Mike Schmidt or Killebrew?
- 
I’m wondering same thing 
- 
Schmidt at 3rd, Killebrew 1st PH off bench 
- 
I have both, and love Schmidt (as a baseball player he was the best 3B I ever saw). That being said, last year and this year I hit below what I should with his cards. Not sure why. Killebrew is the offensive beast he seems to be, but he's been a bench bat for me while I use Schmidt at 3B. I'm giving Schmidt 100 at bats to turn it around, but it's looking like Killebrew is gonna win that contest at the moment. 
- 
Schmidt is unbelievable so far mind you I only played a couple events games, boy hits the ball harder than any other 3rd option I had thus far ie. Chipper / Arenado etc. 
- 
I know one thing. I couldn't hit my way out of a paper bag with Killebrew against Ohtani in the Killebrew Moment and that was only on Veteran lol 
- 
@TEXAS10PT said in Mike Schmidt or Killebrew?: I know one thing. I couldn't hit my way out of a paper bag with Killebrew against Ohtani in the Killebrew Moment and that was only on Veteran lol Moments are like a game of guess who. That is the worst way to rate a card. 
- 
@Hikes83 said in Mike Schmidt or Killebrew?: Schmidt at 3rd, Killebrew 1st PH off bench This is the correct answer. 
- 
Schmidt has a way worst swing so I would go Killebrew for the bat. Schmidt doesn’t have a swing as bad as Sandberg at least 
- 
I find Schmidt swing slow IMO .. i struggle with him 
- 
Schmidt is the pick, even if Killer has better hitting in some categories the difference in their defense is ridiculous 
- 
A admin locked this topic on






