Commentary

SDS

Please for the love of Baseball can we get the commentary changed. I love the team, but it doesn't work for the game and the way its implemented, it never will. Go back and listen to the commentary the last couple of years of 2K. Go to youtube and watch videos people have made of the game spliced with real world commentary. It completely changes the game. I mostly play now on mute. theres way too much downtime, often times big moments have small reaction and aren't mentioned again. story lines, stats are overlooked. They don't mention injuries and on and on. I wish they could just buy all of the commentary recorded by mlb2k and then hire that team to continue from here on out. This game is near perfect in so many ways, but this HAS to be fixed.

SDS

With the speed of gameplay and variety of outcomes, commentary is probably one of the most difficult things to master in order to give it more of a real feel, like 2k as you mentioned. With that being said, I do agree, they could spice it up a little, especially big moments. Right now, it's all monotone and redundant. Even the home run calls are lame.

SDS

Getting rid of Plesac would be a step in the right direction to having better commentary.

DeRosa can get annoying at times, but he’s much more tolerable than Plesac.

Harold Reynolds will always be the absolute worst though.

SDS

@DriveByTrucker17 said in Commentary:

Getting rid of Plesac would be a step in the right direction to having better commentary.

DeRosa can get annoying at times, but he’s much more tolerable than Plesac.

Harold Reynolds will always be the absolute worst though.

It's almost like all the MLB Network guys are just terrible at commentary. Even in real life i don't like Matt V commentary. My favorite broadcast team is the Mets, I'm not a Mets fan but i like listening to that broadcast team.

SDS

Steve stone harry caray

SDS

One of the biggest mistakes they ever made was getting rid of individual commentary audio sliders. I want to hear the count but not all the painfully repetitive jibber jabber. Regardless of who makes up the commentary team, they need to record at least 10 times the amount of audio dialogue.

SDS

@Sordidum81 said in Commentary:

One of the biggest mistakes they ever made was getting rid of individual commentary audio sliders. I want to hear the count but not all the painfully repetitive jibber jabber. Regardless of who makes up the commentary team, they need to record at least 10 times the amount of audio dialogue.

Yep. One of my biggest pet peeves about the game is not being able to turn on just play-by-play.