout for that. If you don't hit as well with Griffey or Trout that is fine but McCutchen is objectively not better than those two cardsLol you’re really paying attention too much the attributes
If you go by attributes Gary Sheff is the best card in the game
Cutch is glitchy just like Brett- there are cards with better attributes but there’s just something about Brett that he plays wayyy better and same thing with Cutch
Cutch is better than Griffey lol- that’s not a debate- and as far as hitting with Griffey- he’s never even made my lineup my outfield is too stacked lol
But Trout will def be in there when I get him-
Remember the question that was raised is who is better than trout in the game and no way should the answer be Griffey over Andrew Cutch
Like I said before you see Cutch in most content creators line up still to this day- Griffey not so much
It looks to me you are just refusing to believe that the collection rewards have been passed by. You are playing Rollins and Lindor in the outfield and have Bo Bichette at short. Brett is still a top option but he's been passed by at 3rd too. I understand you spent a lot time and stubs on the collection rewards but the top 3 outfielders year in and year out are Trout, Griffey, and Mantle. This year will be absolutely no different
No their in my lineups because they are the best players in the game lolThere isn’t a better 3B than Bret- if your don’t have Bret in your lineup you’re doing it wrong lol
I understand you want Griffey to be the same Griffey he is every year in this game but this year he isn’t him I’m sorry for that- just like this years Babe card isn’t him either
I use who I’m good with- so your argument that I only care about collection players is false
Posada and Mauer aren’t collection players and they are amazing
Griffey is not better than Cutch
Griffey is better than Cutch, its not even a debate its just fact. Just because you or your "top 50 streamer" buddy claim otherwise means absolutely nothing. Same as me claiming Future Stars Oneil Cruz is the best card in history because i absolutely mash with him. Opinions are not facts.
And for what its worth, I hit 20 times better with Wade Boggs than I do Brett.
-
@jonblaze2424_PSN said in Better than Trout:
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@the_dragon1912 said in Better than Trout:
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@the_dragon1912 said in Better than Trout:
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@the_dragon1912 said in Better than Trout:
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@the_dragon1912 said in Better than Trout:
Griffey is the only one you can reasonably make an argument for imo
Have you guys forgot that there was a collection for a retro finest Andrew McCutch??!!
Like he might literally be the best card in the game lol
I love the Cutch card, but even if you don't factor in active quirks Trout is still better in every single way
Cutch is better than Griffey
Like what are you dudes talking about lol?
Cutch is arguably the best card in the game
McCutchen: 116/125/106/115/100 with 94 Fielding and 87 Speed
Griffey:122/111/125/121/109 with 98 Fielding and 90 Speed
Trout:113/121/125/125/81 with 91 Fielding and 99 Speed
Cutch has the lowest arm strength, vs. R is more important and vision doesn't matter enough to knock Trout for that. If you don't hit as well with Griffey or Trout that is fine but McCutchen is objectively not better than those two cardsLol you’re really paying attention too much the attributes
If you go by attributes Gary Sheff is the best card in the game
Cutch is glitchy just like Brett- there are cards with better attributes but there’s just something about Brett that he plays wayyy better and same thing with Cutch
Cutch is better than Griffey lol- that’s not a debate- and as far as hitting with Griffey- he’s never even made my lineup my outfield is too stacked lol
But Trout will def be in there when I get him-
Remember the question that was raised is who is better than trout in the game and no way should the answer be Griffey over Andrew Cutch
Like I said before you see Cutch in most content creators line up still to this day- Griffey not so much
It looks to me you are just refusing to believe that the collection rewards have been passed by. You are playing Rollins and Lindor in the outfield and have Bo Bichette at short. Brett is still a top option but he's been passed by at 3rd too. I understand you spent a lot time and stubs on the collection rewards but the top 3 outfielders year in and year out are Trout, Griffey, and Mantle. This year will be absolutely no different
No their in my lineups because they are the best players in the game lolThere isn’t a better 3B than Bret- if your don’t have Bret in your lineup you’re doing it wrong lol
I understand you want Griffey to be the same Griffey he is every year in this game but this year he isn’t him I’m sorry for that- just like this years Babe card isn’t him either
I use who I’m good with- so your argument that I only care about collection players is false
Posada and Mauer aren’t collection players and they are amazing
Griffey is not better than Cutch
Griffey is better than Cutch, its not even a debate its just fact. Just because you or your "top 50 streamer" buddy claim otherwise means absolutely nothing. Same as me claiming Future Stars Oneil Cruz is the best card in history because i absolutely mash with him. Opinions are not facts.
And for what its worth, I hit 20 times better with Wade Boggs than I do Brett.
Man starts off by saying “griff is better than Cutch not a debate just facts”
And then ends by saying opinions are not facts lol
lol can’t make this stuff up lol- yea buddy you keep using boggs over Brett!
-
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@CookieMonster64_NSW said in Better than Trout:
Kiner or Honus, both from Juicy 2 pack so they are easy to get especially Kiner because he is in the base round.
Neither of them are better than 99 trout lol
His question was who better not who is a suitable replacement
And the only outfielder that I would even consider better is 99 RF Cutch
That's just me.
I absolutely love their swings.
Kiner's defense sucks though. -
The fish has been caught!!
-
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@jonblaze2424_PSN said in Better than Trout:
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@the_dragon1912 said in Better than Trout:
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@the_dragon1912 said in Better than Trout:
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@the_dragon1912 said in Better than Trout:
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@the_dragon1912 said in Better than Trout:
Griffey is the only one you can reasonably make an argument for imo
Have you guys forgot that there was a collection for a retro finest Andrew McCutch??!!
Like he might literally be the best card in the game lol
I love the Cutch card, but even if you don't factor in active quirks Trout is still better in every single way
Cutch is better than Griffey
Like what are you dudes talking about lol?
Cutch is arguably the best card in the game
McCutchen: 116/125/106/115/100 with 94 Fielding and 87 Speed
Griffey:122/111/125/121/109 with 98 Fielding and 90 Speed
Trout:113/121/125/125/81 with 91 Fielding and 99 Speed
Cutch has the lowest arm strength, vs. R is more important and vision doesn't matter enough to knock Trout for that. If you don't hit as well with Griffey or Trout that is fine but McCutchen is objectively not better than those two cardsLol you’re really paying attention too much the attributes
If you go by attributes Gary Sheff is the best card in the game
Cutch is glitchy just like Brett- there are cards with better attributes but there’s just something about Brett that he plays wayyy better and same thing with Cutch
Cutch is better than Griffey lol- that’s not a debate- and as far as hitting with Griffey- he’s never even made my lineup my outfield is too stacked lol
But Trout will def be in there when I get him-
Remember the question that was raised is who is better than trout in the game and no way should the answer be Griffey over Andrew Cutch
Like I said before you see Cutch in most content creators line up still to this day- Griffey not so much
It looks to me you are just refusing to believe that the collection rewards have been passed by. You are playing Rollins and Lindor in the outfield and have Bo Bichette at short. Brett is still a top option but he's been passed by at 3rd too. I understand you spent a lot time and stubs on the collection rewards but the top 3 outfielders year in and year out are Trout, Griffey, and Mantle. This year will be absolutely no different
No their in my lineups because they are the best players in the game lolThere isn’t a better 3B than Bret- if your don’t have Bret in your lineup you’re doing it wrong lol
I understand you want Griffey to be the same Griffey he is every year in this game but this year he isn’t him I’m sorry for that- just like this years Babe card isn’t him either
I use who I’m good with- so your argument that I only care about collection players is false
Posada and Mauer aren’t collection players and they are amazing
Griffey is not better than Cutch
Griffey is better than Cutch, its not even a debate its just fact. Just because you or your "top 50 streamer" buddy claim otherwise means absolutely nothing. Same as me claiming Future Stars Oneil Cruz is the best card in history because i absolutely mash with him. Opinions are not facts.
And for what its worth, I hit 20 times better with Wade Boggs than I do Brett.
Man starts off by saying “griff is better than Cutch not a debate just facts”
And then ends by saying opinions are not facts lol
lol can’t make this stuff up lol- yea buddy you keep using boggs over Brett!
My dude, look at the attributes. Griffey is better, it baffles me how this is so hard to understand. Just because some scrub says the card is "glitchy" doesn't mean it's like that for everyone. If you go by straight up attributes/ratings, Griffey is MUCh better than Cutch. Deal with it.
-
Bryan Reynolds has entered the chat
-
@DaddyDingerz_PSN said in Better than Trout:
Bryan Reynolds has entered the chat
Honestly, Reynolds definitely got some special treatment in this program. Finest cards are supposed to be juiced, but Reynolds is juiced so much more than the rest of them
-
@the_dragon1912 said in Better than Trout:
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@the_dragon1912 said in Better than Trout:
Griffey is the only one you can reasonably make an argument for imo
Have you guys forgot that there was a collection for a retro finest Andrew McCutch??!!
Like he might literally be the best card in the game lol
I love the Cutch card, but even if you don't factor in active quirks Trout is still better in every single way
Not true.
Cutch has better dreadlocks than Trouty 🤪 -
@jonblaze2424_PSN said in Better than Trout:
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@jonblaze2424_PSN said in Better than Trout:
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@the_dragon1912 said in Better than Trout:
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@the_dragon1912 said in Better than Trout:
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@the_dragon1912 said in Better than Trout:
@mookieparlaybetts_MLBTS said in Better than Trout:
@the_dragon1912 said in Better than Trout:
Griffey is the only one you can reasonably make an argument for imo
Have you guys forgot that there was a collection for a retro finest Andrew McCutch??!!
Like he might literally be the best card in the game lol
I love the Cutch card, but even if you don't factor in active quirks Trout is still better in every single way
Cutch is better than Griffey
Like what are you dudes talking about lol?
Cutch is arguably the best card in the game
McCutchen: 116/125/106/115/100 with 94 Fielding and 87 Speed
Griffey:122/111/125/121/109 with 98 Fielding and 90 Speed
Trout:113/121/125/125/81 with 91 Fielding and 99 Speed
Cutch has the lowest arm strength, vs. R is more important and vision doesn't matter enough to knock Trout for that. If you don't hit as well with Griffey or Trout that is fine but McCutchen is objectively not better than those two cardsLol you’re really paying attention too much the attributes
If you go by attributes Gary Sheff is the best card in the game
Cutch is glitchy just like Brett- there are cards with better attributes but there’s just something about Brett that he plays wayyy better and same thing with Cutch
Cutch is better than Griffey lol- that’s not a debate- and as far as hitting with Griffey- he’s never even made my lineup my outfield is too stacked lol
But Trout will def be in there when I get him-
Remember the question that was raised is who is better than trout in the game and no way should the answer be Griffey over Andrew Cutch
Like I said before you see Cutch in most content creators line up still to this day- Griffey not so much
It looks to me you are just refusing to believe that the collection rewards have been passed by. You are playing Rollins and Lindor in the outfield and have Bo Bichette at short. Brett is still a top option but he's been passed by at 3rd too. I understand you spent a lot time and stubs on the collection rewards but the top 3 outfielders year in and year out are Trout, Griffey, and Mantle. This year will be absolutely no different
No their in my lineups because they are the best players in the game lolThere isn’t a better 3B than Bret- if your don’t have Bret in your lineup you’re doing it wrong lol
I understand you want Griffey to be the same Griffey he is every year in this game but this year he isn’t him I’m sorry for that- just like this years Babe card isn’t him either
I use who I’m good with- so your argument that I only care about collection players is false
Posada and Mauer aren’t collection players and they are amazing
Griffey is not better than Cutch
Griffey is better than Cutch, its not even a debate its just fact. Just because you or your "top 50 streamer" buddy claim otherwise means absolutely nothing. Same as me claiming Future Stars Oneil Cruz is the best card in history because i absolutely mash with him. Opinions are not facts.
And for what its worth, I hit 20 times better with Wade Boggs than I do Brett.
Man starts off by saying “griff is better than Cutch not a debate just facts”
And then ends by saying opinions are not facts lol
lol can’t make this stuff up lol- yea buddy you keep using boggs over Brett!
My dude, look at the attributes. Griffey is better, it baffles me how this is so hard to understand. Just because some scrub says the card is "glitchy" doesn't mean it's like that for everyone. If you go by straight up attributes/ratings, Griffey is MUCh better than Cutch. Deal with it.
For me, Griffey Jr. is always the best outfielder in the game; he has the best swing which plays above his attributes. This year, they gave him the best attributes I can remember. So I agree that Griffey Jr. is the best OF. However, attributes are not everything, and some cards play different for some than others. I’m sure there are people who don’t like his swing as much as Cutch, or other OF, and that’s fine. It doesn’t bother me if someone doesn’t use Griffey; just means I don’t have to pitch to him. There are plenty of OF that are good. Griffey Jr is my best.
-
A admin locked this topic on
