Cards you thought you would crush with, but didn’t
-
What are some cards you thought were perfect, but you didn’t do well with. For me it’s Brooks Robinson. The attributes are perfect. Maxed out defense, great contact, power, and vision. I thought, man, people are sleeping on this card. Thought it might be the best card in the game. The defense is advertised. I’ve been playing Robinson at 3rd and Ozzie at SS, and nothing gets through that side of the IF. But, I have not got it going at the plate with Brooks. I think my problem is his attributes are too good. Pitches I normally would be fouling off or missing, I’m catching enough of with his giant pci to pop up on the infield or ground weakly somewhere. Had the same problem with AS22 Kirk, but eventually got it going with him, so I guess I’ll stick it out with Brooks for a little while longer
-
So far RF Sheffield.
So far. I didn't trust him in my Mini-Seasons playoffs to use him there. -
The lotf Hank, and Andre Dawson. Can't hit with either for some reason
-
@Finn_Scotus_PSN said in Cards you thought you would crush with, but didn’t:
The lotf Hank, and Andre Dawson. Can't hit with either for some reason
Don't try to pull with Aaron. I found out early!
-
Aaron Judge, always Aaron Judge dosn't matter what card, i also don't love batting with George Brett even though his card is great this year.
-
Hank Aaron for sure.
I finally started raking with Giambi but it took me a long time.
-
LOTF Ray Durham. I have loved his lower tier cards so far this year but he is BY FAR my worst hitter of any of the new cards that have come out in the last couple weeks. However, when I face him it feels like it's an automatic hit. I don't know when the last time I got him out was.
-
All of them
-
Cano and Sheffield. Incredible
-
@TheGoaler_PSN said in Cards you thought you would crush with, but didn’t:
Cano and Sheffield. Incredible
Actually I find Hank Aaron to be a beast. Way better card than last years version for me.
-
FL Rickey.
I hit well with his takashi series and the other,but with the FL card finally got his first hit in his 15th AB.hoping it's just a slow start. -
Hank Aaron and Steve Finley. I really like both of their stances and attributes, but I just can't hit with either of them. I just recently replaced Finley with Aaron so he has less than 30AB's right now, but I couldn't hit with him last year either.
-
Posada for me … I’ll stick with Kendall
-
@whiplash0013_PSN said in Cards you thought you would crush with, but didn’t:
Hank Aaron and Steve Finley. I really like both of their stances and attributes, but I just can't hit with either of them. I just recently replaced Finley with Aaron so he has less than 30AB's right now, but I couldn't hit with him last year either.
That is surprising. Finley is glitch year after year.
-
@mjfc_363_PSN said in Cards you thought you would crush with, but didn’t:
@whiplash0013_PSN said in Cards you thought you would crush with, but didn’t:
Hank Aaron and Steve Finley. I really like both of their stances and attributes, but I just can't hit with either of them. I just recently replaced Finley with Aaron so he has less than 30AB's right now, but I couldn't hit with him last year either.
That is surprising. Finley is glitch year after year.
Yeah, going to give him another go. He is one of the cards that I really looked forward to with this latest program.
-
Mantle. Every year.
But this year will be different!
-
I don't know what happened, but in 30 offline ABs with FOTF Helton, I'm batting .200.
I loved him in prior years. Weird.
-
@Bob_Loblaw1984 said in Cards you thought you would crush with, but didn’t:
Mantle. Every year.
But this year will be different!
Dupe
-
A admin locked this topic on
