I know a lot of people are complaining about the new hitting. I see most people have issue with what happens when you square up a hit. My issue is a slight delay. With hitting I'm behind on all fastballs unless I commit way early. On pitching I use the button one and I'm behind by so much, I most stop my cursor very early or I'll get a wild pitch. Is this what everyone else is experiencing? Or could this just be a WiFi lag cause the influx of people cause of the quarantine?
Most likely is input lag. Response time on whatever screen you are using is responsible. I recommend a monitor for online play with around a 5ms response time. 1ms is the best but I think they get a little pricey. Also make sure your internet is running properly. Hope this helps.