The Definitive Review of MLB the show 25
-
Trolling or not if people can leave negative reviews then Tyler should be allowed to post his review also.
-
@Dolenz_PSN
This isn't a review. This is a statement. Nobody is saying he can’t, either. -
Name a ultimate team mode better or more NMS friendly than Diamond Dynasty.
-
@Talkingben9558_XBL
Doesn’t mean it’s great. Definitely does it make it a 10/10 solely for that reason. We’re comparing the game to previous releases, not other franchises. Yes that statement is true, but it’s irrelevant. -
@Talkingben9558_XBL said in The Definitive Review of MLB the show 25:
Name a ultimate team mode better or more NMS friendly than Diamond Dynasty.
Diamond Dynasty of 2021-2023
-
@Teak2112_MLBTS
2023 was sets and seasons so no
2022 had too few programs, packs were overpowered and collections were far less interesting, and it also had the old hitting engine and display (which was objectively worse I can assure you)
I started in 22 so I cant evaluate 21, but MLB 25 is by far the best MLB the Show that I have ever played. -
For me content is king with gameplay important as well, and 2023 easily beats 2025 in those areas.
But yeah, I couldnt use some cards for longer than 6 weeks. Personally never had issues with finding new cards I wanted to use though. And it was still the best iteration of captains with a guaranteed hitter and pitcher for every theme team plus lots of fun captain cards like the SS one.
-
2023 was better than this sadly. AND THAT DOES NOT MEAN BRINGING BACK SETS AND SEASONS, SDS
-
No PLEASE bring back seasons. By an enormous margin better than these tepid innings. I miss being excited for huge content dumps at the start of a season. I have zero excitement for tomorrow, the 29th is where the actual content looks it might be.
Just leave the expiring cards behind
-
2024 is the only time as a semi casual player that I was ever able to finish the live series collection (albeit in December) so I would probably say that it was the easiest.
-
@TheBigPapa55_PSN
I would understand if you thought the gameplay was better last year, but 23? Anyone else remember perfect flyball outs with 125 power? -
No I don’t tbh
