Since I’m probably done for the year
-
@rushmore_NSW I would love a madden style theme team style implemented in to mlb the show. I’ve been saying this all year.
-
I know its been said before, but I would love to see some kind of salary cap type ranked mode (separate from regular ranked). Something where you have to use certain players or build a team a certain way. Almost like a BR or the old Events style, but full 9 inning ranked games.
-
Let me throw in something I see as a positive that others do not.
I much prefer the Spotlight programs this year. Not the split between Programs and Packs but the fact that I have finished programs simply by playing with my Cardinals Theme team. Sometimes I may have to do a few moments to complete them, but normal play gets me most of the way there.
I hated past years where you had to work to earn the first card. Then you had to play with that card to earn the second card, then you had to play with that card to earn the 3rd, etc.
-
Let me throw in something I see as a positive that others do not.
I much prefer the Spotlight programs this year. Not the split between Programs and Packs but the fact that I have finished programs simply by playing with my Cardinals Theme team. Sometimes I may have to do a few moments to complete them, but normal play gets me most of the way there.
I hated past years where you had to work to earn the first card. Then you had to play with that card to earn the second card, then you had to play with that card to earn the 3rd, etc.
Yes great call, this has been a solid change.
-
Let me throw in something I see as a positive that others do not.
I much prefer the Spotlight programs this year. Not the split between Programs and Packs but the fact that I have finished programs simply by playing with my Cardinals Theme team. Sometimes I may have to do a few moments to complete them, but normal play gets me most of the way there.
I hated past years where you had to work to earn the first card. Then you had to play with that card to earn the second card, then you had to play with that card to earn the 3rd, etc.
I wish they did more with the optional objectives. I liked the final program each month giving you the extra pack for using the card.
-
Haven't seen this yet. Majority of away online games at Coors or did I miss someone posting that? That and switch hitter meta really made the game stale with lack of diversity.
-
@rushmore_NSW I’ve thought the easiest fix to this would be if say David Ortiz is a jolt captain card. The all ortiz cards for the year should be Red Sox and be captain cards. If that makes sense
-
They need to add a rating system for Ranked Seasons, like where you can use only so many diamonds, golds, silvers, etc. Or a salary cap or a rating cap. A 99-rated superteam is just unrealistic and boring.
Make stadium selection random, so you're not playing in Coors Field for the thousandth time. Or just give every stadium the same elevation, maybe 3,500 feet.
Stop making every card have 125 and 99 everything, and stop recycling the same [censored] cards 500 times.
I mean, how many players do they have in MLB and the minor leagues that they can use?
And stop making every card have Gold Glove defense. Just because a player has a good month or wins Player of the Month doesn't mean his defense goes up with it. His hitting attributes, yes. Everything else, no.
Give players their actual defensive numbers, even if they are 99-rated cards.
Because if you give everyone almost the same attribute ratings, the cards feel the [censored] same.
They need to figure out the 99-rating system. Either speed it up so we get 99-rated cards by the All-Star break, because that's when the best players from every team are getting picked, or slow it way down and let us work our way up to them, so we don't get 99-rated cards until the postseason. Something like that.
-
Negatives
- Cheating at the higher levels (Makes people question the entire system)
- Stub Farming by Bots/Programs
- Chase Packs have the best cards AKA Pay Wall
4. Mini Seasons stats have been broken all year (Unfortunate, because this would be really cool) - BR Rewards have been butchered and No point to Play
- Events are now limited and has just turned into a stat grind
7. Pack odds are ridiculous this year. Even Headliners have maintained their value - Too many of the same card released, especially level 99 cards
9. Legends are an afterthought. They seem to only be released in bunches
10. Way too much focus on Switch Hitters! - 2026 and still no new online modes
- Foul tips might need to be revisited
- Dread Lag still appears to be a thing
- Stadium lag in most MLB parks
- Stealing is this game is a little too easy
- Team Affinities have truly been gutted
- Captains have been left out
This is an awesome list, dude, thank you.
I've highlighted the ones most egregious to me.
On top of that, one that concerns me is ongoing issues with gameplay, difficulties and outcomes.
I can often tell after two swings if i am going to have an good or difficult game, and at that point you're either smashing the cover off everything or incapable of a hit whilst i can destroy the CPU on HoF, then struggle to get a hit on veteran.I get baseball can be like that, but i've never played a game with more russian roulette RNG, whilst at the same time having a lot of very predictable mini outcomes in game (like sudden surges of home runs by the CPU in the 8th or 9th innings to break up perfect games, starters getting hit if they pitch more than one innings in conquest games etc.)
-
2026 and still no new online modes
I would argue that Weekend Classic is a new mode. Sure, it piggybacks off your Ranked levels, but the structure and rewards are different.
If you say that it is not a new mode then you also have to say that DQ is not a new mode since it is just Moments, Showdowns and 3 Inning Conquest games all smashed together.
I also wonder if their reluctance to add more online modes and their decision to make Events short term while Ranked and WC modes are ran separately is because they are trying to keep online players from being spread too thinly. You still want to be matched up quickly against equally skilled opponents but how much harder is that when you have players spread out among 3 or 4 online modes, and many of those players have cross platform matchmaking turned off. That is just speculation on my part though.
-
I joined late in the year when the game was free after not playing for two or three years. I've enjoyed some things and other things reminded me why I quit mid-season in 2023 (got so tired of showdown, mini seasons, the glut of flashbacks compared to legends, and doing new programs for cards that were borderline unusable if you're a player that keeps up every week). My notes from this year:
Positive:
- At least for me as a late season joiner, there was a ton to do. I'm an offline grind/collection player so I like doing stuff that works towards new cards and there was plenty of that
- PXP seemed easier to come by than I remember from 23
- WBC - I imagine it was even more fun earlier in the year when it was new, but I enjoyed that big program and collection
- Collections (actually both pos/neg) - I thought they were good for the most part. But also, it's disappointing that Zobrist was a huge collection reward (and I'm a cub fan). I get that they are doing rewards that are good for the way the game plays, but Zobrist just isn't a big enough name for a huge collection reward imo.
Negatives
- Offline modes - Yeah, I still don't care for mini season or showdown. I know there's only so many ways to play offline but I'd like to see some new modes that are actually fun. Showdown does seem a bit better, but I still don't like it. Those two modes are like my two children, I dislike them both equally. Diamond Quest was new to me and it's...fine. I have nothing against it but don't' love it. I do like conquest, so I like that there's plenty of that.
- Offline hitting - plenty of threads on this but it sure seems like it has been severely nerfed this year. I play this game to chill and unlock cards and enjoy a "mindless" grind and the number of 1-0 games I had against the cpu on lower difficulties really sucked the fun out of that at times.
- Team Affinity/Exchanges - I really missed those things. I'd like to see a return to bigger TAs and have more to do with duplicate cards than quick sell them.
- Legends compared to flashbacks - there continues to be way too much emphasis on flashbacks for my taste. But maybe most players love it so whatever
Overall, for a free game, I got plenty of enjoyment out of it for the last couple of months. But, unless I see some changes I can't see spending money to buy the game and playing a full season again.
