Favorite LS swing this year?
-
@suntlacrimae50_mlbts said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
Soto, Harper, and Yordan for lefties.
J-Ram and Tre for righties.
Can't hit well with Trout to save my life.
This is online, because offline it really doesn't matter.
Yordan for lefty is very very nice. I approve of this message.
-
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@ericulous1_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@ericulous1_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@ericulous1_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
Harper, Acuna, Albies....best LS swings.
I disagree on Acuna and Albies
I take Story over both even Betts has a better swing. Harper I agree with. Buxton swing is better but lacks vision.
Oh man, Albies hits everything for me. I can't hit with Buxton. Everyone is different.
very true everyone is different, Albies has a good swing but Story hits better for me.What is weird is his LS card hits better than his TN card for me
Oh I've had that happen definitely. And I do love Storys swing for sure.
I think Donaldson will be mine #1 3b until the 99 George Brett comes out.
My best team as far as what I like for swings with the cards I have
C Gary Carter
1B Fielder
2b Story LS/ FOTF Jazz/ Utley
SS T Turner
3B Donaldson
LF Gibson
CF Mantle
RF ClementeTurner has made the the squad. .450 with 2 bombs 4 ribs. Thanks!
-
@hoboadam_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@suntlacrimae50_mlbts said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
Soto, Harper, and Yordan for lefties.
J-Ram and Tre for righties.
Can't hit well with Trout to save my life.
This is online, because offline it really doesn't matter.
Yordan for lefty is very very nice. I approve of this message.
I am not good with Jrams swing but ill try it out in custom practice to see if I can work with it. I cant see the leg kick to well.
-
@mubby_33_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@mubby_33_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
JoRam and Harper for sure. Soto was also solid but I was better with Harper so Harper is still my go to lefty bat off the bench. Gold Will SMith was also a nice surprise. I'm assuming your on a budget or else I would suggest Tatis, Acuna and Trout, however, well worth the cost long term.
I can not hit with Acuna, and I like Turner and Story better than Tatis.
I feel like Acuna and Tatis have similar swings so that makes sense. A lot of it is really personal preference. I will says Tatis just hits bombs. He gets some ridiculous HR animations off of questionable PCI placement. Yeah he strikes out a tons but something about Tatis's quirks that make up for it. I would give him another try and stick with him. He was my second position player I got to P5. Turner is glitchy for sure, but I like him as my swiss army knife on the bench. Im hoping Story takes off and his LS gets some serious upgrades. It is nice that SS is kind of a deep position this year.
The way you feel about Tatis is how I feel about Story he hits questionable HR's for me, I pretty much staying offline this year. I hit good with Tatis to, If I did not have Donaldson at third then I would have Tatis, Turner and Story in the lineup, I have used Tatis LS to help with the Cover Athlete program.
-
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@mubby_33_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@mubby_33_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
JoRam and Harper for sure. Soto was also solid but I was better with Harper so Harper is still my go to lefty bat off the bench. Gold Will SMith was also a nice surprise. I'm assuming your on a budget or else I would suggest Tatis, Acuna and Trout, however, well worth the cost long term.
I can not hit with Acuna, and I like Turner and Story better than Tatis.
I feel like Acuna and Tatis have similar swings so that makes sense. A lot of it is really personal preference. I will says Tatis just hits bombs. He gets some ridiculous HR animations off of questionable PCI placement. Yeah he strikes out a tons but something about Tatis's quirks that make up for it. I would give him another try and stick with him. He was my second position player I got to P5. Turner is glitchy for sure, but I like him as my swiss army knife on the bench. Im hoping Story takes off and his LS gets some serious upgrades. It is nice that SS is kind of a deep position this year.
The way you feel about Tatis is how I feel about Story he hits questionable HR's for me, I pretty much staying offline this year. I hit good with Tatis to, If I did not have Donaldson at third then I would have Tatis, Turner and Story in the lineup, I have used Tatis LS to help with the Cover Athlete program.
I guess I could move Donaldson to 3rd and put Tatis in the there
-
Now if you remove LS from the equation, Finley or AJ Pierzinski have the best LH swings in my opinion. I even used the AJ for the RH swing.
-
Rafael Devers
-
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@mubby_33_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@mubby_33_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
JoRam and Harper for sure. Soto was also solid but I was better with Harper so Harper is still my go to lefty bat off the bench. Gold Will SMith was also a nice surprise. I'm assuming your on a budget or else I would suggest Tatis, Acuna and Trout, however, well worth the cost long term.
I can not hit with Acuna, and I like Turner and Story better than Tatis.
I feel like Acuna and Tatis have similar swings so that makes sense. A lot of it is really personal preference. I will says Tatis just hits bombs. He gets some ridiculous HR animations off of questionable PCI placement. Yeah he strikes out a tons but something about Tatis's quirks that make up for it. I would give him another try and stick with him. He was my second position player I got to P5. Turner is glitchy for sure, but I like him as my swiss army knife on the bench. Im hoping Story takes off and his LS gets some serious upgrades. It is nice that SS is kind of a deep position this year.
The way you feel about Tatis is how I feel about Story he hits questionable HR's for me, I pretty much staying offline this year. I hit good with Tatis to, If I did not have Donaldson at third then I would have Tatis, Turner and Story in the lineup, I have used Tatis LS to help with the Cover Athlete program.
I guess I could move Donaldson to 3rd and put Tatis in the there
I just feel like speed is so important in this game. I usually permit my 1st baseman to be slow and maybe my catcher if he makes up for in with defense and the bat. If you nixed Donaldson, that would give you a super speed infield with Tatis, Turner and Story in there all at the same time. I know he is slow but how is Donaldson's defense?
-
@ibonafidescrub_ said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
Rafael Devers
YES. How could he have lasted this long without being mentioned? Good call.
-
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@mubby_33_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
JoRam and Harper for sure. Soto was also solid but I was better with Harper so Harper is still my go to lefty bat off the bench. Gold Will SMith was also a nice surprise. I'm assuming your on a budget or else I would suggest Tatis, Acuna and Trout, however, well worth the cost long term.
I can not hit with Acuna, and I like Turner and Story better than Tatis.
Last year I killed with the Tatis LS card, this year I am hitting under .250 with him. I hit much better with Turner and Lindor.
-
JRam, Trout and Aaron Judge for me-lots of power the other way
-
I generally only use Tatis and Acuna, sometimes Vlad Jr...I actually don't like using Trout, his plate vision isn't so hot and I honestly, no flex, have the best possible team you could acquire. I also use Lindor's FOTF card and I'm sure his swing is the same as the LS card and I LOVE that card. Also love Ketel Marte's swing.
I have every high end card except Helton, Bumgarner, Story, Biggio, Salmon, Doby, and Jason Bay. I can't stand Frank Thomas' swing. I Also hate Utley's swing, but I like Delgado's swing,, Clemente has a great swing.....so does Mauer, Pujols, also Glaus....But I still hit better with Lindor and Ketel But I also rake with Acuna LS and Tatis LS and you said you didn't like either one of their swings.....
I guess in short, I'd say Lindor, Ketel, Vlad Jr, J-Ram. In the past I have liked Trea's swing but not this year. I also like Soto and Harper's swings. And one final one...honestly, as a hitter, i LOVE Ohtani's swing. He's a beast as a hitter.
-
@capt_awesome34 said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@aam34_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
Looking to change up the squad and get rid of swings that don't work for me. Whos worth looking at or buying?? LF, 1ST, RF, C are the positions i may change. Or any position as I may take a look at their swing. Thanks
Soto always
Soto was my first P5 this year. Likely gets replaced at some point and then it becomes a challenge as LH off the bench. Devers is first off currently and destroys everything consistently. I’ll likely stick with the homer selection, but I’ll question it.
-
@mubby_33_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@mubby_33_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@mubby_33_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
JoRam and Harper for sure. Soto was also solid but I was better with Harper so Harper is still my go to lefty bat off the bench. Gold Will SMith was also a nice surprise. I'm assuming your on a budget or else I would suggest Tatis, Acuna and Trout, however, well worth the cost long term.
I can not hit with Acuna, and I like Turner and Story better than Tatis.
I feel like Acuna and Tatis have similar swings so that makes sense. A lot of it is really personal preference. I will says Tatis just hits bombs. He gets some ridiculous HR animations off of questionable PCI placement. Yeah he strikes out a tons but something about Tatis's quirks that make up for it. I would give him another try and stick with him. He was my second position player I got to P5. Turner is glitchy for sure, but I like him as my swiss army knife on the bench. Im hoping Story takes off and his LS gets some serious upgrades. It is nice that SS is kind of a deep position this year.
The way you feel about Tatis is how I feel about Story he hits questionable HR's for me, I pretty much staying offline this year. I hit good with Tatis to, If I did not have Donaldson at third then I would have Tatis, Turner and Story in the lineup, I have used Tatis LS to help with the Cover Athlete program.
I guess I could move Donaldson to 3rd and put Tatis in the there
I just feel like speed is so important in this game. I usually permit my 1st baseman to be slow and maybe my catcher if he makes up for in with defense and the bat. If you nixed Donaldson, that would give you a super speed infield with Tatis, Turner and Story in there all at the same time. I know he is slow but how is Donaldson's defense?
It good for me, I got him to P4 he has Gold shield Defense. I am not sure what level got him the Gold Shield. I love his swing and power. I use his CA card.
-
@whiplash0013_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
@mubby_33_psn said in Favorite LS swing this year?:
JoRam and Harper for sure. Soto was also solid but I was better with Harper so Harper is still my go to lefty bat off the bench. Gold Will SMith was also a nice surprise. I'm assuming your on a budget or else I would suggest Tatis, Acuna and Trout, however, well worth the cost long term.
I can not hit with Acuna, and I like Turner and Story better than Tatis.
Last year I killed with the Tatis LS card, this year I am hitting under .250 with him. I hit much better with Turner and Lindor.
usually I can not hit with Lindor in past years. I used him a little to complete the Mets Mission and he hit well for me but not enough speed for me at SS.
-
A admin locked this topic on
