Review plays

SDS

Have the review plays more open then just first base. I wanna be able to have them review a play that I was safe at home Instead of out.

SDS

This is a really good idea. Also expand them from the current criteria: include other bases (as suggested) steals, double plays, two outs. Make it so the user can choose when to challenge.

Unlikely though; Ramone said in the pre-16 streams I think it was that this is very time intensive to implement.

SDS

I like the pitch selection at the bottom makes game look more crisp

SDS

Also have mangers get thrown out the game for arguing pitches

SDS

I wanna see more arguing and ejections

SDS

You wanna see more arguing and ejections I suggest watching real baseball cause its unlikely to be added

SDS

@Dartwuff i know right lol but I wanna see pitches get argue and calls on being out and safe get argue to but I rather see reviews though. We need the option to have them review a call at any base.

SDS

Just thinking about it more; the manager challenges don’t really achieve anything apart from holding up gameplay - the plays that are selected are obvious calls which you can see from the first replay so you’re unlikely to be wrong. The end result is the same as if the call was made correctly the first time.

If some on-field calls were deliberately wrong to prompt challenges that would be a different story, but with the replays not being an exact copy of what happened in the first place it’s not really viable.

So I override my earlier comment, at least until replays are overhauled. Maybe that’s why there’s so much work involved in it.

SDS

What I wanna see happen is being able to choose when to challenge instead of the game choosing. It could help players a lot!!!