All-Star should be the only difficulty for all online content

Let's be honest. It's the only difficulty that is actually fun. What good is a video game if it isn't fun. All the people who praise HOF and legend need to realize they're the minority and that they would have way more fun if they played on All-star.

Very popular opinion: “All star sucks”

@iwhites31_psn said in All-Star should be the only difficulty for all online content:

Let's be honest. It's the only difficulty that is actually fun. What good is a video game if it isn't fun. All the people who praise HOF and legend need to realize they're the minority and that they would have way more fun if they played on All-star.

I disagree.

I partiality agree.
But games would be pretty insane once you get above Wild Card.
Final scores would look like football finals.

Or, and hear me out, it's ok that there are different difficulties since people hate hof and different people hate all-star, so compromise is nessecary

Idk man. Hall of fame is a pain in the [censored] and you are correct, the only people that enjoy It are well above the average player. But the foul balls on allstar are killing me. You can completely guess wrong and move your pci low and away and still foul off a fastball high and in. That is stupid.

A difficultly between All Star and HOF would be nice.

@tossgawd_xbl said in All-Star should be the only difficulty for all online content:

A difficultly between All Star and HOF would be nice.

Or simply make two ranked seasons. One Veteran and Allstar and the other HOF and Legend

All star has too many foul offs and only like 5-10% of players enjoy HOF.

Yeah I hate the flip flop of difficulties when your about to move up. Plus why? No other game does that

All star is ******* TERRIBLE

i feel like the setup rn is pretty good, it scales with ur skill level which makes a lot of sense. the best players playing on anything less than legend would result in unrealistic 30-28 scores which would be annoying but for the new players who r just learning the game veteran/all star make more sense cause its not too hard to hit/pitch

Just eliminate or shrink the outer pci. There is no reason the outer pci should be bigger than the strike zone. That is the issue with Allstar.

This is a terrible idea. All star is the worst game play. I rather play on rookie or legend than all star

No thanks. I’m not looking for games where guys can mash homers 10 feet out of the strike zone.

i'm happy with HOF

I sort of agree with OP. I think there should be casual online ranked seasons and competitive online ranked seasons. Competitive gets better rewards but Casual can get rewards as well and both count for the online grind. Sometimes I just want to watch TV and play (like you can in the current event) but other times I am completely locked in and trying hard. Competitive has two levels HoF and Legend, Casual plays up to Allstar.

@lazy_toast_psn said in All-Star should be the only difficulty for all online content:

@tossgawd_xbl said in All-Star should be the only difficulty for all online content:

A difficultly between All Star and HOF would be nice.

Or simply make two ranked seasons. One Veteran and Allstar and the other HOF and Legend

Nobody even the top 1% would choose HOF LEG to grind when they can smack kids around in Allstar

Good luck pitching on Allstar at times it can be impossible to get good players out that PCI size with 99 players is child’s play .

@joeythebigboss said in All-Star should be the only difficulty for all online content:

Good luck pitching on Allstar at times it can be impossible to get good players out that PCI size with 99 players is child’s play .

Maybe add a level cap.