Potm Semien or Awards Story?
-
Personally I wouldn’t really consider Grinding the BR program as free you still have to spend a lot of stubs on entry fees + that’s a lot of games you have to grind and win for the cumulative Reward .
-
Trevor Story can ball
speed - power combo - with good defense. Maybe only Honus or Jeter might replace him in my lineup.
-
Awards Series Trevor Story is, for my money, the best card in the game. I've had him for over 200 at-bats and I can safely say that he has zero weaknesses or downsides. He is worth every Stub I paid for him.
For whatever it's worth, these are the five best position player cards in the game, in my humble opinion:
- #! - Trevor Story, SS (Awards Series)
- #2 - Mike Trout, OF (Live Series)
- #3 - Chipper Jones, 3B (Awards Series)
- #4 - Alfonso Soriano, 2B/OF (Milestones Series)
- #5 - Byron Buxton, OF (Monthly Awards Series)
Honorable Mentions: Matt Wieters (Awards), Jim Thome (2nd Half Heroes), Marcus Semien (Monthly Awards)
-
They hit about the same for me. Noticeable difference was defense. Story is a fkin magician man.
-
@bodamescapeplan said in Potm Semien or Awards Story?:
Awards Series Trevor Story is, for my money, the best card in the game. I've had him for over 200 at-bats and I can safely say that he has zero weaknesses or downsides. He is worth every Stub I paid for him.
For whatever it's worth, these are the five best position player cards in the game, in my humble opinion:
- #! - Trevor Story, SS (Awards Series)
- #2 - Mike Trout, OF (Live Series)
- #3 - Chipper Jones, 3B (Awards Series)
- #4 - Alfonso Soriano, 2B/OF (Milestones Series)
- #5 - Byron Buxton, OF (Monthly Awards Series)
Honorable Mentions: Matt Wieters (Awards), Jim Thome (2nd Half Heroes), Marcus Semien (Monthly Awards)
Jackie says sup
-
@kingakp_xbl said in Potm Semien or Awards Story?:
I prefer Story but Simeon hits righties better for me. Have you considered a CAP?
TA 2 mets shortstop is better
-
How would you go about switching the position of your CAP to fit Story into your lineup?
-
Grind a different archetype with the same CAP or start over?
-
@jwkeep__psn said in Potm Semien or Awards Story?:
@kingakp_xbl said in Potm Semien or Awards Story?:
I prefer Story but Simeon hits righties better for me. Have you considered a CAP?
TA 2 mets shortstop is better
Imagine being so wrong...
-
@bbsoli15_psn said in Potm Semien or Awards Story?:
@raesone_psn said in Potm Semien or Awards Story?:
@imdfc_psn said in Potm Semien or Awards Story?:
But Semien is free, so there's that
Story is free as well, if you grind out the BR program.
You keep saying that Story is free, but the amount of time spent to get him is much much longer. So in reality they are not the same cost.
I actually liked the BR grind for Story. Lots of packs along the way, a free Reggie, and an average player like I am gets a premium card.
And.... Story > Semien
-
@arvcpa_psn said in Potm Semien or Awards Story?:
@bbsoli15_psn said in Potm Semien or Awards Story?:
@raesone_psn said in Potm Semien or Awards Story?:
@imdfc_psn said in Potm Semien or Awards Story?:
But Semien is free, so there's that
Story is free as well, if you grind out the BR program.
You keep saying that Story is free, but the amount of time spent to get him is much much longer. So in reality they are not the same cost.
I actually liked the BR grind for Story. Lots of packs along the way, a free Reggie, and an average player like I am gets a premium card.
And.... Story > Semien
Trevor Story beats Semen out if the water.
-
@lazy_toast_psn said in Potm Semien or Awards Story?:
@bodamescapeplan said in Potm Semien or Awards Story?:
Awards Series Trevor Story is, for my money, the best card in the game. I've had him for over 200 at-bats and I can safely say that he has zero weaknesses or downsides. He is worth every Stub I paid for him.
For whatever it's worth, these are the five best position player cards in the game, in my humble opinion:
- #! - Trevor Story, SS (Awards Series)
- #2 - Mike Trout, OF (Live Series)
- #3 - Chipper Jones, 3B (Awards Series)
- #4 - Alfonso Soriano, 2B/OF (Milestones Series)
- #5 - Byron Buxton, OF (Monthly Awards Series)
Honorable Mentions: Matt Wieters (Awards), Jim Thome (2nd Half Heroes), Marcus Semien (Monthly Awards)
Jackie says sup
I didn't target the 42 Series Legends before their price went up so high, so I have no experience using that 99 Jackie. I'd like to get him eventually but I've been happy with Semien lately and I've never liked Robinson's swing in years prior.
-
@codywolfgang_xbl said in Potm Semien or Awards Story?:
Grind a different archetype with the same CAP or start over?
Yea you just switch the archetype and grind it out. I prefer the hawk for SS. I sold Story when I tried my CAP
-
@jwkeep__psn said in Potm Semien or Awards Story?:
@kingakp_xbl said in Potm Semien or Awards Story?:
I prefer Story but Simeon hits righties better for me. Have you considered a CAP?
TA 2 mets shortstop is better
He is definitely decent but I wouldn't say he's better than Story or Simien. To each their own but I wouldn't personally recommend him.
-
A admin locked this topic on
