Obligatory 'Who do I take' post

Just hit Silver 40. Have the options of choosing AS Rickey, Sig Newhouser, AS McCovey, and Awards Fingers.

Probably down to Fingers or Newhouser.

Rickey could be End Game, but could be replaced of a 99 Griffey comes out.

Don't need McCovey becauae I have either LS Bellinger, Freeman, or Bell there.

Newhouser would be my #2 starter with the rest being Award Kluber, POTM Corbin (may take him out), Prospect Kopech and Manning, then a mix of LS Kershaw, Strasburg, Buehler, or BO Gibson

Finger would lineup with Sig Franco, AS Wood, LS Chapman, PS Morton, TN Amir, LS Ocuna and LS Bettances. (Probably replace Ocuna or Bettances and buy Gagne or Nen to replace the other.

Thoughts?

Ricky Runs down everything, I hit ok with him, He does have some pop in his bat. I hit a lot of singles with him

I’d go Hal considering your rotation isn’t great. Your bullpen will definitely work.

@dbarmonstar Rickey would be a huge upgrade, as I'm running Acuna there. But I think I can wait for him.

@advisory822ant
Will it change your suggestion if I tell you that I mainly play offline and IF I do play H2H, its only if the Event reward is worth it or if I need a decent (4 Stars or More) Daily?

@Psycho__Kinetic said in Obligatory 'Who do I take' post:

@dbarmonstar Rickey would be a huge upgrade, as I'm running Acuna there. But I think I can wait for him.

@advisory822ant
Will it change your suggestion if I tell you that I mainly play offline and IF I do play H2H, its only if the Event reward is worth it or if I need a decent (4 Stars or More) Daily?

I went Rollie when I got to 40, but based on your team I’d go Hal. But if you don’t play online, it’s really just whichever you want to give a try. They’re both great.