Walker or Misual??

SDS

I have Walker currently, but I've been struggling badly with him of late. I'm thinking of selling him for Musial. Any reviews from people whove tried both on who is better?

SDS

I find Walker very very hard to remove from the lineup.

Musial has been good off the bench for a hit. When I start him, he takes a collar.

SDS

If you are talking about starting in the OF, it’s not even close. Walker is an elite defender, Musial is a liability.

SDS

@phillydave35 said in Walker or Misual??:

If you are talking about starting in the OF, it’s not even close. Walker is an elite defender, Musial is a liability.

That's what I was afraid of. Even struggling at the plate walker is a huge plus defensively. Thanks.

SDS

@PhillyRunt44 said in Walker or Misual??:

I have Walker currently, but I've been struggling badly with him of late. I'm thinking of selling him for Musial. Any reviews from people whove tried both on who is better?

Who’s on first?

....what’s at second...

SDS

Only place Musial plays is at first.

SDS

Yeah, I don’t think you can even consider Musial an outfielder...he may be the best first baseman in the game, but not sure you can live with the speed/defense out there.

SDS

Ifb you're talking about right field then there is no comparison you got to keep Walker. If you are talking about a better hitter I would go with Stan but put him at first base. He has that super smooth Lou Gehrig type swing I love it.

SDS

I'm trash with Walker too. Swing is long like Reggie. It's hard to take the diamond defense, arm, and almost 80 speed off the field tho.

SDS

@seannydrama7 said in Walker or Misual??:

Yeah, I don’t think you can even consider Musial an outfielder...he may be the best first baseman in the game, but not sure you can live with the speed/defense out there.

I could put Stan at 1B and move POTM prestige Belli to RF if I sell Walker??

SDS

I have Walker in RF and Stan at 1B. I love smashing baseballs with Stan, truly better than the last 2 years cards.

SDS

@PhillyRunt44 said in Walker or Misual??:

@seannydrama7 said in Walker or Misual??:

Yeah, I don’t think you can even consider Musial an outfielder...he may be the best first baseman in the game, but not sure you can live with the speed/defense out there.

I could put Stan at 1B and move POTM prestige Belli to RF if I sell Walker??

Yes. That’s why I started the Abbot and Costello joke only 1 person got. There was some merit behind the question lol.

I actually moved Big Papi to the bench to see how this thing with Musial goes.

SDS

@wingo18 said in Walker or Misual??:

@PhillyRunt44 said in Walker or Misual??:

@seannydrama7 said in Walker or Misual??:

Yeah, I don’t think you can even consider Musial an outfielder...he may be the best first baseman in the game, but not sure you can live with the speed/defense out there.

I could put Stan at 1B and move POTM prestige Belli to RF if I sell Walker??

Yes. That’s why I started the Abbot and Costello joke only 1 person got. There was some merit behind the question lol.

I actually moved Big Papi to the bench to see how this thing with Musial goes.

I think that's what I'm gonna do. Plus, with the stubs ill save ill put them towards another SP. Looking at either Wood or Hershiser. Thanks for your help!

SDS

Musial hits EVERYTHING hes a very difficult out... and i have not struck out with him yet... although he comes off the bench for me