All Time Teams - one of the best programs ever released
-
No showdown, no moments, not even an event. It's a decent enough program as long as I don't rush through it. Definitely not extreme though. I'll eventually get it done cause I want Hank Aaron.
-
Extreme is a tough balance - none of us want to do the extreme "hit for the cycle" kinds of challenges. Play a game against cpu on legend is a bit boring, but what else is there?
It would help a bit if the CPU AI were more realistic.
-
I won 4 HOF, 30 Veteran & 3 All Star games so I can either try to win 6 more Extreme games or 4 more Standatd games to finish the Standard program. I need sleep. I think I was half in a daze the last few games. This is a long one.

-
I like the idea of all time teams, and there’s something here, but imo the extreme program should Have the following elements:
-
Repeatable PXP missions for progress (for long haul players to complete over time…used to be 25k PXP for 5 points until it was 40k last year)
-
Normal one-time stat or PXP missions (this program has no missions at all! They could have a mission for some program points for Ks with Maddox or hits with Utley or PXP earned with players from this program)
-
Conquest (some players like CQ and others don’t, but it should be included)
-
Showdown (again, some players like showdown and others don’t, but it should be included)
-
“Real” moments (these whole-game super-moments would be ok if you didn’t have to invest so much time without earning stats and PXP)
-
Vouchers of some kind (could be MINI season vouchers or even some other lofty accomplishment like 762 HR or 1,000 HR legacy that could be collected for progress)
-
Options!!! (This is yet another program that forces players into one narrow path to completion)
I’m sure there are other things I forgot that extreme programs used to have. And even new things like the all time teams could be a part of it (even a main feature), but it should not be the only way to finish the program as it is now, especially since stats and PXP are not even awarded.
-
-
This isn't "The Extreme Program" and was never advertised as such. Its a different concept that has a higher difficulty option.
-
For me this is a fantastic program following the Elly collection. Double the awards series, milestone series, and signature series. It’s a kick in the balls to everyone who jacked up the prices on cards needed for collections in those series (and frankly the opposite is true to those who purchased those cards). If you were like me and stayed patient to see what was coming with these programs we were rewarded with much needed cards to not get F’d by the insane market. Actually going to give a thumbs up to SDS here.
-
@Jeff7407_PSN last year they had a program where they gave away two Gaylord Perry and two Jim Edmonds cards. Both 99’s with different teams and different attributes. I ended getting one of those Gaylord cards to P5. They could’ve made this program similar to that or made it even bigger. Nolan and Maddux def could’ve had 99’s with different teams. Thus program is good, but they always miss the boat.
-
@Teak2112_MLBTS
You might be right that this is not the extreme program, but I wouldn’t put it past the devs at this point that this is the only program with extreme in the name. We’ll see on Friday, because if it doesn’t come out then, it won’t in ‘26 -
I think they are just skipping the extreme program altogether. Its a tough spot for them because 23/24 people cried too easy, but last year probably had low engagement because they didn't give a realistic grind option to go along with it (and it was a general 'just play the game', not something you could actively focus)
I personally wish they would do more turn based conquest maps...not full on extreme but enough to put a little thought into it.
-
Yeah, this isn't technically an "extreme" program like players are used to but I am thinking it is all we get this year.
-
How is this one of the greatest programs of all time again?
-
How is this one of the greatest programs of all time again?
You could read the comments above, even if you don’t agree.
-
Say what you want but beating the stacked team on legend solicited a positive expletive out of my mouth when I hit a homer off Nolan and later against Randy let alone the sigh of relief getting the final out. The nice part of this being a moment is for the short games you can just restart quickly if you don't score in the top of the first. I wish there was pxp and stats too but there is still a positive benefit to aid in completion. The people asking for other ways to complete are being silly at this point. I don't think SDS did a decent job this year but they should give rewards that force people into modes. Otherwise, why have those modes? I enjoy challenging games against the computer but I need to be incentivized to do it because it's not beneficial in modes like mini seasons to sweat it out on a hard difficulty unless I'm rewarded for it more than just extra pxp or xp etc.
-
I’m honestly surprised to see the positive reaction to this. It’s a massive grind, which I like, but not in November. This is months too late. How many people are actually going to grind this out?
No PXP is simply inexcusable.
The benefit of extreme being purely cosmetic is weak. The hardest things in the game should actually be rewarding. Extreme should drop as soon as 99’s roll out, not November.
-
@Dolenz_PSN
Yes, that’s why my suggestions for improvement are based on past extreme program context. If there’s another extreme program, then my comments are moot. I agree that it’s super unlikely that another program with “extreme” in its name happens this year. -
@Teak2112_MLBTS I remember that extreme conquest map with Eddie Murray as a reward, that map is what got me playing conquest. I'm up to Joe Mauer in the extreme program, chipping away I guess.
-
I’m honestly surprised to see the positive reaction to this. It’s a massive grind, which I like, but not in November. This is months too late. How many people are actually going to grind this out?
No PXP is simply inexcusable.
The benefit of extreme being purely cosmetic is weak. The hardest things in the game should actually be rewarding. Extreme should drop as soon as 99’s roll out, not November.
I might be playing it if it had PXP because I still have players who are not there yet.
But the equivalent of 53 Conquest games (Almost the entire US map twice) with no benefit other than the rewards themselves make it a hard sell.
I don't take shortcuts and I play every game out in full (no take a lead and then bunting for outs). That is 10-15 minutes a game? I will say 10 even though the only two I played went into extra innings so they were probably at least 15.
53x10 = 530
So just shy of 9 hours of play with no PXP or Stats. If I got one or both of those I might also get some extra programs down by using players I need PXP with to finish other programs.
-
But what do you want as an extreme reward? Getting double the rewards is a pretty big haul - especially if you need a few cards for the Elly collection. Because I hadn't yet locked in the Elly collection, I was able to make a million stubs selling off other cards (because all the cards you get from this program make those other cards unnecessary)
Im sure some people want exclusive cards as extreme rewards. I wouldn't complain about that - but lots of people would.
At some point, theres no more rewards they can give you. You have all the stuff. There should be another mode to give you reason to use all the rewards - but then people would just be too lazy to do that mode and complain too.
You cant do much if the real complaint people have is - they just dont actually wanna play the game.
-
I'm in Dolenz's camp. I would have probably played this a lot this weekend if I could work towards DeVries or foam finger goals while doing this. But not having the ability to progress in anything besides working towards wheel spins (which are garbage if you dont get the 1:20 or whatever chance for a diamond) kind of took away from my enthusiasm.
-
But what do you want as an extreme reward? Getting double the rewards is a pretty big haul - especially if you need a few cards for the Elly collection. Because I hadn't yet locked in the Elly collection, I was able to make a million stubs selling off other cards (because all the cards you get from this program make those other cards unnecessary)
Im sure some people want exclusive cards as extreme rewards. I wouldn't complain about that - but lots of people would.
At some point, theres no more rewards they can give you. You have all the stuff. There should be another mode to give you reason to use all the rewards - but then people would just be too lazy to do that mode and complain too.
You cant do much if the real complaint people have is - they just dont actually wanna play the game.
I agree here. This was personally fun for me because it gave me reason to use a good lineup that isn't against people online.