Mike Schmidt or Killebrew?

Looking to go after one of these for 3rd base. Mike Schmidt seems like the overall pick because of his solid hitting and defense but Killebrew's hitting looks crazy good. Let me know your thoughts.

I’m wondering same thing

Schmidt at 3rd, Killebrew 1st PH off bench

I have both, and love Schmidt (as a baseball player he was the best 3B I ever saw). That being said, last year and this year I hit below what I should with his cards. Not sure why.

Killebrew is the offensive beast he seems to be, but he's been a bench bat for me while I use Schmidt at 3B. I'm giving Schmidt 100 at bats to turn it around, but it's looking like Killebrew is gonna win that contest at the moment.

Schmidt is unbelievable so far mind you I only played a couple events games, boy hits the ball harder than any other 3rd option I had thus far ie. Chipper / Arenado etc.

I know one thing. I couldn't hit my way out of a paper bag with Killebrew against Ohtani in the Killebrew Moment and that was only on Veteran lol

@TEXAS10PT said in Mike Schmidt or Killebrew?:

I know one thing. I couldn't hit my way out of a paper bag with Killebrew against Ohtani in the Killebrew Moment and that was only on Veteran lol

Moments are like a game of guess who. That is the worst way to rate a card.

@Hikes83 said in Mike Schmidt or Killebrew?:

Schmidt at 3rd, Killebrew 1st PH off bench

This is the correct answer.

Schmidt has a way worst swing so I would go Killebrew for the bat. Schmidt doesn’t have a swing as bad as Sandberg at least

I find Schmidt swing slow IMO .. i struggle with him

Schmidt is the pick, even if Killer has better hitting in some categories the difference in their defense is ridiculous