Who would you pick from the Rare round?

I just bought two of the beach ball packs. First pack was base and I took Posada. Then the second pack I hit on and got the rare round. Now I’m a little stuck of who to take? Leaning towards Ryan or Robert, who would you guys take?

Ryan for sure. Outfield is crowded right now

@KommanderNKeef9 said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

Ryan for sure. Outfield is crowded right now

True and what do you think of the Hornsby card? Not good enough right ?

I just bought Hornsby, he looks really good, just hope the silver fielding isn't too bad. Plus I can use him in the event.

Hornsby is probably the best second baseman on the market, he is the pick imo

@dantheranman said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

I just bought Hornsby, he looks really good, just hope the silver fielding isn't too bad. Plus I can use him in the event.

I hear you but I have Biggio not sure if you do but I don’t think Biggio is still a lot better than Hornsby especially Prestige

@eatyum said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

Hornsby is probably the best second baseman on the market, he is the pick imo

Yea key word on the market tho. I already have Biggio and I’m 10 runs from prestige Biggio. I feel even the base Biggio is better than Hornsby tho. I guess Ryan might be the pick

@Liljayne300 said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

@eatyum said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

Hornsby is probably the best second baseman on the market, he is the pick imo

Yea key word on the market tho. I already have Biggio and I’m 10 runs from prestige Biggio. I feel even the base Biggio is better than Hornsby tho. I guess Ryan might be the pick

Personally, I'm not a fan of Biggio, but to each their own

@eatyum said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

@Liljayne300 said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

@eatyum said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

Hornsby is probably the best second baseman on the market, he is the pick imo

Yea key word on the market tho. I already have Biggio and I’m 10 runs from prestige Biggio. I feel even the base Biggio is better than Hornsby tho. I guess Ryan might be the pick

Personally, I'm not a fan of Biggio, but to each their own

Well does Hornsby being a Cardinal have anything to do with this opinion ?

@Liljayne300 said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

@eatyum said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

@Liljayne300 said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

@eatyum said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

Hornsby is probably the best second baseman on the market, he is the pick imo

Yea key word on the market tho. I already have Biggio and I’m 10 runs from prestige Biggio. I feel even the base Biggio is better than Hornsby tho. I guess Ryan might be the pick

Personally, I'm not a fan of Biggio, but to each their own

Well does Hornsby being a Cardinal have anything to do with this opinion ?

No, I have no emotional attachment to Hornsby, I never saw him play, barely heard him mentioned growing up.

Ask a lot of top players, Hornsby is a god.

@Liljayne300 said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

@dantheranman said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

I just bought Hornsby, he looks really good, just hope the silver fielding isn't too bad. Plus I can use him in the event.

I hear you but I have Biggio not sure if you do but I don’t think Biggio is still a lot better than Hornsby especially Prestige

I have Mantle/Trout done (and all fotf... I'm a completionist addict haha), I doubt he's better... Just gonna use him a bit and I'm expecting to flip for a profit once the pack is gone. Ryan looks fun tho, especially if you need pitching

@dantheranman said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

@Liljayne300 said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

@dantheranman said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

I just bought Hornsby, he looks really good, just hope the silver fielding isn't too bad. Plus I can use him in the event.

I hear you but I have Biggio not sure if you do but I don’t think Biggio is still a lot better than Hornsby especially Prestige

I have Mantle/Trout done (and all fotf... I'm a completionist addict haha), I doubt he's better... Just gonna use him a bit and I'm expecting to flip for a profit once the pack is gone. Ryan looks fun tho, especially if you need pitching

I’m sorry I worded that like an idiot. I meant Biggio is a lot better than Hornsby, do you agree ?

Hornsby and it’s not close for me.

@Liljayne300 said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

@KommanderNKeef9 said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

Ryan for sure. Outfield is crowded right now

True and what do you think of the Hornsby card? Not good enough right ?

No sir I put Hornsby at 2B the second I got him. Got lucky and pulled two rare tiers

@Ur_MomsD_ildo said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

Ur mom

Good one dude. Did you find out If 5th grade will be online or in person yet?

Hornsby's a monster.

I took Ryan and bought Hornsby. I got Sheffield in left now, Hornsby at 3rd and my 89 CAP at 2nd since my 89 CAP catcher was replaced by Posada.

No worries about Sheffield though in left because of his arm and speed and Prestige Mantle in center to offset.

Hornsby would be my 3rd basemen if I had that liberty to choose. That would be one of those tough nut cuttin moments where I’d have to find somewhere for Didi.

Just took hornsby.....ryan was out and Robert's just starting his career so was a no brainer.....

@Liljayne300 said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

@dantheranman said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

@Liljayne300 said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

@dantheranman said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

I just bought Hornsby, he looks really good, just hope the silver fielding isn't too bad. Plus I can use him in the event.

I hear you but I have Biggio not sure if you do but I don’t think Biggio is still a lot better than Hornsby especially Prestige

I have Mantle/Trout done (and all fotf... I'm a completionist addict haha), I doubt he's better... Just gonna use him a bit and I'm expecting to flip for a profit once the pack is gone. Ryan looks fun tho, especially if you need pitching

I’m sorry I worded that like an idiot. I meant Biggio is a lot better than Hornsby, do you agree ?

Hornsby is better than Biggio. Better swing, better contact, better power, just less speed and fielding. Don’t feel obligated to play Biggio because of his price tag

Hornsby is the choice and it’s a no brainer. He’s the best second baseman in the game and they even made him better than last year. Good hitters pick up on Ryan easily and Robert isn’t better than many of the other outfield options.

I ended up going Ryan. I like Biggio and he’s about to be prestiged. Plus this Ryan is great. I dominated with his 92 and this one has outlier and a sinker. Hornsby does look interesting tho

@Liljayne300 said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

@Ur_MomsD_ildo said in Who would you pick from the Rare round?:

Ur mom

Good one dude. Did you find out If 5th grade will be online or in person yet?

I nearly fell outta my chair reading your reply!